Articles

How do you run a lease versus buy analysis for equipment?

Approve the project first, then compare the ways of financing it. A lease is compared with borrowing to buy, at the after-tax cost of debt, including the tax deductions on both sides and the residual value the lessee gives up.

Leasing is a financing decision. Compare the after-tax cost of leasing with the after-tax cost of buying, discounted at the after-tax cost of debt, not at the project's hurdle rate. In the case below, a lease of a $4,500,000 machine at $760,000 a year in advance costs $371,000 more than buying in present-value terms.

Worked in full in The Capital Budgeting Handbook by Julian R. Sterling, with every figure reproduced in a free workbook.Get the PDF, $19.99 →or the paperback

The case

Ellsmere Plastics, a fictional packaging manufacturer, has approved a $4,500,000 production line. The equipment vendor's finance arm offers a seven-year lease at $760,000 a year, paid at the start of each year, with the equipment returned at the end. Bought, the equipment would be worth $550,000 at the end of year 7. Ellsmere's tax rate is 25% and it can borrow at 6.8% before tax, or 5.10% after tax.

The cash flows that differ

Present value of the cost at 5.10% ($ thousands)
CaseBuyLeaseNet advantage to leasing
Bonus depreciation3,1383,510-371
MACRS 7-year instead3,2633,510-247
No tax paid (discounted at 6.8%)4,1534,405-252

Why buying wins here

The pre-tax interest rate implicit in the lease, comparing the $4,500,000 cash price with the payments in advance and the residual given up, is 8.75%, against Ellsmere's 6.8% cost of borrowing. Buying also gives Ellsmere the whole depreciation deduction in year 1 and the $550,000 residual. Even for a company paying no tax, the lease loses, because its pricing does not pass on the lessor's tax advantage.

The break-even payment

The payment at which leasing and buying cost the same is $680,000 a year. That is the number to take into a negotiation. The vendor's final offer, $740,000, was still above it.

The classic mistake: discounting the lease payments at the project's hurdle rate. That compares a financing cost with an investment return and makes almost any lease look cheap. Lease payments are as certain as debt service, so they are discounted at the cost of debt.

Accounting is not the reason

Under ASC 842, most leases longer than 12 months are recognized on the lessee's balance sheet as a right-of-use asset and a lease liability. A seven-year lease of equipment with an eight-year life covers the major part of its economic life and would be a finance lease. The decision should rest on the after-tax cost, with any covenant effect noted separately.

Free Excel template: Capital Project Appraisal Workbook (incremental cash flows, NPV, IRR, MIRR, sensitivity, lease versus buy and capital rationing).

Also on this site: a capital budgeting example with taxes · NPV versus IRR conflicts.

Questions readers ask

What discount rate should a lease versus buy analysis use?

The after-tax cost of debt, because lease payments and the purchase financing are fixed obligations of similar risk. The project's hurdle rate is used to decide whether to invest, not how to finance.

How does bonus depreciation affect lease versus buy?

It makes buying more attractive for a company that can use the deduction, because the whole tax saving arrives in year 1. If the deduction cannot be used, the comparison should show the saving when it is actually realized.

When does leasing make sense?

When the rate implicit in the lease is below the company's own borrowing cost, when the lessor passes on a tax or residual-value advantage, or when the lease bundles services or flexibility that have a measurable value.

Does a lease keep debt off the balance sheet?

Generally no under ASC 842: leases longer than 12 months are recognized as a right-of-use asset and a lease liability. Covenant definitions may still treat operating and finance leases differently.

Sources: IRC 168(k) as amended in July 2025, IRS Notice 2026-11, IRS Publication 946, Rev. Proc. 2025-32 and ASC 842, checked on 18 November 2026. Figures computed by the author's model for a fictional company. Education only, not tax, accounting or investment advice.

Read the whole case

This article is one calculation from The Capital Budgeting Handbook. The book follows one manufacturer's capital plan from the call for projects to the board's approval and a post-completion review, and every figure it prints is a live formula in the free workbook.

Get the PDF edition, $19.99 Paperback · Free companion files