Articles · Supervisory Capital & SREP

Pillar 2R, Pillar 2G, and MDA Trigger Calculation: CRD V Stacking and AT1 Spillover

Step-by-step stacking of TSCR, CBR, OCR, AT1 shortfall spillover, P2G bucketing, and Article 141 MDA quartile caps.

Under CRD V Article 104a(4), banks can meet Pillar 2R with 56.25% CET1, 18.75% AT1, and 25.00% Tier 2. Yet if actual AT1 falls below 1.50% + 18.75% of P2R, CET1 must fill the gap before counting toward the Combined Buffer. On Rheinburg Commercial Bank AG (EUR 40,000.00M TREA), a 0.35% AT1 shortfall raises the effective MDA trigger from 10.60% to 10.95%, cutting binding MDA headroom from 3.30% to 2.95% (EUR 1,180.00M).

1. How P2R, CBR, and P2G stack under CRD V

Under CRD V Articles 104a, 104b, 128, and 141, a Eurozone bank's capital stack builds from the bottom up. First come the Pillar 1 minimums (4.50% CET1, 6.00% Tier 1, 8.00% Total Capital). Immediately on top sits the binding Pillar 2 Requirement (P2R), which under Article 104a(4) must be met at least 56.25% with CET1 and at least 75.00% with Tier 1 (allowing up to 18.75% AT1 and 25.00% Tier 2). Pillar 1 plus P2R forms the Total SREP Capital Requirement (TSCR). On top of TSCR sits the Combined Buffer Requirement (CBR), met 100% with CET1 (CCoB + CCyB + G-SII/O-SII + SyRB), creating the Overall Capital Requirement (OCR). Finally, non-binding Pillar 2 Guidance (P2G) sits above CBR in 100% CET1 and does not trigger automatic MDA restrictions.

2. Worked Example: The AT1 Shortfall Spillover Trap

Consider Rheinburg Commercial Bank AG (EUR 40,000.00M TREA, EUR 5,560.00M CET1 at 13.90%, EUR 640.00M AT1 at 1.60%, and EUR 1,080.00M Tier 2 at 2.70%). Its SREP P2R is 2.40% (1.35% CET1, 0.45% AT1, 0.60% Tier 2), giving a TSCR of 5.85% CET1, 7.80% Tier 1, and 10.40% Total Capital. Adding its 4.75% CBR produces a nominal CET1 OCR of 10.60%.

However, RCB's AT1 bucket capacity is 1.95% (1.50% Pillar 1 + 0.45% P2R), whereas actual AT1 is only 1.60%. That 0.35% (EUR 140.00M) shortfall must be filled by CET1 before CET1 counts toward the CBR, and RCB's 0.10% Tier 2 surplus cannot offset it.

Capital Stack ComponentCET1 (% TREA)Tier 1 (% TREA)Total Cap (% TREA)
Pillar 1 Minimum (CRR Art. 92)4.50%6.00%8.00%
Pillar 2 Requirement (P2R, Art. 104a)1.35%1.80%2.40%
Total SREP Capital Requirement (TSCR)5.85%7.80%10.40%
Combined Buffer Requirement (CBR)4.75%4.75%4.75%
Nominal OCR (TSCR + CBR)10.60%12.55%15.15%
AT1 Shortfall Spillover into CET10.35%0.00%0.00%
Effective MDA Trigger / Binding Headroom10.95% / 2.95%12.55% / 2.95%15.15% / 3.05%

Key insight: Issuing EUR 140.00M of AT1 at a 7.00% coupon (EUR 9.80M/year pre-tax) completely eliminates the 0.35% spillover, dropping RCB's effective MDA trigger from 10.95% back to 10.60% and unlocking +EUR 140.00M of immediate MDA headroom.

3. MDA Quartiles and Distribution Waterfall

When a bank breaches its effective OCR, CRD Article 141 restricts common dividends, variable remuneration, and AT1 coupons to a percentage of distributable profits based on the remaining CBR quartile: 60% in Q4 (>75% to <100% of CBR; >=100% is compliant with no MDA cap), 40% in Q3 (>50% to 75%), 20% in Q2 (>25% to 50%), and 0% in Q1 (<=25%). In Year 2 of RCB's Adverse scenario, CET1 drops to 9.55% against an effective OCR of 11.37% (61.68% of CBR met), triggering Quartile 3 (40% factor) and capping total distributions at EUR 168.00M on an illustrative EUR 420.00M distributable profits base.

4. Sources

1. Directive (EU) 2019/878 (CRD V), Articles 104a, 104b, 128, 141, 141a, and 142 (verified 2026-11-21).
2. European Banking Authority (EBA), Guidelines on common procedures and methodologies for SREP (EBA/GL/2022/03).

Frequently asked questions

What is the difference between Pillar 2R and Pillar 2G?

Pillar 2R (Article 104a) is a binding capital requirement sitting below the Combined Buffer; breaching it or the buffer above it triggers automatic MDA payout restrictions. Pillar 2G (Article 104b) is a non-binding supervisory expectation sitting above the Combined Buffer in 100% CET1 and does not trigger automatic MDA restrictions.

How does an AT1 shortfall affect the MDA trigger?

Under CRD V Articles 141 and 141a, CET1 must satisfy Pillar 1 (4.50%) plus P2R CET1 (56.25% of P2R) plus any shortfall in AT1 (below 1.50% + 18.75% of P2R) or Tier 2 (below 2.00% + 25.00% of P2R) before counting toward the CBR. Binding MDA headroom always equals the minimum of CET1, Tier 1, and Total Capital headrooms above OCR.

What are the four CRD V MDA quartile percentages?

When CET1 falls inside the Combined Buffer (below 100% of CBR), distributions are capped at 60% of distributable profits in Q4 (>75% to <100% of CBR met), 40% in Q3 (>50% to 75%), 20% in Q2 (>25% to 50%), and 0% in Q1 (<=25%).

Free Excel calculator

Test your own bank's P2R split, AT1 shortfall spillover, MDA quartile cap, Normative vs Economic ICAAP, and UK PRA / US SCB stack in the Pillar 2 SREP & MDA Calculator (Excel).

The Pillar 2 ICAAP and SREP Handbook

Complete worked computations on Rheinburg Commercial Bank AG (EUR 40,000.00M TREA, 13.90% CET1), covering CRD V P2R/P2G, AT1 spillover, MDA waterfalls, Normative vs Economic ICAAP, UK PRA Pillar 2A/2B, and US CCAR SCB.

DRM-free PDF, $19.99 → · Paperback, $32.99 · Book page

Also on this site