Articles · US Tax Law
Why even Constant Rental Accrual diverges from ASC 842 straight-line rent, with a 10-year Schedule M-1 / M-3 and ASC 740 DTA/DTL rollforward.
Corporate tax provision teams often assume that Constant Rental Accrual eliminates book-tax differences under ASC 842. In reality, because total tax accrual under Section 467 includes imputed interest on the Section 467 Loan, both Proportional and Constant Rental Accrual diverge from ASC 842 straight-line rent ($1,800,000.00/yr) in every single year, generating a temporary Schedule M-1/M-3 difference that peaks at $440,757.25 DTA/DTL in Year 4 under Regime 2 before reversing to $0.00 in Year 10.
Under FASB ASC 842, an operating lease recognizes a single straight-line lease cost (lessee) or straight-line lease income (lessor) equal to total undiscounted lease payments divided by the lease term ($18,000,000.00 / 10 years = $1,800,000.00/year on Meridian-Cascade). Under IRC Section 467, however, tax deductions and tax income rarely match straight-line:
At a 25.00% combined corporate tax rate, whenever ASC 842 book expense ($1,800,000.00) exceeds Section 467 tax deduction, the lessee records an unfavorable Schedule M-1 / M-3 add-back and builds an ASC 740 Deferred Tax Asset (DTA) (while the lessor builds a symmetrical Deferred Tax Liability (DTL)). Under Regime 2 on Meridian-Cascade, the cumulative temporary difference peaks in Year 4 at $1,763,029.02 (a $440,757.25 DTA/DTL) before reversing completely to exact $0.00 in Year 10:
| Year | ASC 842 Book SL | Reg. 2 Tax Total | Annual M-1/M-3 | Cum. Temp. Diff | Ending DTA / DTL |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | $1,800,000.00 | $1,153,711.18 | +$646,288.82 | +$646,288.82 | $161,572.20 |
| 4 (Peak) | $1,800,000.00 | $1,608,967.74 | +$191,032.26 | +$1,763,029.02 | $440,757.25 |
| 5 (Cross) | $1,800,000.00 | $1,821,496.84 | -$21,496.84 | +$1,741,532.18 | $435,383.04 |
| 10 | $1,800,000.00 | $2,354,237.60 | -$554,237.60 | $0.00 | $0.00 |
Tax provision audit check: Under all three Section 467 regimes, total 10-year cumulative tax deductions equal $18,000,000.00, matching total ASC 842 book expense of $18,000,000.00. Every Schedule M-1 / M-3 variance is purely temporary and must roll to exact $0.00 at lease expiration (unless a portion of Section 467 Interest is permanently disallowed or carried forward separately under IRC Section 163(j)).
1. FASB ASC Topic 842 (Leases) and ASC Topic 740 (Income Taxes) (verified 2026-11-22).
2. IRC Section 467 and Treas. Reg. Sections 1.467-1 through 1.467-4.
No. Constant Rental Accrual levels only the rent component (at present value), whereas total tax expense or income also includes Section 467 Interest on the imputed loan, creating a book-tax difference every year.
In early years when ASC 842 straight-line lease expense exceeds the lower stepped or proportional Section 467 tax deduction, the lessee records a Schedule M-1/M-3 add-back and a Deferred Tax Asset (DTA), while the lessor records a symmetrical Deferred Tax Liability (DTL).
Yes. Because total Section 467 Rent plus Section 467 Interest equals total undiscounted cash payments, cumulative book-tax differences and ending DTA/DTL balances reverse to exact $0.00 at lease expiration.
Model Proportional Rental Accrual, Constant Rental Accrual, 110% AFR Section 467 Loans, 85/115 and 90/110 safe harbors, and ASC 842 book-tax schedules in the Section 467 Rental Accrual Calculator (Excel).
Complete worked computations on Meridian Logistics Trust and Cascade Distribution Corp. ($18,000,000.00 10-year commercial lease), covering Proportional and Constant Rental Accrual, 110% AFR loans, safe harbors, Section 467(c) recapture, substantial modifications, and ASC 842 / ASC 740 book-tax reconciliation.