Articles

Installment agreement, offer in compromise or currently not collectible: how do you choose?

Price every route from the same balance and the same date: total paid including fees, amount left unpaid when the collection statute dates pass, and the risk of each.

Choose by pricing every route from the same balance and date: total paid including fees, the payments and their end date, what is left unpaid when the collection statute dates pass, and what can go wrong. A full-pay installment agreement must be affordable; a partial payment plan and currently not collectible leave interest running; an offer in compromise is measured against the reasonable collection potential. In the example below, a balance of $70,823 costs $93,469 on a full-pay plan, $51,379 on a partial payment plan and $19,359 as a lump-sum offer.

Worked in full in The Tax Resolution Professional by Julian R. Sterling.Get the DRM-free PDF, $19.99 →or the paperback

Free: the offer in compromise calculator in Excel, which turns a monthly financial statement and the assets into the reasonable collection potential and prices four payment routes on the same balance.

One balance, four routes

A taxpayer who cannot pay a balance in full has, in broad terms, four routes with the Internal Revenue Service: an installment agreement that pays the whole balance over time; a partial payment installment agreement that pays what the taxpayer can until the collection period ends; an offer in compromise that settles for the reasonable collection potential; and currently not collectible status, which stops most collection without paying anything. Comparing them by the monthly payment misleads. Compare them from the same balance and the same date, on the total paid including fees, the amount left unpaid, and what happens if something goes wrong.

The clock behind every route: the collection statute

Under 26 U.S.C. 6502(a) as read in November 2026, tax may be collected by levy or court proceeding begun within 10 years after the assessment. Each assessment has its own collection statute expiration date, and penalties assessed later can carry a different date from the tax of the same period (IRM 5.1.19, revised 5 May 2026). The date is suspended, among other events, while an offer in compromise is pending, while an installment agreement request is pending (not while an agreement is in effect), from a timely collection due process request until the determination is final, and in bankruptcy; suspensions that overlap run together rather than adding up.

Silas Wrenfield’s four years: ten years after each assessment, with the case ignoring any suspension in its projections.
Tax year (fictional client)Collection statute expiration date
202119 December 2032
202229 May 2033
202311 November 2034
202410 August 2036

The dates matter twice. A partial payment plan stops collecting when they pass, and an offer is priced on the months left before the shortest of them.

Installment agreements

Section 6159(a) allows written agreements for the full or partial collection of a liability in installments. As read on the IRS payment plans page in November 2026, setup fees run from $29 (direct debit, applied for online) to $178 (other payment, by phone, mail or in person), with $107 for direct debit arranged by phone, mail or in person, and a reduced or waived fee for low-income taxpayers. Interest and some penalties continue until the balance is paid. For a balance of tax of $10,000 or less, section 6159(c) requires the IRS to accept an individual’s agreement that meets its conditions, among them full payment within three years.

Currently not collectible

When a taxpayer cannot pay because of financial hardship, the account may be placed in currently not collectible status and most collection stops. As read on the IRS page in November 2026, the debt is not forgiven, penalties and interest continue, a notice of federal tax lien may still be filed, refunds are applied to the debt, and the IRS may review the taxpayer’s finances and resume collection. A financial statement and documents may be required.

Offer in compromise

An offer requires every return filed, the required estimated payments made, and no open bankruptcy. It carries a $205 application fee and a first payment unless the low-income qualifications are met, and the IRS generally does not accept one when the balance can be paid in full through a payment plan or asset equity. While it is pending the collection statute date is suspended and no levy is made. After acceptance the taxpayer stays compliant for five years, or the original balance can come back.

Worked example: the four routes priced

The client owes $70,823 at 15 August 2026, after a first-time abatement. His disposable income is $442 a month and his reasonable collection potential $19,154 for a lump-sum offer and $24,458 for a periodic one. Plans start on 15 December 2026; the case uses a 7.00 percent interest rate compounded monthly, a teaching assumption.

Fictional case. The amount left unpaid in (b) is what the projection shows when the last collection statute date passes on 10 August 2036; it is a feature of the projection, never an aim of the file.
RouteTotal paid, fees includedPaymentsLeft unpaidMain risk
(a) Installment agreement, full balance in 72 months$93,46972, of $1,297 (last $1,275)$0not affordable on $442 a month: default as soon as one month is missed
(b) Partial payment installment agreement$51,379116 of $442, the last on 15 July 2036$70,172reviewed, the payment can rise with income; the lien stays filed; ten years of payments
(c) Lump-sum offer in compromise$19,359$3,831 with the application, $15,323 after acceptance$0rejection; default in the five-year compliance term; the dates are suspended while it is pending
(d) Periodic payment offer$24,66323 of $1,019, last $1,021$0not affordable without outside money

Read the lines one at a time. Route (a) pays everything, $93,469, but needs $1,297 a month against $442. Route (b) is affordable by construction, since the payment is the disposable income; it runs 116 months, the lien stays filed, and in the case’s reading the agreement is reviewed and the payment can rise if income does. Route (d) costs $24,663 but needs $1,019 a month for 24 months. Route (c) costs $19,359, paid between 16 November 2026 and 20 July 2027 in the case, and needs outside money the client can raise: his savings, his retirement account and a loan from his brother.

Currently not collectible is not on the table: it is not available while disposable income is positive. Its cost shows why it is not a free pause either. With no payment for one year from 15 August 2026, the balance grows from $70,823 to $78,954, $8,131 more, because interest and the failure-to-pay penalty keep running.

The trap: choosing by the monthly payment. Route (b) has the smallest payment and the longest exposure; route (c) has the largest first payment and the smallest total. Put every route on the same balance, the same start date and the same fees before anyone reads the payment column.

How the case chose

The practice chose the lump-sum offer of $19,154, $19,359 with the fee. The reasons written into the engagement file: the offer equals the potential computed under the Internal Revenue Manual method; the client can fund it; the balance cannot be paid before the collection statute dates expire. The conditions written next to them: no asset left off Form 433-A (OIC), compliance through 22 June 2032, and estimated payments kept current. In the case the offer is accepted on 22 June 2027; in a real file no route is certain, and an offer that fails leaves the fee with the IRS and the balance still owed.

A comparison sheet for the client

Sources

  1. Internal Revenue Service, Payment plans, installment agreements (page reviewed 13 August 2026, read November 2026)
  2. Internal Revenue Service, Temporarily delay the collection process (page reviewed 13 July 2026, read November 2026)
  3. Internal Revenue Service, Offer in compromise (page reviewed 19 October 2026, read November 2026)
  4. Internal Revenue Manual 5.1.19, Collection Statute Expiration (revised 5 May 2026, read November 2026)
  5. Internal Revenue Code, Title 26 of the United States Code: sections 6159, 6331, 6502, 6651 and 7122 (read November 2026)

Rules as read in November 2026 in the Internal Revenue Code, the Internal Revenue Manual and pages of the Internal Revenue Service; amounts, thresholds and procedures change, so check the current figure on irs.gov. US federal rules only, illustrative, and not tax or legal advice; for a real file, consult a qualified tax professional. The taxpayers, the practice and the figures in the examples are fictional teaching assumptions, and nothing here promises any result.

Questions readers ask

Is an offer in compromise always cheaper than an installment agreement?

No. The IRS generally does not accept an offer when the balance can be paid in full through a payment plan or asset equity. An offer fits when the reasonable collection potential is below the balance, and it carries its own costs and risks.

Does interest stop under a payment plan or currently not collectible?

No. As read on IRS pages in November 2026, interest and some penalties continue under a payment plan until the balance is paid, and penalties and interest continue in currently not collectible status.

What is the collection statute expiration date?

The end of the period in which the IRS can collect an assessment, generally 10 years after it (26 U.S.C. 6502). Each assessment has its own date, and some events, such as a pending offer, suspend it.

Can the IRS still file a lien in currently not collectible status?

Yes. As read on the IRS page, a notice of federal tax lien may still be filed, refunds are applied to the debt, and collection can resume if the taxpayer's finances improve.

Read the whole book

This article is one step of The Tax Resolution Professional, a practitioner’s guide to representing taxpayers before the IRS in collection, penalty and examination matters: intake and transcripts, the assessment and collection statute dates, penalties and interest, notices, liens, levies and hearings, the financial statement, installment agreements and currently not collectible, the offer in compromise, penalty abatement, payroll tax cases and the trust fund recovery penalty, audits and appeals, and Circular 230.

Also on this site