Articles

Which transfer pricing method should you use?

The one that gives the most reliable measure on the facts, under the best method rule; for routine distributors and manufacturers that is often the comparable profits method.

US rules list six methods for goods: comparable uncontrolled price, resale price, cost plus, comparable profits, profit split and an unspecified method. None has priority: the best method rule picks the one that gives the most reliable measure on the facts. In the worked case below, the group sets aside CUP and resale price and tests each distributor on operating margin and its manufacturer on markup on total costs.

Worked in full in The Transfer Pricing Professional by Julian R. Sterling.Get the DRM-free PDF, $19.99 →or the paperback

Free: the transfer pricing benchmark template in Excel, which computes the interquartile range, the median and the true-up by the counting rule of the regulation.

The six methods for goods

For a transfer of tangible property between related companies, 26 CFR 1.482-3(a) lists six methods. The services, loans and intangibles have their own sections, but the logic is the same.

26 CFR 1.482-3(a); the third column is a reading aid, not a ranking.
MethodWhat it comparesWhere it tends to fit
Comparable uncontrolled price (CUP)The price itself, against the same goods sold between independent partiesCommodities, or the same product sold to third parties on the same terms
Resale priceThe reseller’s gross marginDistributors, when the comparables’ gross margins are reliable
Cost plusThe producer’s gross markup on costsSimple manufacturing or assembly, with costs classed the same way
Comparable profits (CPM)An operating profit indicator of the tested partyRoutine distributors, manufacturers and service providers
Profit splitHow the combined profit is dividedBoth sides contribute valuable, unique assets
Unspecified methodAny reliable measure not listed aboveWhen none of the five fits the facts

The best method rule

There is no fixed order. Under 26 CFR 1.482-1(c)(1), the arm’s length result is the one given by the method that, on the facts, provides the most reliable measure; no method is always more reliable than another, and a method can be used without first proving the others inapplicable. The catch is in the last clause: if another method is later shown to be more reliable, that one must be used. The file therefore has to say why each method was set aside, not only why the chosen one works.

Worked example: a group with three foreign affiliates

Harnwick Instruments, the fictional US group of the book, makes industrial sensors. Two limited-risk distributors buy from the parent and resell abroad; a contract manufacturer produces for the parent; the parent owns the technology.

In the first year the results were: Harnwick Asia 3.53 percent, inside its range; the manufacturer 6.5 percent on total costs, inside a range of 5.16 to 7.76 percent; Harnwick Europe 0.91 percent, below a range of 2.44 to 4.18 percent.

The trap: a method is not a price policy. Harnwick Europe bought at a price fixed for the year at 74.0 percent of its net sales. When sales came in below budget and costs above, nothing brought the margin back, and the result fell 2.13 percentage points short of the median. The method tests the result; the policy, with a year-end true-up, is what keeps it inside the range.

Choosing the profit level indicator

Under CPM, the indicator has to measure the tested party’s returns reliably. 26 CFR 1.482-5(b)(4) names the return on capital employed and financial ratios such as operating profit to sales and gross profit to operating expenses (the Berry ratio), and warns that financial ratios need closer functional comparability. A distributor with few assets is usually measured on sales; a manufacturer working for one customer, on its costs. Whatever the choice, the comparables are measured the same way, over the same kind of years.

What the method memo should contain

Sources

  1. 26 CFR 1.482-1 (Cornell LII), read 17 November 2026
  2. 26 CFR 1.482-3 (Cornell LII), read 17 November 2026
  3. 26 CFR 1.482-5 (Cornell LII), read 17 November 2026

Rules checked on 17 November 2026 in the text of the regulations. US federal rules only, illustrative, and not tax or legal advice. The group in the examples is fictional and its figures are teaching assumptions.

Questions readers ask

Is there a hierarchy of transfer pricing methods in the US?

No. Under 26 CFR 1.482-1(c)(1) there is no strict priority; the method that gives the most reliable measure on the facts applies, and a more reliable method shown later must be used.

What is the difference between CPM and TNMM?

Both test an operating profit indicator of one party against comparable companies. CPM is the name in the US regulations; TNMM is the name used in the OECD guidance followed by many other countries.

Who should be the tested party?

Under 26 CFR 1.482-5(b)(2)(i), the participant whose results can be verified with the most reliable data and the fewest adjustments, usually the least complex one, without valuable intangibles.

When is a profit split used?

When both sides make valuable, unique contributions that independent comparables cannot capture, so that no one-sided test is reliable.

Read the whole book

This article is one calculation from The Transfer Pricing Professional, a practitioner’s guide to the work of a transfer pricing manager: the arm’s length principle, the functional analysis, the choice of method, benchmarking studies, the year-end true-up, services, loans and royalties, intercompany agreements, documentation, audits and the mutual agreement procedure.

Also on this site