Articles · US Tax Law
Protecting stepped commercial leases from IRS Constant Rental Accrual disqualification under Treas. Reg. Section 1.467-3(c)(4).
To prevent the IRS from imposing Constant Rental Accrual on a leaseback or long-term agreement, Treas. Reg. Section 1.467-3(c)(4) provides the uneven rent safe harbor: 90% to 110% of average annual rent for equipment leases, and a wider 85% to 115% band for real estate leases. On an $18,000,000.00 10-year warehouse lease ($1,800,000.00 average), keeping annual allocations between $1,530,000.00 and $2,070,000.00 guarantees safe harbor protection.
If a lease is a leaseback (to a party who held an interest within 2 years) or a long-term agreement (lease term exceeding 75% of the statutory recovery period under IRC Section 467(e)(3)(A), which is 14.25 years for commercial real estate based on the statutory 19-year recovery period, not 39-year MACRS), the IRS can impose punitive Constant Rental Accrual if tax avoidance is a principal purpose. Treas. Reg. Section 1.467-3(c)(4) provides a bright-line safe harbor that completely insulates a lease from tax-avoidance disqualification.
Practitioners frequently misapply the 90/110 rule to real estate leases. Under Treas. Reg. Section 1.467-3(c)(4)(iii), the safe harbor band depends on the underlying asset:
| 10-Year Schedule ($18,000,000.00 Total) | Min Rent (% Avg) | Max Rent (% Avg) | 85/115 Real Estate | 90/110 Equipment |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Base Meridian-Cascade Lease | $1,200,000.00 (66.67%) | $2,400,000.00 (133.33%) | FAIL | FAIL |
| Compliant Real Estate Variant | $1,550,000.00 (86.11%) | $2,050,000.00 (113.89%) | PASS | FAIL |
| Compliant Equipment Variant | $1,640,000.00 (91.11%) | $1,960,000.00 (108.89%) | PASS | PASS |
Two distinct rent holiday rules protect commercial leases from failing the uneven rent test:
1. IRC Section 467(b)(4)-(5) and Section 467(e)(3)(A) (verified 2026-11-22).
2. Treas. Reg. Section 1.467-3(c)(3)-(4) (T.D. 8820).
The 90/110 uneven rent test applies to personal property and equipment leases, while Treas. Reg. Section 1.467-3(c)(4)(iii) widens the safe harbor to 85% to 115% of average annual rent for real estate leases (at least 90% real property by value).
Under IRC Section 467(e)(3)(A), the statutory recovery period for both residential rental and nonresidential real property is 19 years (not 39-year MACRS). Seventy-five percent of 19 years is 14.25 years.
An initial rent holiday of 3 months or less is always disregarded. For real estate under the 85/115 test, a single commercially reasonable rent holiday up to the lesser of 24 months or 10% of the lease term is also disregarded.
Model Proportional Rental Accrual, Constant Rental Accrual, 110% AFR Section 467 Loans, 85/115 and 90/110 safe harbors, and ASC 842 book-tax schedules in the Section 467 Rental Accrual Calculator (Excel).
Complete worked computations on Meridian Logistics Trust and Cascade Distribution Corp. ($18,000,000.00 10-year commercial lease), covering Proportional and Constant Rental Accrual, 110% AFR loans, safe harbors, Section 467(c) recapture, substantial modifications, and ASC 842 / ASC 740 book-tax reconciliation.