Articles

Booth rent or commission: what does the salon keep, and what does the stylist keep?

The same stylist, clients and prices, counted as an employee and as a booth renter, for the salon and for her, and the federal tests that decide which she is.

Compare the same stylist both ways. In the worked case she leaves the salon $54,949 a year as an employee and $14,300 as a booth renter at $275 a week; she receives $71,285 as an employee and $117,446 as a renter, before her own taxes and benefits.

Worked in full in The Hair Salon Owner by Julian R. Sterling.Get the DRM-free PDF, $19.99 →or the paperback

Free: the Hair Salon Service Price and Break-Even Planner in Excel, with the price build, the break-even and the booth rent comparison of the book's case.

The rule: compare the same stylist, the same clients, two ways

Booth rent and commission are two different businesses. As an employer, the salon keeps the stylist's service and retail revenue after her pay, its burden, the tax on her tips, the back bar, the cost of retail and card fees. As a landlord, it keeps the rent. For the stylist it is the reverse: wages and tips as an employee, or everything her clients pay less rent and her own costs as a renter, before her self-employment taxes and benefits.

Example 1: one stylist, one year, both ways

The worked case is Vellwyn Hair Studio, the fictional salon of the book. In FY2025 it rented four stations at $260 a week, $54,080 of booth rent for the year. In week 53 two of the renters became employees on hourly pay plus commission, one kept renting at $275 a week and one left. The table follows the first former renter through FY2026, 52 weeks, with the same clients, prices and products either way. Every figure is a teaching assumption, not a market norm.

Commission against booth rent, the first former booth renter, FY2026 (fictional case).
PartyAs an employee ($)As a renter at $275 a week ($)As a renter at $400 a week ($)
The salon54,94914,30020,800
The stylist, before her own taxes71,285117,446110,946

To the salon as her employer = $121,030 + $12,104 − $49,486 − $4,924 − $1,668 − $12,132 − $6,294 − $3,681 = $54,949

To the salon as her landlord = $275 × 52 = $14,300

The salon's station costs are the same either way, so they appear in neither column. For her: $49,486 of pay plus $21,799 of tips makes $71,285 as an employee; as a renter her clients' $154,933, less the rent, the back bar, the cost of retail, card fees and $1,080 of her own insurance and booking software, leave $117,446.

The trap: reading the stylist's column as take-home pay. Her renter figure comes before self-employment taxes, her own benefits and any unpaid time, which the illustration leaves out. The salon's employer figure comes before its own rent, front desk and overhead.

What a higher booth rent changes

At $400 a week the salon would receive $20,800 and she $110,946. Each side's gap narrows by $6,500; the order does not change. In the case, the two former renters' service and retail revenue, now counted as the salon's, was $261,869 in FY2026, more than half of the year's revenue increase: converting renters changes the size of the salon's statements, not only its margin.

Employee or tenant: the label does not decide

Under 29 CFR 795.105 as in force in November 2026, the Fair Labor Standards Act's minimum wage, overtime and recordkeeping duties apply to employees, and calling an employee an independent contractor does not remove them; the test is the economic reality of the relationship. The Department of Labor proposed on 26 February 2026 to replace that rule (91 FR 9932); no final rule had appeared in the eCFR by 16 November 2026. The IRS weighs behavioral control, financial control and the type of relationship, and either side may file Form SS-8 for a determination. For tax years beginning after 2025 the reporting threshold for nonemployee compensation on Form 1099-NEC is $2,000. States may apply stricter tests and may require a booth rental license or permit. Whether a renter is a tenant or an employee is for counsel in the salon's state and the CPA.

Sources

  1. eCFR, 29 CFR part 795: employee or independent contractor under the FLSA
  2. IRS: independent contractor (self-employed) or employee?
  3. IRS: instructions for Forms 1099-MISC and 1099-NEC

Figures checked on 18 November 2026. The salon in the examples is fictional, and its hours, prices, pay, rents and costs are teaching assumptions, not market norms or the rule of any state. Not legal, tax or accounting advice.

Questions readers ask

Is booth rent or commission better for a salon owner?

In the worked case the salon keeps $54,949 a year from one stylist as an employee and $14,300 as a renter. The book draws no general rule: the answer depends on the salon's own figures, and on what the law says the stylist is.

Do stylists earn more renting a booth?

Before her own taxes and benefits, the case's stylist would have $117,446 as a renter against $71,285 as an employee. Self-employment taxes, benefits and unpaid time are left out of that figure.

Is a booth renter an employee?

The label does not decide. The federal test under 29 CFR 795.105 is the economic reality of the relationship, the IRS weighs behavioral control, financial control and the type of relationship, and states may apply stricter tests. Counsel in the salon's state decides.

What booth rent would close the gap?

None in the case. At $400 a week the salon would receive $20,800, still far below $54,949 as an employer, and each side's gap narrows by $6,500.

Read the whole book

This article is one calculation from The Hair Salon Owner, a practitioner’s guide to running a salon by the numbers: service pricing and chair time, commission, booth rent and suites, stylist pay and tips, product cost and retail, rebooking and retention, cash flow, break-even and what the salon is worth, with seven workbooks.

Also on this site