Compare the purchase order, the receiving report and the invoice. Split any difference into quantity and price, test it against your tolerance, and send each part to the person who can fix it.
A three-way match compares the purchase order, the receiving report and the invoice before payment. In the worked case, an invoice for $9,408.00 meets a receipt worth $9,047.50 at the PO price. The $360.50 difference splits into a $196.00 quantity variance and a $164.50 price variance, and the line fails a tolerance of the lower of 2% and $50.
Worked in full in The Accounts Payable Handbook by Julian R. Sterling, with every figure reproduced in a free workbook.Get the PDF, $19.99 →or the paperback
The case is a fictional manufacturer, Marlow Precision Products, buying steel blanks from a distributor, Kessler Steel Service.
| Document | Quantity | Unit price | Value |
|---|---|---|---|
| Purchase order | 2,400 | 3.85 | 9,240.00 |
| Receiving report | 2,350 | 3.85 | 9,047.50 |
| Invoice | 2,400 | 3.92 | 9,408.00 |
What the company owes is what it received, at the price it agreed: 2,350 x $3.85 = $9,047.50. The invoice is $360.50 higher.
A total difference does not tell anyone what to fix. Split it:
Check: $196.00 + $164.50 = $360.50.
The company's policy passes a price variance within the lower of 2% and $50 per line, and allows no tolerance for billing more than was received. The price variance is 1.82% of the PO price, inside 2%, but $164.50 is above $50, so the line holds. The quantity variance holds on its own.
Why the lower of a percentage and an amount? A percentage alone lets large lines through with large absolute differences; an amount alone stops thousands of small lines for trivial ones. The combination catches what matters both ways.
The supplier confirmed the short shipment and issued a credit memo for 50 units, and accepted the PO price. The company paid $9,047.50. Accounts payable did not change the purchase order or the receipt to force the match; each was corrected, or confirmed, by the department that owns it.
In March 2026 the company received 4,050 invoices, 3,159 of them against purchase orders. 2,243 matched at the first pass, a rate of 71.0%. The 916 exceptions broke down into 338 price, 247 quantity, 214 with no receipt in the system, 69 against closed or fully consumed orders and 48 other. Most were fixed upstream: receipts entered before the truck leaves the dock, prices updated on open orders, alerts on blanket orders.
Free Excel template: Accounts Payable Workbook (three-way match, discounts, DPO, accruals, duplicates, Form 1099 and the automation case).
Also on this site: DPO, calculated three ways · finding duplicate payments.
A two-way match compares the invoice with the purchase order. A three-way match adds the receiving report, so the company pays only for what it actually received. A four-way match adds an inspection or quality acceptance record.
Many companies use the lower of a percentage and a fixed amount per line for price, approved by the controller, and no tolerance for billing more than was received. Review tolerances every year against the variances they let through.
No. AP identifies and routes the exception; purchasing corrects the order and receiving corrects the receipt. Otherwise the match stops being a control.
Usually with a two-way match plus a confirmation, recorded in the system by the requester, that the service was performed.
Sources: IRS instructions for Forms 1099, Nacha Operating Rules, FASB ASU 2022-04 (as cited in the text). Figures computed by the author's model and checked on 18 November 2026. Education only, not accounting, legal or tax advice.
This article is one calculation from The Accounts Payable Handbook. The book follows one AP team through a year, from the purchase order to the 1099 season, and every figure it prints is a live formula in the free workbook.
Get the PDF edition, $19.99 Paperback · Free companion files