Articles

How do you calculate overbilling and underbilling in construction?

Compare billings to date with revenue earned under percent complete: billed more is overbilling, a liability; billed less is underbilling, an asset.

Overbilling and underbilling compare what a contractor has billed with the revenue it has earned under the cost-to-cost method. Revenue earned is contract value times cost to date over estimated total cost. A job 90% complete on a $14,610,000 contract has earned $13,149,000; billed $12,900,000, it is underbilled by $249,000.

Worked in full in The Construction Accountant by Julian R. Sterling.Get the DRM-free PDF, $19.99 →or the paperback

Free: the WIP schedule template in Excel, with all nine jobs of the case, the fade and the loss job.

The definitions

Overbilling, or billings in excess of costs and estimated earnings, is the amount by which a contractor has billed a job beyond the revenue it has earned to date. It is a liability: work the contractor still owes. Underbilling, or costs and estimated earnings in excess of billings, is revenue earned but not yet billed. It is an asset, a contract asset under ASC 606.

Percent complete = cost to date ÷ estimated total cost

Revenue earned to date = contract value × percent complete

Over (+) or under (−) billing = billed to date − revenue earned to date

Example 1: an underbilled job

A fictional general contractor's job J02 has a contract value of $14,610,000 and an estimated total cost of $13,560,000. At year end it has spent $12,204,000 and billed $12,900,000.

J02 at year end, cost to cost (fictional case).
StepAmount
Percent complete: $12,204,000 ÷ $13,560,00090%
Revenue earned: $14,610,000 × 90%$13,149,000
Billed to date$12,900,000
Underbilled$249,000

The job has earned $249,000 more than it has billed. That is an asset, but a surety or a bank will ask why it has not been billed: an unapproved change order, a disputed pay application or, worse, an estimate of total cost that is too low.

Example 2: an overbilled job

Job J06 is at the start: $1,640,000 spent against an estimate of $6,560,000, so 25% complete. Revenue earned is $1,767,500, but the contractor has billed $1,920,000, front-loading the schedule of values.

Overbilled = $1,920,000 − $1,767,500 = $152,500

Moderate overbilling is healthy: the owner is financing the job. But the cash it brings in is already spent work, and a contractor that uses overbillings to pay old bills is borrowing from the jobs still to be built.

The book goes further

The Construction Accountant builds the whole year-end WIP schedule, the fade analysis, the pay application and the statements. DRM-free PDF, $19.99. Or start with the free WIP schedule template in Excel.

Example 3: a job that will lose money

Job J04's estimate has risen to $8,520,000 against a contract value of $8,300,000: a loss of $220,000. At 55% complete, cost to cost would show gross profit to date of $4,565,000 − $4,686,000 = −$121,000. But a loss is recognized in full as soon as it is expected, so the contractor books a provision for the remaining $99,000, and the job shows the whole −$220,000 now.

The trap: the loss provision is separate from the billing position. J04 is also overbilled by $185,000, since $4,750,000 billed exceeds $4,565,000 earned. A lender looking only at billings would miss the loss, and a WIP schedule that netted the two would hide both.

Uninstalled materials

Costs that do not measure progress come out of cost to date. Job J03 has $420,000 of rooftop units delivered but not installed: they come out of both cost to date and estimated total cost, so percent complete is ($7,868,000 − $420,000) ÷ ($11,120,000 − $420,000) = 69.6%, and the job is underbilled by $154,908. Left in, they would give 70.8% and overstate revenue by $10,504.

Across the whole schedule

On the contractor's nine jobs, underbillings total $595,704 and overbillings $337,500, a net underbilled position of $258,204. A net underbilled contractor has earned more than it has collected the right to bill, which ties up cash and is the first figure a surety checks.

Sources

  1. FASB ASC 606, Revenue from Contracts with Customers
  2. IRS Publication 538, Accounting Periods and Methods (long-term contracts)
  3. AICPA, construction contractors resources

Figures checked on 18 November 2026. Federal rules only, illustrative, and not legal or tax advice. The people and properties in the examples are fictional.

Questions readers ask

Is overbilling an asset or a liability?

A liability. Billings in excess of costs and estimated earnings is work the contractor has been paid for but not yet performed, a contract liability under ASC 606.

Is underbilling bad?

Not always, but large or growing underbillings worry sureties and lenders: they can mean unapproved change orders, slow billing, or a cost estimate that is too low.

How do you calculate percent complete for a WIP schedule?

Under the cost-to-cost method, divide cost to date by the current estimate of total cost, excluding costs such as uninstalled materials that do not measure progress.

How is a loss on a construction job recorded?

The whole expected loss is recognized as soon as it is known, through a provision for the part not yet recorded under percent complete.

Read the whole book

This article is one calculation from The Construction Accountant, a practitioner guide to contractor accounting: the WIP schedule, percent complete, overbillings and underbillings, fade, loss jobs, pay applications, certified payroll, overhead and the statements a surety reads.

Also on this site