Articles

How do you calculate lost profits damages?

Build the sales the business would have made without the breach, subtract actual sales, apply the incremental margin, adjust for costs saved and added and for mitigation, then bring every item to the measurement date.

In the worked dispute, a coatings maker lost its resin supply for seven months. Its but-for sales exceed actual sales by $10,702,829 over the claim. At an incremental margin of 44.0 percent that is $4,709,245 of lost profits; after saved costs, extra costs, mitigation, the cover premium, interest and discounting, damages at the trial date are $6,880,636.

The formula

Lost profits = (but-for sales − actual sales) × incremental margin − costs the breach saved + extra costs the breach caused − profit earned only because of the breach.

Damages at the measurement date = past items + prejudgment interest + present value of future items.

Each term is a decision, and the order matters. The but-for sales come first, because everything else is a percentage or an adjustment of the gap they create.

Step 1: the but-for sales

The worked plaintiff sold $21,600,000, $22,980,000 and $24,410,000 in the three years before the breach. Its market, measured by an industry index, fell 5.5 percent in the year of the breach. Projecting sales as market times share gives but-for sales of $23,653,991 for that year, which, spread by the monthly pattern, predicts the two months before the breach within 0.3 percent. The method article explains why that test matters.

Step 2: lost sales and the incremental margin

Lost sales are but-for sales less actual sales, period by period. The margin is not the one on the income statement. Classify each cost line by whether it would have moved with the lost sales:

Fictional plaintiff of the book; shares are teaching assumptions, not norms.
Cost lineShare of salesMoves with volume
Raw materials and packaging (resin at the contract price)45.0%Yes
Direct labor: overtime and temporary workers3.0%Yes
Direct labor: the permanent crews6.0%No
Plant utilities, supplies and maintenance that move with output2.0%Yes
Plant overhead that does not move with output (depreciation, plant salaries, property costs)4.0%No
Freight out3.5%Yes
Sales commissions2.5%Yes
Other selling, general and administrative expense20.5%No

The moving costs add to 56.0 percent, so the incremental margin is 44.0 percent, against a gross margin of 40.0 percent and an operating margin of 13.5 percent.

Example 1: lost sales and lost profits by period.
PeriodLost salesLost profits
March to September 2025$6,269,128$2,758,416
October to December 2025$1,114,266$490,277
2026$2,427,588$1,068,139
January to May 2027$572,690$251,984
June to December 2027$319,157$140,429

Worked in full in The Lost Profits Damages Handbook by Julian R. Sterling.Get the DRM-free PDF, $19.99 →or the paperback

Free: the lost profits damages calculator in Excel, from lost sales to damages at the trial date, with its checks.

Step 3: what the breach saved and added

Example 2 is the outage period alone. Lost profits of $2,758,416, less $312,000 of wages saved by a furlough, plus $186,000 of expedited trials and $94,000 of testing, less $138,000 of profit on toll work taken in on idle tanks, give $2,588,416. The first draft of the claim added the extra costs and deducted neither saving: a one-sided treatment worth $450,000 before interest.

Step 4: cover, if an input had to be replaced

A buyer of goods who buys a substitute can recover the difference between the cover price and the contract price under UCC 2-712. In the example the substitute cost $0.75 a pound more; on the pounds actually bought to the end of the supply agreement that is $1,882,500. Keep the margin at the contract price, or the premium is counted twice.

Step 5: bring everything to the measurement date

Past items of $5,774,316 earn prejudgment interest under the governing rule, $479,848 at the case's simple rate; the future item is discounted to $626,472. Total: $6,880,636. The interest article shows the arithmetic.

The trap: a growth rate from good years projected through a market downturn, the gross margin used as the margin on lost sales, and a lost customer claimed years past its contract. Together they took the worked demand letter to $20,677,874, 3.0 times the supported figure.

Sources

  1. UCC 2-712, cover by the buyer (official text, Cornell LII)
  2. UCC 2-715, incidental and consequential damages (official text, Cornell LII)

Figures checked on 18 November 2026. The dispute in the examples is fictional and its figures are teaching assumptions, not market norms or rules of law. Not legal advice.

Questions readers ask

Are lost profits calculated on revenue or on profit?

On profit: lost sales less the costs that would have been incurred to make them. The incremental margin does the conversion.

Are lost profits consequential damages?

Often, but whether a particular lost profit is direct or consequential depends on the governing state law and the contract's wording. A clause excluding consequential damages can remove most of a claim, so read the contract first.

What does reasonable certainty mean for lost profits?

The amount must be established by evidence with reasonable certainty, not speculation. It does not require precision, but projections that rest on hope rather than history are exposed.

Read the whole book

This article is one step from The Lost Profits Damages Handbook, a practitioner’s guide to measuring commercial damages: the but-for world, the yardstick, incremental margin, mitigation, cover, prejudgment interest, discounting and the expert report under Rule 702, worked on one dispute from the demand letter to the trial date.

Also on this site