Articles · US Tax Law

Section 467 90/110 and 85/115 Uneven Rent Safe Harbors and Rent Holidays

Protecting stepped commercial leases from IRS Constant Rental Accrual disqualification under Treas. Reg. Section 1.467-3(c)(4).

To prevent the IRS from imposing Constant Rental Accrual on a leaseback or long-term agreement, Treas. Reg. Section 1.467-3(c)(4) provides the uneven rent safe harbor: 90% to 110% of average annual rent for equipment leases, and a wider 85% to 115% band for real estate leases. On an $18,000,000.00 10-year warehouse lease ($1,800,000.00 average), keeping annual allocations between $1,530,000.00 and $2,070,000.00 guarantees safe harbor protection.

1. Why the uneven rent safe harbor matters

If a lease is a leaseback (to a party who held an interest within 2 years) or a long-term agreement (lease term exceeding 75% of the statutory recovery period under IRC Section 467(e)(3)(A), which is 14.25 years for commercial real estate based on the statutory 19-year recovery period, not 39-year MACRS), the IRS can impose punitive Constant Rental Accrual if tax avoidance is a principal purpose. Treas. Reg. Section 1.467-3(c)(4) provides a bright-line safe harbor that completely insulates a lease from tax-avoidance disqualification.

2. 90/110 (Equipment) vs. 85/115 (Real Estate)

Practitioners frequently misapply the 90/110 rule to real estate leases. Under Treas. Reg. Section 1.467-3(c)(4)(iii), the safe harbor band depends on the underlying asset:

10-Year Schedule ($18,000,000.00 Total)Min Rent (% Avg)Max Rent (% Avg)85/115 Real Estate90/110 Equipment
Base Meridian-Cascade Lease$1,200,000.00 (66.67%)$2,400,000.00 (133.33%)FAILFAIL
Compliant Real Estate Variant$1,550,000.00 (86.11%)$2,050,000.00 (113.89%)PASSFAIL
Compliant Equipment Variant$1,640,000.00 (91.11%)$1,960,000.00 (108.89%)PASSPASS

3. Rent holiday exclusions

Two distinct rent holiday rules protect commercial leases from failing the uneven rent test:

4. Sources

1. IRC Section 467(b)(4)-(5) and Section 467(e)(3)(A) (verified 2026-11-22).
2. Treas. Reg. Section 1.467-3(c)(3)-(4) (T.D. 8820).

Frequently asked questions

What is the difference between the 90/110 and 85/115 Section 467 safe harbors?

The 90/110 uneven rent test applies to personal property and equipment leases, while Treas. Reg. Section 1.467-3(c)(4)(iii) widens the safe harbor to 85% to 115% of average annual rent for real estate leases (at least 90% real property by value).

What is the long-term agreement threshold for commercial real estate under Section 467?

Under IRC Section 467(e)(3)(A), the statutory recovery period for both residential rental and nonresidential real property is 19 years (not 39-year MACRS). Seventy-five percent of 19 years is 14.25 years.

How long can a rent holiday be without violating the Section 467 safe harbor?

An initial rent holiday of 3 months or less is always disregarded. For real estate under the 85/115 test, a single commercially reasonable rent holiday up to the lesser of 24 months or 10% of the lease term is also disregarded.

Free Excel calculator

Model Proportional Rental Accrual, Constant Rental Accrual, 110% AFR Section 467 Loans, 85/115 and 90/110 safe harbors, and ASC 842 book-tax schedules in the Section 467 Rental Accrual Calculator (Excel).

The Section 467 Rental Agreements Handbook

Complete worked computations on Meridian Logistics Trust and Cascade Distribution Corp. ($18,000,000.00 10-year commercial lease), covering Proportional and Constant Rental Accrual, 110% AFR loans, safe harbors, Section 467(c) recapture, substantial modifications, and ASC 842 / ASC 740 book-tax reconciliation.

DRM-free PDF, $19.99 → · Paperback, $32.99 · Book page

Also on this site