Articles

Severance damages: how they are taxed

Severance damages are not part of the award: they reduce the basis of the land you keep, and only the excess over that basis is a gain.

Severance damages pay for the loss in value of the part of a parcel the owner keeps. Net of their share of the fees, they first reduce the basis of that remaining land; only the excess is a gain, which section 1033 lets the owner postpone with the gain on the part taken. In the example, $95,000 of net severance damages against a basis of $60,000 gives $35,000 of gain.

Worked in full in The Involuntary Conversion Handbook by Julian R. Sterling.Get the DRM-free PDF, $19.99 →or the paperback

Free: the section 1033 replacement workbook in Excel: gain realized, recognized and postponed, basis of the replacement and the end of the period, plus the condemnation worksheet of Publication 544 line by line, with live formulas.

What severance damages are

When an agency takes part of a parcel, it often pays twice: an award for the part taken, and severance damages for the loss in value of the part the owner keeps, for example because the remaining land loses frontage or access. Publication 544 (2025) treats the two payments differently. The award for the part taken is the proceeds of the condemned property. Severance damages are not: they are compensation for damage to property the owner still holds, and they first reduce its basis.

The settlement papers matter. Publication 544 asks the contracting parties to agree on the amount of severance damages in writing. If they do not, all the proceeds are considered awarded for the condemned property, although closing papers that clearly show the part both parties intended as severance damages can be enough. A new allocation cannot be made after the transaction is completed.

The order of the steps

  1. Spread the expenses of obtaining the payments. Fees that can be traced to one part go against it; fees that cannot be traced are allocated in proportion to the two payments.
  2. Net the severance damages: less their share of the fees, and less any special assessment retained from the award for benefits to the remaining property.
  3. Reduce the basis of the remaining property by the net severance damages. If the net severance damages exceed that basis, the excess is a gain.
  4. Compute the gain on the part taken from the net award and the basis of that part.
  5. Both gains can be postponed under section 1033 by buying qualifying property, or, for severance damages, by restoring the remaining property.

Worked example: severance damages that produce a gain

A strip of a parcel is taken for a road. The owner receives $300,000 for the strip and $100,000 of severance damages stated in the settlement agreement. He pays $20,000 of fees that cannot be traced to either payment, so $5,000 goes against the severance damages and $15,000 against the award. The basis of the land he keeps is $60,000; the basis of the strip is $40,000.

Fictional example; Publication 544 (2025), Table 1-3, as read in November 2026.
Line of Table 1-3Amount
Net severance damages (line 5)$95,000
Basis of the land kept (line 6)$60,000
Gain from severance damages (line 7)$35,000
Refigured basis of the land kept (line 8)$0
Net award (line 13)$285,000
Gain on the strip (line 15)$245,000
Total gain (line 22)$280,000
Amount to reinvest to postpone it all (line 19)$380,000

The net severance damages of $95,000 wipe out the $60,000 basis of the land kept, which falls to $0, and leave $35,000 of gain. Add the $245,000 gain on the strip, and the total gain is $280,000.

Without any replacement, all $280,000 is recognized. If the owner spends $400,000 on qualifying replacement property, more than the $380,000 of line 19, nothing is recognized, $280,000 is postponed, and the replacement takes a basis of $120,000.

The trap: treating severance damages as part of the award. Added to the award, they would be set against the basis of the strip instead of the basis of the land kept, and the gain, the basis of the remaining land and the amount to reinvest would all be wrong.

When severance damages produce no gain

In most partial takings the net severance damages are smaller than the basis of the remaining property. They then only lower that basis: no gain, nothing to reinvest, and a larger gain on the remaining land when it is sold later. Part 1 of the worksheet ends at line 8, and only the award runs through Part 3.

Restoring instead of replacing

Publication 544 (2025) says that an owner who restores the remaining property to its former usefulness, for example by replacing fences, digging new wells or ditches or planting trees, can treat the cost of restoring it as the cost of replacement property; line 20 of Table 1-3 adds that cost to the cost of any property bought. The gain deferral article shows how the postponed gain then moves into the basis of what is bought or restored.

Sources

  1. IRS, Publication 544 (2025), Sales and Other Dispositions of Assets, chapter 1
  2. 26 U.S.C. 1033, Involuntary conversions
  3. 26 CFR 1.1033(a)-2, Involuntary conversion into similar property, into money or into dissimilar property

Figures checked on 20 November 2026. Rules as read in November 2026. Illustrative examples, not tax or legal advice: a CPA confirms whether a real event and a real replacement qualify, and the tax that applies. The owners and properties in the examples are fictional.

Questions readers ask

Are severance damages taxable?

Only to the extent the net severance damages exceed the adjusted basis of the remaining property. Below that, they reduce the basis and produce no gain for the year.

How are fees split between the award and severance damages?

Fees traceable to one payment go against it. Fees that cannot be traced are allocated in proportion to the award and the severance damages.

What makes a payment severance damages rather than award?

The parties should agree on the amount in writing; closing papers that clearly show the part intended as severance damages can also serve. Without that, all the proceeds are treated as the award for the condemned property.

Can a severance damages gain be postponed?

Yes, under section 1033, by buying qualifying replacement property or restoring the remaining property within the period. In the example, spending $400,000 postpones all $280,000 of gain.

Read the whole book

This article is one calculation from The Involuntary Conversion Handbook, a practitioner’s guide to section 1033: condemnation awards and severance damages, insurance proceeds and the year the gain is realized, replacement property and its deadlines, basis, related sellers, disaster rules and the election.

Also on this site