Articles · Supervisory Capital & SREP
Why the US SCB makes stress-test losses a binding payout trigger, how Eligible Retained Income differs from EU MDA, and how UK PRA Pillar 2A/2B bridges both worlds.
While the EU splits supervisory capital into binding P2R (2.40%) and non-binding P2G (1.50%) around a static 2.50% CCoB, the US Federal Reserve replaces the CCoB with a binding Stress Capital Buffer (SCB). On Rheinburg Americas Holdings Inc., a 3.40% CCAR drawdown plus 0.45% planned dividends produces a 3.85% SCB and an 8.35% binding CET1 trigger.
Both the European Union (ECB/SSM) and the United States (Federal Reserve Board) require large banks to hold substantial CET1 capital above the 4.50% Basel Pillar 1 floor, but they wire stress testing into the capital stack in fundamentally different ways. The EU separates static risk-by-risk deficiencies into a binding Pillar 2 Requirement (P2R) below the static 2.50% Capital Conservation Buffer (CCoB), while placing forward-looking stress-test losses into a non-binding Pillar 2 Guidance (P2G) above the Combined Buffer. By contrast, under 12 CFR 225.8, the US Federal Reserve replaces the static 2.50% CCoB with a dynamic, binding Stress Capital Buffer (SCB) derived directly from the CCAR / DFAST Severely Adverse supervisory stress test, with no separate P2R.
Under 12 CFR 225.8(f)(2)(i)(C), the US Stress Capital Buffer formula is: SCB = max(2.50%, Peak-to-Trough CET1 Decline + 4 Quarters of Planned Common Stock Dividends / Projected RWA in the Minimum CET1 Quarter). On Rheinburg Americas Holdings Inc. (a scaled pro forma comparative benchmark with USD 15,000.00M RWA, assuming stable projected trough RWA equal to starting RWA), starting CET1 is 13.20% (USD 1,980.00M) and the Fed Severely Adverse trough is 9.80%, yielding a 3.40% peak-to-trough decline. Adding four quarters of planned common dividends (USD 67.50M, or 0.45% of trough RWA) produces an SCB of 3.85% and a total binding CET1 requirement of 8.35% (4.50% + 3.85%), leaving 4.85% (USD 727.50M) of headroom.
| Feature | EU SREP (RCB Parent) | UK PRA (Rheinburg UK) | US Fed (Rheinburg Americas) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Binding Pillar 2 Add-on | P2R 2.40% (56.25% CET1) | Pillar 2A 2.60% (56.25% CET1) | None (embedded in SCB) |
| Stress-Test Capital Layer | P2G 1.50% (non-binding) | Net PRA Buffer 0.85% (non-binding) | SCB 3.85% (binding, 2.50% floor) |
| Static CCoB (2.50%) | Yes, part of 4.75% CBR | Yes, part of 4.50% CBR | Replaced by SCB |
| Binding CET1 Payout Trigger | 10.95% (incl. AT1 spillover) | 10.46% (TCR + CBR) | 8.35% (4.50% + SCB) |
| Payout Restriction Base | CRD Art. 141(5) Distributable Profits | CRD/PRA Distributable Profits | Reg Q Eligible Retained Income (ERI) |
If a US bank falls inside its SCB, Regulation Q (12 CFR 217.11) caps payouts at 60%, 40%, 20%, or 0% of Eligible Retained Income (ERI), defined as the greater of (a) four-quarter net income minus distributions or (b) the four-quarter average of net income. For Rheinburg Americas Holdings Inc. (USD 240.00M four-quarter net income and USD 200.00M distributions), the net method yields USD 40.00M, whereas the four-quarter average method yields USD 60.00M, making USD 60.00M the binding ERI and setting a Quartile 4 (60%) cap of USD 36.00M. This averaging rule avoids the abrupt cliff effect present in EU MDA calculations.
1. Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve System, 12 CFR 225.8 (Capital Plans / SCB) and 12 CFR Part 217 (Regulation Q) (verified 2026-11-21).
2. Prudential Regulation Authority (UK), SS31/15 and Statement of Policy on Pillar 2 Capital.
Under 12 CFR 225.8(f)(2)(i)(C), SCB equals the greater of 2.50% or the sum of the bank's peak-to-trough CET1 ratio decline under the Federal Reserve Severely Adverse stress test plus four quarters of planned common stock dividends divided by projected RWA in the minimum CET1 quarter.
The US SCB is binding for distribution restrictions: falling inside the SCB triggers automatic 60%/40%/20%/0% payout caps under Regulation Q. In contrast, EU Pillar 2G is non-binding and sits above the Combined Buffer without triggering automatic MDA restrictions.
Both are non-binding CET1 buffers above the Combined Buffer, but the UK PRA explicitly offsets stress-test losses already captured by CCoB and CCyB (reducing Rheinburg UK Bank plc's 1.75% gross PRA Buffer by 0.90% overlap to 0.85% net).
Test your own bank's P2R split, AT1 shortfall spillover, MDA quartile cap, Normative vs Economic ICAAP, and UK PRA / US SCB stack in the Pillar 2 SREP & MDA Calculator (Excel).
Complete worked computations on Rheinburg Commercial Bank AG (EUR 40,000.00M TREA, 13.90% CET1), covering CRD V P2R/P2G, AT1 spillover, MDA waterfalls, Normative vs Economic ICAAP, UK PRA Pillar 2A/2B, and US CCAR SCB.