Articles · UK Corporate Interest Restriction

UK CIR Fixed Ratio vs. Group Ratio Method: Complete Worked Example Under TIOPA 2010

How QNGIE related-party exclusions, the ANGIE and QNGIE debt caps, and the Group Ratio election change cash UK Corporation Tax.

When a UK corporate group's Aggregate Net Tax-Interest Expense (ANTIE) exceeds the £2.00m de minimis threshold under TIOPA 2010 s. 392, the reporting company faces an immediate strategic election: accept the default Fixed Ratio Method (FRM) under s. 397 or elect the Group Ratio Method (GRM) under s. 398 and Schedule 7A paragraph 13. The wrong choice can cost hundreds of thousands of pounds in unnecessary current Corporation Tax.

1. The Statutory Formulas Side by Side

Under the Fixed Ratio Method (s. 397), a worldwide group's Basic Interest Allowance equals the lower of 30% of UK Aggregate Tax-EBITDA and the Fixed Ratio Debt Cap (Adjusted Net Group-Interest Expense, or ANGIE, plus any 1-year excess debt cap brought forward from the prior period under s. 400).

Under the Group Ratio Method (ss. 398-399), the 30% statutory cap is replaced by the group's actual worldwide third-party leverage ratio: Qualifying Net Group-Interest Expense (QNGIE) divided by Worldwide Group-EBITDA, capped at 100%. That percentage is applied to UK Aggregate Tax-EBITDA, subject to the Group Ratio Debt Cap (QNGIE plus any excess debt cap brought forward under s. 400(2)).

The critical friction point between ANGIE and QNGIE is TIOPA 2010 s. 414. While ANGIE includes related-party interest expense recognized in consolidated financial statements, QNGIE strips out three categories of interest: (1) interest on related-party debt (under the 25% investment, acting-together, and related-party guarantee rules in ss. 462-472), (2) results-dependent securities such as profit-participating loans, and (3) perpetual or equity notes with terms exceeding 50 years.

2. Worked Example: Thamesbridge Group (FY2025)

Consider Thamesbridge Infrastructure & Industrial Group plc in FY2025 following a debt-funded acquisition. UK ANTIE rises to £16.50m, UK Aggregate Tax-EBITDA is £28.00m, and the group brings forward £3.00m of unused interest allowance from FY2024. Consolidated IFRS Net Group-Interest Expense (NGIE) is £17.10m, plus £0.90m of capitalized interest add-back under s. 413, yielding ANGIE of £18.00m. However, £2.50m of shareholder loan interest and £0.50m of results-dependent interest must be stripped out under s. 414, leaving QNGIE of £15.00m against Worldwide Group-EBITDA of £42.00m.

Computation StepFixed Ratio MethodGroup Ratio Method
UK Aggregate Net Tax-Interest Expense (ANTIE)£16.50m£16.50m
UK Aggregate Tax-EBITDA£28.00m£28.00m
Applicable Ratio (30% vs. QNGIE / Group-EBITDA)30.00%35.71%
EBITDA-Based Allowance£8.40m£10.00m
Debt Cap (ANGIE + B/F vs. QNGIE)£18.00m£15.00m
Basic Interest Allowance (Lower of EBITDA Cap & Debt Cap)£8.40m£10.00m
Add: Brought-Forward Unused Allowance (FY2024)£3.00m£3.00m
Total Interest Capacity£11.40m£13.00m
Total Disallowed Tax-Interest Expense£5.10m£3.50m
Cash UK Corporation Tax Impact (at 25%)£1.28m£0.88m

3. Key Takeaways for UK Tax Directors

Even after losing £3.00m of related-party and results-dependent interest from QNGIE, electing GRM boosts Thamesbridge's Basic Interest Allowance from £8.40m to £10.00m, cutting the FY2025 disallowance by £1.60m and saving £0.40m in current UK Corporation Tax. Under TIOPA 2010 s. 400(4)-(7), GRM also generates an excess debt cap carry-forward into FY2026 of £3.50m (capped at the FY2025 total disallowed amount of £3.50m plus nil brought forward), raising the FY2026 Fixed Ratio Debt Cap to £19.50m. Remember that the GRM election must be made in a valid full Interest Restriction Return within 12 months (or revised return within 36 months) of the end of the period of account.

Run your own FRM vs. GRM comparison in Excel

Download the free unlocked UK CIR Disallowance Calculator with a 0/1 FRM/GRM toggle, automatic s. 414 QNGIE adjustments, and 10 live control checks.

Download the free Excel calculator →

Complete coverage in The UK Corporate Interest Restriction Handbook

Chapters 5, 6, and 7 walk through ANGIE/QNGIE reconciliations, related-party guarantee traps (s. 466), and alternative calculation elections (ss. 422-427).

Read about the handbook →

Next: UK CIR Public Infrastructure Exemption (PIE): Eligibility, Trade-Offs, and Worked Calculation

Also read: UK CIR Unused Interest Allowance Carry-Forward and Reactivation Rules Explained