Under ASC 450-20, accrue the best estimate in the range; if no amount is a better estimate than any other, accrue the minimum and disclose the reasonably possible loss above it.
A loss contingency is accrued when two conditions are met at the same time: the information available before the statements are issued shows that a liability probably existed at the balance sheet date, and the amount of the loss can be reasonably estimated. A range is enough to meet the second condition. What it does not settle is which number to book. US GAAP answers in two steps: the best estimate within the range if there is one, and the low end of the range when every amount is as likely as any other, with the reasonably possible excess disclosed. In the worked case below, a distributor sues for $4,500,000; the company accrues nothing in the first year, $1,200,000 in the second, and settles after year-end for $1,750,000.
Worked in full in The Contingencies and Provisions Handbook by Julian R. Sterling.Get the DRM-free PDF, $19.99 →or the paperback
Free: the contingencies and provisions model in Excel, with a probability matrix, a litigation accrual at the low end of a range, a warranty reserve with its proof and ARO layers, all checked.
ASC 450-20 sorts every loss contingency into one of three likelihoods. Probable means the future event is likely to occur. Remote means the chance is slight. Reasonably possible is everything in between. Only a probable loss can be accrued, and only when it can also be reasonably estimated. A reasonably possible loss is disclosed, with an estimate of the possible loss or range, or a statement that no estimate can be made. A remote loss is neither accrued nor disclosed, with the exception of guarantees, which are disclosed even when payment is remote.
The probability judgment belongs to management, informed by counsel. Counsel’s letter to the auditors corroborates it; it does not replace it. The file should carry, for each matter, the assessment, who made it, the date, and the range counsel is prepared to support.
When the estimate is a range, the accrual is the amount within it that appears to be a better estimate than any other. If no amount is better, the minimum of the range is accrued, and the possibility of a loss above the accrual is disclosed. Two consequences follow. A preparer cannot pick the midpoint because it feels balanced: under US GAAP the midpoint has no special status. And a substantive settlement offer made by the defendant is strong evidence for the low end, because the defendant has shown it is prepared to pay that amount.
Legal fees are a separate question. The company chooses a policy, expense defense costs as incurred, or accrue them with the loss, and applies it consistently. The worked case expenses them as incurred and says so in the policy note.
Corvane Hydraulics, a fictional pump maker, terminated an exclusive distribution agreement in 2024. On 12 March 2024 the distributor sued for $4,500,000.
| Year-end | Assessment | Range | Accrued |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2024 | Reasonably possible | 500,000 to 2,500,000 | 0 |
| 2025 | Probable | 1,200,000 to 3,000,000 | 1,200,000 |
| 2026 | Probable, settled 5 February 2027 | 1,200,000 to 2,600,000 before the settlement | 1,750,000 |
31 December 2024. Counsel and the general counsel judge an unfavorable outcome reasonably possible, not probable. Nothing is accrued. The note describes the claim and gives the range of reasonably possible loss, $500,000 to $2,500,000, and states that the estimate may change.
31 December 2025. Mediation failed in November after the company offered $1,200,000, and discovery produced emails supporting part of the claim. The loss is now probable. Counsel supports a range of $1,200,000 to $3,000,000 and cannot point to a better estimate inside it, so the minimum is accrued, and the offer confirms that low end:
| Account | Debit | Credit |
|---|---|---|
| Litigation expense | 1,200,000 | |
| Accrued litigation liability | 1,200,000 |
The note then discloses the reasonably possible loss in excess of the accrual: $3,000,000 - $1,200,000 = $1,800,000. Leaving that sentence out is how an accrual at the low end turns into a misleading note, because the reader sees only the smallest number.
31 December 2026. The range has narrowed to $1,200,000 to $2,600,000 and the books still carry $1,200,000. Before any later news, the excess to disclose would have been $2,600,000 - $1,200,000 = $1,400,000. Then, on 5 February 2027, before the statements were available to be issued, the parties settled for $1,750,000. The settlement gives evidence about a condition that existed at the balance sheet date, the 2024 termination, so it is a recognized subsequent event: the 2026 accrual is raised to the settlement amount and the charge is $1,750,000 - $1,200,000 = $550,000. The note now states the settlement, its amount and the payment date, 2 March 2027, and no range.
IAS 37 measures a provision at the best estimate of the amount needed to settle the obligation. For a single obligation that is the most likely outcome, adjusted for the others; where a continuous range has every point equally likely, it is the midpoint. On the 2025 range, $1,200,000 + $3,000,000 = $4,200,000 and $4,200,000 / 2 = $2,100,000, against the US GAAP accrual of $1,200,000: a difference of $900,000 from the same facts. A US subsidiary reporting to an IFRS parent keeps both figures. At the end of 2024 the frameworks agree: a loss that is not more likely than not is a contingent liability under IAS 37, disclosed and not recognized.
Defense costs were $180,000 in 2024, $260,000 in 2025 and $140,000 in 2026, expensed as incurred under the company’s policy and never added to the accrual. Mixing them into the litigation liability makes the roll-forward impossible to read and the disclosure of the reasonably possible excess meaningless.
Rules read on 18 November 2026, paraphrased, not quoted. The company is the fictional case of the book; its figures are teaching assumptions, not market data. Not accounting, tax or legal advice.
No. You accrue the amount in the range that is a better estimate than any other. If none is, you accrue the minimum and disclose the reasonably possible loss above it. The midpoint is the IAS 37 answer for a continuous range where every point is equally likely.
A substantive offer made by the defendant is strong evidence that at least that amount will be paid, so it supports the low end of the range. In the worked case the offer of $1,200,000 equals the minimum of counsel’s range, and that is what is accrued.
If the settlement gives evidence about a condition that existed at the balance sheet date and arrives before the statements are available to be issued, it is a recognized subsequent event: the accrual is adjusted to the settlement amount. In the case the 2026 charge is $550,000.
This article is one calculation from The Contingencies and Provisions Handbook, a practitioner’s guide to ASC 450, ASC 460 and ASC 410 with IAS 37 side by side: loss contingencies and litigation accruals, warranties, guarantees, asset retirement and environmental obligations, restructuring and subsequent events, on one manufacturer followed for three years.
DRM-free PDF, $19.99 · Paperback, shipped worldwide · Free Excel model