Active participation opens the allowance; modified adjusted gross income above $100,000 takes back 50 cents per dollar, and nothing is left at $150,000. Part II of Form 8582, line by line.
A couple filing jointly who actively participate in a rental can deduct up to $25,000 a year of passive rental real estate loss against wages and other income. The allowance falls by 50 percent of modified adjusted gross income above $100,000 and is gone at $150,000. At a MAGI of $131,000 it is $9,500: an $18,000 rental loss is allowed for $9,500 and $8,500 is carried to the next year.
Worked in full in The Passive Activity Loss Handbook by Julian R. Sterling, with every figure reproduced in a free workbook.Get the DRM-free PDF, $19.99 →
Section 469 normally lets a passive loss offset passive income only. Section 469(i), as read in November 2026, carves out one exception for natural persons: the part of the passive activity loss that comes from rental real estate activities in which the individual actively participated is allowed against any income, up to $25,000 for the year. It is not a separate deduction. It is a ceiling on how much of the rental loss escapes the passive limit, and whatever does not escape stays with the activity as a carried loss.
Active participation is a much lighter test than material participation. It asks for decisions made in a significant and bona fide sense: approving tenants, setting the rent and the lease terms, approving capital or repair spending. An owner who uses a property manager but keeps those decisions would generally still actively participate; an owner who has handed them over entirely would not. A spouse's participation counts.
Three limits apply whatever the owner does. The owner and spouse together must hold at least 10 percent of the property by value at all times during the period. No interest held as a limited partner counts as active participation, except as regulations provide. And for a loss carried from an earlier year, the owner must have actively participated both in the year the loss arose and in the current year; otherwise the carried loss goes in Part V of Form 8582, outside the allowance.
The phase-out runs on a modified figure, not on AGI. The IRS instructions for Form 8582 build it from everything used to figure AGI, then leave out a list of items: any passive activity loss, any rental real estate loss allowed to a real estate professional, taxable social security benefits, IRA deductions, the deductible part of self-employment tax and the other items the instructions name. What stays in matters as much: portfolio income such as interest, nonpassive income including net income recharacterized under the passive rules (a building rented to the owner's own business, for example), and any overall loss from the disposition of an entire interest in a passive activity.
Two consequences follow. A salary raise or a bonus reduces the allowance even though the rental has not changed. And a nonpassive loss from a sale lowers MAGI in the year of the sale, which can restore part of the allowance for the other rentals.
The $25,000 is reduced, not below zero, by 50 percent of the amount by which MAGI exceeds $100,000. The allowance is therefore full up to $100,000, falls by 50 cents for each dollar above it, and reaches zero at $150,000. Inside that band, each extra dollar of MAGI costs half a dollar of rental deduction, on top of the tax on the dollar itself.
| MAGI | Reduction | Allowance |
|---|---|---|
| $100,000 or less | $0 | $25,000 |
| $127,800 | $13,900 | $11,100 |
| $131,000 | $15,500 | $9,500 |
| $150,000 or more | $25,000 | $0 |
The form reaches the same figure from the other end. Line 4 is the smaller of the net loss of the rentals with active participation (line 1d) and the total net passive loss (line 3), so the allowance never exceeds the loss that is actually left after passive income. Line 5 is $150,000. Line 6 is MAGI. Line 7 is line 5 minus line 6. Line 8 is 50 percent of line 7, but not more than $25,000. Line 9, the special allowance, is the smaller of line 4 and line 8. Part VI then spreads line 9 over the rentals with an overall loss, in proportion to their losses, and Part VII spreads what remains unallowed over every activity still in loss.
Line 4 is the line that is most often skipped. When the couple's other passive activities show net income, that income absorbs rental loss first, and the allowance only covers what is left. When they show a net loss, line 3 is larger than line 1d and line 4 takes the rental figure.
A sample couple, not the book's case, files jointly. Their MAGI is $131,000. They own one rental house, which they manage themselves, choosing the tenants and approving repairs; it shows a passive loss of $18,000 for the year, and they have no other passive activity. All figures are teaching assumptions.
| Line | Amount |
|---|---|
| Modified adjusted gross income | $131,000 |
| Reduction: 50 percent x ($131,000 - $100,000) | $15,500 |
| Allowance: $25,000 less the reduction | $9,500 |
| Passive loss of the rental, active participation | $18,000 |
| Loss allowed this year | $9,500 |
| Loss carried to the next year | $8,500 |
Read through Part II, the form gives the same answer: line 7 is $150,000 less $131,000, line 8 is half of that, $9,500, and line 9 is the smaller of line 4, $18,000, and line 8. The couple deducts $9,500 against their wages. The other $8,500 is not lost: it stays attached to the house as an unallowed loss, enters next year's Form 8582 in the column for prior-year losses, and comes back either against passive income, through a later allowance, or in full when the house is sold in a fully taxable sale to an unrelated buyer.
A useful check on the arithmetic: for any rise in MAGI inside the band, the allowance falls by half of the rise and the carried loss grows by the same amount. Plans that add income in a year with a large rental loss deserve that check before the year ends.
Married individuals who file separately and lived apart from their spouse at all times during the year get half of everything: an allowance of $12,500, a phase-out starting at $50,000, and zero at $75,000 on line 5. Those who file separately and lived together at any time during the year get no allowance at all. Their rental losses go in Part V, and the whole loss is carried unless passive income absorbs it.
Passive credits also use the allowance, through a deduction equivalent and after losses; the separate rules for those credits are beyond this page.
The case is fictional: Bertil and Saskia Morlaine, a married couple filing a joint return for 2026, with six activities: a duplex, a single-family house run by a paid manager, a townhouse sold during the year, a lake cabin rented for short stays, a building leased to the veterinary clinic Bertil owns, and a limited partner interest in an apartment syndication. Every amount and every hour count is a teaching assumption, not a market figure, and the facts of your own return govern.
Their MAGI is $127,800 in the first two readings of the return. The allowance falls by $13,900, from $25,000 to $11,100. In the first reading, line 4 is $55,700, so line 9 is the $11,100 of line 8, and Part VI gives it all to the duplex, the only rental with active participation and an overall loss. In the third reading, with the status and the aggregation election, no rental with active participation shows a loss, line 4 is $0, and the allowance is simply not used. Filing separately while living together would cost the couple the whole $11,100: the two separate returns would show $11,100 more AGI than the joint return.
Where a rental loss sits inside a return on investment, see how to calculate the after-tax IRR on a property; a loss that can only be carried changes the timing of the tax and therefore the return.
Rules are described as read in November 2026 from the Internal Revenue Code (26 U.S.C. 469, 465 and 1411), Treas. Reg. 1.469-1T, 1.469-2, 1.469-2T, 1.469-5T, 1.469-9 and 1.1411-4, and the IRS Instructions for Form 8582 (2025), and they change. State rules are not covered. This page is education, not tax advice: the facts of your own return govern, and your tax adviser decides how any rule applies to it.
For a joint return, as read in November 2026, the allowance falls by 50 percent of MAGI above $100,000 and reaches zero at $150,000. Married individuals filing separately who lived apart all year use $12,500, $50,000 and $75,000.
Active participation asks for real management decisions, such as approving tenants, rents and repairs, and a 10 percent interest. Material participation asks for hours under one of seven tests. The allowance needs only active participation.
No. It is AGI figured without passive activity losses, rental losses allowed to a real estate professional, IRA deductions, taxable social security benefits, the deductible part of self-employment tax and the other items in the Form 8582 instructions.
It is carried to the next year and stays with the same activity. It can be used against passive income, through a later allowance, or in full when the entire interest is sold in a fully taxable sale to an unrelated buyer.
Generally no. An interest held as a limited partner is not treated as actively participated, except as regulations provide. Ask your tax adviser how this applies to a given interest.
This article is one step of The Passive Activity Loss Handbook. The book follows one couple through one tax year: six activities classified, a short-stay cabin taken out of rental, hours counted against the seven material participation tests, a real estate professional status won by 75 hours, the aggregation election, the $25,000 allowance cut by MAGI, a self-rental, a K-1 loss pushed through basis, at-risk, passive and excess business loss limits, a sale that releases a carried loss, Form 8582 part by part, and three readings of the same return carried into the next year.
Paperback PDF edition, $19.99 Book page and free files
Free: the passive activity loss calculator in Excel.
Case figures computed by the book's model; the companies are fictional and every term is a teaching assumption. Figures checked on 20 November 2026. Rules described as read on the dates given; not tax advice.