Two questions, two rules: how much the customer can safely owe (capacity) and how much it needs to owe (need). The lower answer is the limit.
Set the limit at the lower of a capacity limit and a need limit. Capacity is a share of the customer's tangible net worth that falls as its risk class rises; need is expected monthly purchases times two on net 30 terms. A class 3 customer with $4,800,000 of tangible net worth buying $80,000 a month has a capacity of $360,000 and a need of $160,000: the limit is $160,000.
Worked in full in The Commercial Credit Manager by Julian R. Sterling, with every figure reproduced in a free workbook.Get the PDF, $19.99 →or the paperback
| Risk class | Capacity limit |
|---|---|
| Class 1 | 15% |
| Class 2 | 10% |
| Class 3 | 7.5% |
| Class 4 | 5% |
| Class 5 | secured or cash in advance |
The class comes from a 100-point scorecard: years in business (20 points), payment record (30), financial statements (30), bureau score band (10), industry and concentration (10). 80 to 100 points is class 1, 65 to 79 class 2, 50 to 64 class 3, 35 to 49 class 4, under 35 class 5. The need rule is expected monthly purchases times two: on net 30 terms, a customer that pays on time owes about one month of purchases at any time, more just before a payment run or in a heavy month, and the second month is a full month of buffer for timing, seasonality and small delays.
Kessling Fabrication, class 3, tangible net worth $4,800,000, monthly purchases $80,000
Capacity = 7.5% x 4,800,000 = 360,000
Need = 80,000 x 2 = 160,000
Limit = lower of the two = 160,000
A limit above need invites exposure the business does not require: the extra room is used only when the customer stops paying. If Kessling's purchases grow, the limit can rise toward $360,000 without a new financial review.
Tarrow Plastics, scorecard 45 points (class 4), tangible net worth $1,200,000, monthly purchases $45,000
Capacity = 5% x 1,200,000 = 60,000
Need = 45,000 x 2 = 90,000
Unsecured limit = 60,000; gap to secure = 30,000
The gap can be covered by a standby letter of credit, a deposit or a personal guaranty, by shorter terms, or accepted with written approval and a monthly watch. In the case, a $30,000 standby letter of credit from Tarrow's bank covered it.
Review on a schedule set by risk class (class 4 quarterly, class 3 twice a year, classes 1 and 2 yearly) and whenever utilization reaches 80% of the limit, payments slow, a bureau alert arrives or ownership changes. Kessling's review point is $128,000.
Setting the limit at what the customer or the salesperson asked for, or giving every new account the same round number. A limit is the loss you accept if the customer fails; it should follow the customer's capital and its real purchases, not habit.
How much slow payment costs is shown in how to calculate best possible DSO and average days delinquent.
Free Excel template: Credit Manager Workbook (DSO, CEI, credit limits and reserve).
There is no single rule. A common approach scales the share with risk: in the case, 15% of tangible net worth for the strongest customers down to 5% for class 4, and no open limit for class 5.
Start with a modest limit by risk class, scored without the financial factor, and raise it as the customer pays within terms. Above a set amount, require statements or security.
On a schedule set by risk class and whenever utilization reaches about 80% of the limit, payments slow, or something changes at the customer.
This article is one calculation from The Commercial Credit Manager. The book follows one distributor's credit department through a year, from the first aging to a customer's Chapter 11 filing, and every figure it prints is a live formula in the free workbook.
Get the PDF edition, $19.99 Paperback · Free companion files