Articles

How much of a shipper’s shortfall payments does a one-year make-up window give back?

A minimum volume commitment is a take-or-pay. A make-up right turns a shortfall payment into a credit, but only if the shipper ships the excess before the credit lapses.

A shipper has committed to 100,000 barrels a day at $0.45 a barrel. Over six years it ships below the minimum twice and pays $4.11m for 25k barrels a day it did not ship. With a make-up credit that lasts only one year it recovers $0.82m, 20% of what it paid; with a two-year window it recovers $4.11m, all of it. The pipeline's revenue over the six years falls from $107.58m to $106.76m or $103.48m.

The assumptions

Illustrative pipeline contract, invented figures
ItemValue
Minimum volume commitment100,000 barrels a day
Tariff$0.45 a barrel
Annual volume at the minimum16.43m a year (100,000 × 365 × $0.45)
Shipper volumes, years 1 to 6, thousand barrels a day80, 95, 125, 110, 100, 120
Make-up ruleA shortfall payment earns a credit against later volume above the minimum, oldest first
Credit lifeTested at one, two and three years after the shortfall

The shipper pays the tariff on the committed volume whether it ships or not. A credit lets it ship above the minimum later without paying for that excess, so the pipeline is paid once for the barrels and not twice. All volumes are annual averages.

Step 1: the bill without a make-up right

Billed volume = the larger of actual volume and 100,000

Years 1 and 2 are short by 20k and 5k barrels a day: 25k in total

Shortfall payments = 25,000 × 365 × $0.45 = $4.11m

Excel: =MAX(Volume,Minimum)*365*Tariff

Step 2: the credits with a one-year window

Year by year, thousand barrels a day, one-year credit life
YearActual volumeShortfall (credit earned)Excess over minimumCredit usedBilled volumeBilled, $m
180200010016.43
29550010016.43
3125025512019.71
4110010011018.07
510000010016.43
6120020012019.71
Total255650106.76

The credit earned in year 1 can only be used in year 2, where the shipper is short again, so it lapses. The credit earned in year 2 is used in year 3, when the shipper ships 25k above the minimum, and it is the only one that is recovered: 5k of 25k barrels a day. The shipper has paid $4.11m for shortfall and recovered $0.82m.

Step 3: the same volumes with a longer window

Shortfall recovered and revenue by credit life
Credit lifeCredit used, thousand barrels a dayRecovered, $mLost to the shipper, $mSix-year revenue, $m
No make-up right00.004.11107.58
One year50.823.29106.76
Two years254.110.00103.48
Three years254.110.00103.48

Revenue = 107.58m (billed at the minimum or actual volume, no credits) − credits used × 365 × $0.45

One-year window: 107.58 − 0.82 = $106.76m; two-year window: 107.58 − 4.11 = $103.48m

Moving from one year to two years gives the shipper back $3.29m and takes the same amount from the pipeline. Years 4 and 6 also have excess volume (10k and 20k), but there is no credit left to use against it.

What if: the shipper ships the excess sooner

If the same six volumes arrived in a different order, with the 25k surplus in year 2 straight after the 20k shortfall in year 1 (80, 125, 95, 110, 100, 120), a one-year window would return 25k of the 25k short, and a shipper with no make-up right would get back nothing. The sequence of volumes, not their total, decides how much of the payment is returned.

The common mistakes

Takeaway

Questions readers ask

What is a make-up right in a minimum volume commitment?

A clause that turns a shortfall payment into a credit the shipper can use against later volume above the minimum, so that it does not pay twice for the same barrels. Here the credit is worth the tariff of $0.45 for each barrel a day shipped late.

Why do make-up credits expire?

Pipeline revenue is budgeted year by year, and a credit that lasted forever would turn the minimum commitment into an interest-free loan. With a one-year window, $3.29m of the $4.11m paid in this example is not returned.

How do make-up rights change the value of a pipeline contract?

They take revenue away from the pipeline when the shipper recovers the shortfall. Six-year revenue is $106.76m with a one-year window and $103.48m with a two-year window.

The workbooks behind this article

The free companion files for The Midstream Infrastructure Investor value a fictional fund of three midstream assets with volumes, minimum volume commitments, tariffs, debt and returns in one model. The pipeline in this article is invented and is not in them. No account and no email address.

Open the companion files →

Not on Amazon: 19 paperbacks by Julian R. Sterling on energy, infrastructure and land, printed on demand and shipped worldwide. Browse the bookshop →

Also on this site

Reading guide: infrastructure, data centres and energy → · All 1908 articles →