Three routes to the same capability cost different amounts and fail in different ways. Weight each by its chance of working before comparing the present values.
A company wants a capability that would add $30m a year of cash flow. Built in-house it costs $40m, takes three years and works 60% of the time; bought it costs $120m plus $15m of integration; licensed from a partner it costs $12m up front and half the cash flow for six years. At a 10% discount rate the risk-weighted values are $32.3m to build, $23.1m to buy and $38.5m to partner. Without the weighting, building looks best at $76.2m.
| Item | Build | Buy | Partner |
|---|---|---|---|
| Up-front cost | none | 120 | 12 |
| Spend after year 0 | 15, 15 and 10 in years 1 to 3 | 15 of integration in year 1 | none |
| Cash flow to the company | $30m a year, years 4 to 10 | $30m a year, years 1 to 10 | $15m a year, years 2 to 7 |
| Chance it works | 60% | 85% | 85% |
| Discount rate | 10% | 10% | 10% |
The partner takes half the cash flow and the licence ends after year 7, when the company would have to build or buy a replacement. A failed build still costs all of its spend; a failed purchase still costs its price. That asymmetry is why the chance of success belongs in the comparison.
Build: spend = 15 ÷ 1.10 + 15 ÷ 1.102 + 10 ÷ 1.103 = $33.5m; cash flow = 30 for years 4 to 10 = $109.7m
Buy: cash flow = 30 for years 1 to 10 = $184.3m; integration = 15 ÷ 1.10 = $13.6m
Partner: cash flow = 15 for years 2 to 7 = $59.4m
Excel: =NPV(10%,0,0,0,30,30,30,30,30,30,30) for the build cash flow
Value = chance × PV of cash flow − certain costs
Build = 0.60 × 109.7 − 33.5 = $32.3m
Buy = 0.85 × 184.3 − 120.0 − 13.6 = $23.1m
Partner = 0.85 × 59.4 − 12.0 = $38.5m
| Route | If it works | Risk-weighted |
|---|---|---|
| Build | 76.2 | 32.3 |
| Buy | 50.7 | 23.1 |
| Partner | 47.4 | 38.5 |
If every route worked, building would lead at $76.2m, ahead of buying at $50.7m and partnering at $47.4m. Once the chances are applied the order is reversed: partnering leads by $6.2m over building and $15.4m over buying, because it puts almost no money at risk before the capability exists.
Build overtakes partner when chance × 109.7 − 33.5 = 38.5
Chance = (38.5 + 33.5) ÷ 109.7 = 65.6%
Buy overtakes partner when 0.85 × 184.3 − 13.6 − price = 38.5
Price = $104.6m
| Case | Build | Buy | Partner |
|---|---|---|---|
| Base case | 32.3 | 23.1 | 38.5 |
| Build works 75% of the time | 48.8 | 23.1 | 38.5 |
| Target bought for $100m | 32.3 | 43.1 | 38.5 |
| Licence runs ten years (years 2 to 10) | 32.3 | 23.1 | 54.8 |
Each change reorders the routes. At 75% the build wins, at $100m the purchase wins, and a longer licence widens the partner's lead to $22.5m over the build.
Discount each route's cash flows, multiply the cash flow by its chance of working, and subtract the costs that are paid regardless. Here that gives $32.3m, $23.1m and $38.5m.
In this example when the in-house project works more than 65.6% of the time. At 60% the build is worth $6.2m less.
Its price and integration cost, $133.6m in present value, are paid whether or not the capability delivers. A 15% failure rate removes $27.7m of value.
The free companion files for The Corporate Development Professional rebuild a fictional acquisition's standalone value, synergies, walk-away price, accretion and return on capital with live formulas. The capability in this article is invented and is not in them. No account and no email address.
Not on Amazon: 36 paperbacks by Julian R. Sterling on how to read the documents, printed on demand and shipped worldwide. Browse the bookshop →
Reading guide: corporate finance, valuation and markets → · All 1908 articles →