Articles

How do you calculate the R&D tax credit with the ASC method?

Fourteen per cent of the year’s qualified research expenses above half the average of the three prior years, or 6 per cent if any of those years had none.

The alternative simplified credit is 14 per cent of the year’s qualified research expenses above 50 per cent of their average over the three preceding years. An illustrative company with $2,400,000 of QREs and a prior average of $1,800,000 has a base of $900,000 and a credit of $210,000, or $165,900 if it elects the reduced credit under Section 280C. If any of the three prior years had no QREs, the credit is 6 per cent of the current year instead, and that rule catches start-ups.

Worked in full in The R&D Tax Credit Handbook by Julian R. Sterling.Get the DRM-free PDF, $19.99 →or the ebook and paperback

The ASC formula

The alternative simplified credit, Section B of Form 6765, is 14 per cent of the qualified research expenses (QREs) of the year above a base of 50 per cent of the average QREs of the three preceding years. If the taxpayer had no QREs in any one of those three years, the credit is 6 per cent of the current year’s QREs instead.

ASC = 14% × MAX(0, QREs − 50% × average QREs of the 3 prior years)

If any of the 3 prior years has zero QREs: ASC = 6% × QREs

In Excel, with this year in B2 and the three prior years in B3:B5: =IF(MIN(B3:B5)=0,6%*B2,14%*MAX(0,B2-50%*AVERAGE(B3:B5)))

A worked example: a growing software company

An illustrative software company spent $2,400,000 on QREs this year (wages of the engineers doing qualified research, supplies, and 65 per cent of contract research) and $1,500,000, $1,800,000 and $2,100,000 in the three years before.

ASC for the year, illustrative.
StepAmount, $
Current-year QREs2,400,000
Average QREs, three prior years1,800,000
Base: 50% of the average900,000
QREs above the base1,500,000
Gross credit: 14%210,000
Reduced credit under Section 280C: × 79%165,900

The base is half the average, so a company whose research spending is flat still earns a credit: here $210,000, 8.75 per cent of the year’s QREs. The regular credit in Section A, at 20 per cent above a base built from gross receipts going back to the 1980s or to the start-up years, can give more, but needs records most young companies do not have, which is why the ASC is the usual choice.

The 79 per cent is not a haircut on the benefit for a company paying tax at 21 per cent. For tax years beginning after 2024, a company that does not elect the reduced credit must reduce its Section 174A research deduction by the full credit. Here that costs $210,000 × 21% = 44,100 of tax, leaving 165,900: the same as the reduced credit. The choice matters when the company is in losses, where a smaller deduction only shrinks a loss carried forward.

The R&D Tax Credit Handbook takes the same company through the four-part test, the wage and contractor rules, Section 174A expensing and the Section G documentation that the IRS now asks for.

The start-up trap: one year at zero

The 6 per cent rule applies if the taxpayer had no QREs in any one of the three prior years, not only when all three are empty. Take a start-up with $600,000 of QREs this year:

The same year, two histories.
Prior three years of QREsRuleCredit, $
Prior years 0, 250,000, 450,000 (one year at zero)6% of current QREs36,000
Prior years 50,000, 250,000, 450,00014% × (600,000 − 125,000)66,500

A first year with no qualified research costs the company 30,500 this year, against a history where the first year had even $50,000 of qualifying wages. Documenting the research done in a founding year, when it existed, is worth checking before the first claim.

Using the credit against payroll tax

A qualified small business, one with gross receipts under $5 million for the year and no gross receipts before the five-year period ending with it, can elect to apply up to $500,000 of the credit against the employer’s share of social security tax, instead of carrying it forward against income tax it does not yet pay. For the start-up above, the whole 36,000 can be used this way from the quarter after the return is filed.

Takeaway

Take 14 per cent of the year’s QREs above half the three-year average: $210,000 on the example, 165,900 after the Section 280C election, which for a taxable company is worth the same. Check the history first: one empty year in the three drops the credit to 6 per cent.

Sources

  1. 26 U.S. Code § 41(c)(4), Election of alternative simplified credit (Cornell LII)
  2. IRS, Instructions for Form 6765 (Rev. 12-2025): Section 280C election, Section 174A adjustment, payroll tax election

Figures checked on 17 November 2026. Tax figures are federal only, for illustration, and are not tax advice.

Free online calculator, no sign-up: r&d tax credit calculator.

Questions readers ask

What is the ASC rate for the R&D tax credit?

Fourteen per cent of qualified research expenses above 50 per cent of the average for the three preceding years. If the taxpayer had no qualified research expenses in any one of those three years, the rate is 6 per cent of the current year’s expenses.

What happens if a company had no QREs in one of the prior three years?

The ASC drops to 6 per cent of current QREs. A start-up with $600,000 of QREs gets 36,000 instead of the 66,500 it would get with even a small amount of qualifying spending in the empty year.

Should I elect the reduced R&D credit under Section 280C?

For a company paying tax at 21 per cent it makes little difference: the reduced credit is 79 per cent of the gross credit, and not electing reduces the Section 174A deduction by the full credit, which costs 21 per cent of it. On a $210,000 credit both routes give 165,900. For a loss-making company, not electing usually keeps more value now.

Can a start-up use the R&D credit against payroll tax?

Yes, if it is a qualified small business: gross receipts under $5 million for the year and none before the five-year period ending with that year. It can elect to apply up to $500,000 of the credit against the employer share of social security tax.

Read the whole book

This article is one calculation from The R&D Tax Credit Handbook: the four-part test, qualified research expenses, the regular and ASC methods, Section 174 and 174A after 2025, the payroll tax offset and Form 6765 Section G.

Not on Amazon: 10 paperbacks by Julian R. Sterling on tax and incentives, printed on demand and shipped worldwide. Browse the bookshop →

Also on this site

All 1908 articles →