Menu engineering sorts each plate by two measures, how well it sells and what it leaves in dollars, and turns the menu into four classes with an action for each.
In the worked restaurant, ten entrees sold 45,800 plates. Weighted by sales, a plate left $16.82 after its plate cost. The two plates with the highest food cost percent on the menu are stars; the cheapest plate to make is the only dog.
Contribution = price − plate cost. Contribution line = weighted average contribution. Popularity line = 70% of an equal share of the plates sold.
With ten entrees an equal share is one tenth, so the popularity line falls at 7.0 percent. Above both lines: star. Popular, below the contribution line: plowhorse. Above the contribution line, unpopular: puzzle. Below both: dog.
| Entree | Contribution | Share | Class |
|---|---|---|---|
| Short rib | $20.40 | 13.5% | Star |
| Roast half chicken | $17.30 | 16.2% | Star |
| Steak frites | $21.20 | 11.1% | Star |
| Salmon | $18.90 | 9.4% | Star |
| Burger | $12.10 | 21.4% | Plowhorse |
| Pasta of the day | $17.20 | 6.8% | Puzzle |
| Pork chop | $18.60 | 4.1% | Puzzle |
| Seared scallops | $20.10 | 3.3% | Puzzle |
| Vegetable risotto | $16.60 | 3.7% | Dog |
| Fish tacos | $12.70 | 10.5% | Plowhorse |
Worked in full in The Restaurant Owner by Julian R. Sterling.Get the DRM-free PDF, $19.99 →or the paperback
Free: the restaurant acquisition model in Excel, from net income to SDE, the offer, the cash at closing and the SBA 7(a) loan with its checks.
Stars stay as they are. On the burger, a plowhorse, weighing the fries and changing the bun takes $0.60 off each plate: $5,880 a year at the same price and sales. Puzzles get better placement: if the scallops sold 750 more plates and each replaced an average entree, the restaurant would keep about $2,460 more a year, not the $15,075 a naive count suggests, because most extra plates replace another order. The one dog, a vegetable risotto, brings $28,220 a year and is the only meatless entree: it stays, because a table with one vegetarian chooses a restaurant that can feed everyone.
The trap: judging plates by food cost percent. The short rib at 40.0 percent leaves $20.40 a plate; the risotto at 21.0 percent leaves less.
Figures checked on 18 November 2026. The restaurant in the examples is fictional and its figures are teaching assumptions, not market norms. Not legal, tax or lending advice.
Every quarter, on the point-of-sale counts and current recipe costs, changing a few plates at a time so each change can be measured.
No, it is a common rule of thumb. A different rule moves plates between classes, which is why the matrix asks questions rather than answering them.
Usually, but not always: a plate may bring tables that would otherwise go elsewhere, which its own line does not show.
This article is one calculation from The Restaurant Owner, a practitioner’s guide to buying and running an independent restaurant by the numbers: prime cost, food cost variance, menu engineering, tip credits and tip pools, labor scheduling, the lease, the liquor license, SDE, the price and SBA financing.
DRM-free PDF, $19.99 · Paperback, $32.99, shipped worldwide · Free Excel model