Articles

How does the if-converted method work for diluted EPS?

Assume conversion at the start of the period, add the conversion shares, add back the after-tax interest or the preferred dividend, and include the instrument only if EPS falls.

The if-converted method assumes a convertible is converted at the start of the period: the conversion shares are added to the denominator and the interest expense, net of tax, or the preferred dividend is added back to the numerator. Since ASU 2020-06 it is the only method for convertible instruments, and share settlement is presumed whenever the issuer may choose.

Worked in full in The Earnings Per Share Handbook by Julian R. Sterling, with every figure reproduced in a free workbook.Get the PDF, $19.99 →or the paperback

The notes

Tallowmere Systems, a fictional listed company, has $200,000,000 of 2.25% convertible senior notes due 2030, convertible at 20.0 shares per $1,000, a conversion price of $50.00. The company may settle conversions in cash, shares or a combination. The notes would convert into 4,000,000 shares.

Step 1: the add-back

Interest expense for 2026 is the coupon of $4,500,000 plus $900,000 of amortized issuance costs, $5,400,000. Conversion would remove that expense, and with it a tax deduction. At a 25% tax rate the add-back is $4,050,000.

Step 2: incremental EPS

Incremental EPS = add-back / conversion shares = $4,050,000 / 4,000,000 = $1.0125. The notes are dilutive if that figure is below the running diluted EPS when they are tested. After options and units, Tallowmere's running figure was $1.5861; the notes reduce it to $1.5467, so they are included, even though the share price averaged between $36.00 and $44.00, far below the $50.00 conversion price.

What ASU 2020-06 changed

If the indenture instead required the principal to be paid in cash, only the conversion spread would be counted, at the average price: zero shares at Tallowmere's 2026 prices, and 666,667 shares at a hypothetical average price of $60.00, with no interest add-back.

Convertible preferred stock

Tallowmere's Series A preferred converts into 1,500,000 shares and carries a $3,000,000 cumulative dividend. Its incremental EPS is $3,000,000 / 1,500,000 = $2.0000, above the running $1.5467: including it would raise diluted EPS, so it is antidilutive for the year. In the fourth quarter alone, its incremental EPS of $0.5000 was below the quarter's running figure, and it was included in that quarter's diluted EPS.

The trap: testing each period once. The notes' incremental EPS was $0.2531 for a quarter and $0.5062 for six months; they were dilutive in the second quarter and antidilutive for the six months, in adjacent columns of the same report.

Takeaway

Free Excel template: Diluted EPS Workbook (treasury stock method, if-converted method, two-class allocation and antidilution sequencing by quarter and year).

Also on this site: diluted EPS, calculated step by step · the two-class method, worked.

Questions readers ask

Can I still use the treasury stock method for convertible notes?

No. Since ASU 2020-06, convertible instruments use the if-converted method under US GAAP. Notes that must settle the principal in cash include only the shares for the conversion spread.

Do out-of-the-money convertible notes dilute EPS?

They can. If the issuer may settle in shares, the full conversion shares are assumed and the after-tax interest is added back; the notes are included whenever their incremental EPS is below the running diluted EPS.

Is the add-back for convertible preferred stock tax-effected?

No. Preferred dividends are not deductible, so the dividend deducted in basic EPS is added back in full.

Are convertibles with a market price trigger included before the trigger is met?

Yes. Contingently convertible instruments with a market price trigger are included in diluted EPS, if dilutive, regardless of whether the trigger has been met.

Sources: FASB ASC 260-10 (Earnings per Share), ASU 2020-06, ASU 2016-09 and ASU 2025-12, as cited in the text. Figures computed by the author's model and checked on 18 November 2026. Education only, not accounting, legal or investment advice.

Read the whole case

This article is one calculation from The Earnings Per Share Handbook. The book follows one listed company's EPS through a fiscal year, quarter by quarter, from the share register to the footnote, and every figure it prints is a live formula in the free workbook.

Get the PDF edition, $19.99 Paperback · Free companion files