Articles · Supervisory Capital & SREP
Step-by-step stacking of TSCR, CBR, OCR, AT1 shortfall spillover, P2G bucketing, and Article 141 MDA quartile caps.
Under CRD V Article 104a(4), banks can meet Pillar 2R with 56.25% CET1, 18.75% AT1, and 25.00% Tier 2. Yet if actual AT1 falls below 1.50% + 18.75% of P2R, CET1 must fill the gap before counting toward the Combined Buffer. On Rheinburg Commercial Bank AG (EUR 40,000.00M TREA), a 0.35% AT1 shortfall raises the effective MDA trigger from 10.60% to 10.95%, cutting binding MDA headroom from 3.30% to 2.95% (EUR 1,180.00M).
Under CRD V Articles 104a, 104b, 128, and 141, a Eurozone bank's capital stack builds from the bottom up. First come the Pillar 1 minimums (4.50% CET1, 6.00% Tier 1, 8.00% Total Capital). Immediately on top sits the binding Pillar 2 Requirement (P2R), which under Article 104a(4) must be met at least 56.25% with CET1 and at least 75.00% with Tier 1 (allowing up to 18.75% AT1 and 25.00% Tier 2). Pillar 1 plus P2R forms the Total SREP Capital Requirement (TSCR). On top of TSCR sits the Combined Buffer Requirement (CBR), met 100% with CET1 (CCoB + CCyB + G-SII/O-SII + SyRB), creating the Overall Capital Requirement (OCR). Finally, non-binding Pillar 2 Guidance (P2G) sits above CBR in 100% CET1 and does not trigger automatic MDA restrictions.
Consider Rheinburg Commercial Bank AG (EUR 40,000.00M TREA, EUR 5,560.00M CET1 at 13.90%, EUR 640.00M AT1 at 1.60%, and EUR 1,080.00M Tier 2 at 2.70%). Its SREP P2R is 2.40% (1.35% CET1, 0.45% AT1, 0.60% Tier 2), giving a TSCR of 5.85% CET1, 7.80% Tier 1, and 10.40% Total Capital. Adding its 4.75% CBR produces a nominal CET1 OCR of 10.60%.
However, RCB's AT1 bucket capacity is 1.95% (1.50% Pillar 1 + 0.45% P2R), whereas actual AT1 is only 1.60%. That 0.35% (EUR 140.00M) shortfall must be filled by CET1 before CET1 counts toward the CBR, and RCB's 0.10% Tier 2 surplus cannot offset it.
| Capital Stack Component | CET1 (% TREA) | Tier 1 (% TREA) | Total Cap (% TREA) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Pillar 1 Minimum (CRR Art. 92) | 4.50% | 6.00% | 8.00% |
| Pillar 2 Requirement (P2R, Art. 104a) | 1.35% | 1.80% | 2.40% |
| Total SREP Capital Requirement (TSCR) | 5.85% | 7.80% | 10.40% |
| Combined Buffer Requirement (CBR) | 4.75% | 4.75% | 4.75% |
| Nominal OCR (TSCR + CBR) | 10.60% | 12.55% | 15.15% |
| AT1 Shortfall Spillover into CET1 | 0.35% | 0.00% | 0.00% |
| Effective MDA Trigger / Binding Headroom | 10.95% / 2.95% | 12.55% / 2.95% | 15.15% / 3.05% |
Key insight: Issuing EUR 140.00M of AT1 at a 7.00% coupon (EUR 9.80M/year pre-tax) completely eliminates the 0.35% spillover, dropping RCB's effective MDA trigger from 10.95% back to 10.60% and unlocking +EUR 140.00M of immediate MDA headroom.
When a bank breaches its effective OCR, CRD Article 141 restricts common dividends, variable remuneration, and AT1 coupons to a percentage of distributable profits based on the remaining CBR quartile: 60% in Q4 (>75% to <100% of CBR; >=100% is compliant with no MDA cap), 40% in Q3 (>50% to 75%), 20% in Q2 (>25% to 50%), and 0% in Q1 (<=25%). In Year 2 of RCB's Adverse scenario, CET1 drops to 9.55% against an effective OCR of 11.37% (61.68% of CBR met), triggering Quartile 3 (40% factor) and capping total distributions at EUR 168.00M on an illustrative EUR 420.00M distributable profits base.
1. Directive (EU) 2019/878 (CRD V), Articles 104a, 104b, 128, 141, 141a, and 142 (verified 2026-11-21).
2. European Banking Authority (EBA), Guidelines on common procedures and methodologies for SREP (EBA/GL/2022/03).
Pillar 2R (Article 104a) is a binding capital requirement sitting below the Combined Buffer; breaching it or the buffer above it triggers automatic MDA payout restrictions. Pillar 2G (Article 104b) is a non-binding supervisory expectation sitting above the Combined Buffer in 100% CET1 and does not trigger automatic MDA restrictions.
Under CRD V Articles 141 and 141a, CET1 must satisfy Pillar 1 (4.50%) plus P2R CET1 (56.25% of P2R) plus any shortfall in AT1 (below 1.50% + 18.75% of P2R) or Tier 2 (below 2.00% + 25.00% of P2R) before counting toward the CBR. Binding MDA headroom always equals the minimum of CET1, Tier 1, and Total Capital headrooms above OCR.
When CET1 falls inside the Combined Buffer (below 100% of CBR), distributions are capped at 60% of distributable profits in Q4 (>75% to <100% of CBR met), 40% in Q3 (>50% to 75%), 20% in Q2 (>25% to 50%), and 0% in Q1 (<=25%).
Test your own bank's P2R split, AT1 shortfall spillover, MDA quartile cap, Normative vs Economic ICAAP, and UK PRA / US SCB stack in the Pillar 2 SREP & MDA Calculator (Excel).
Complete worked computations on Rheinburg Commercial Bank AG (EUR 40,000.00M TREA, 13.90% CET1), covering CRD V P2R/P2G, AT1 spillover, MDA waterfalls, Normative vs Economic ICAAP, UK PRA Pillar 2A/2B, and US CCAR SCB.