Under the three-year holding rule the carry on each asset is taxed by how long the fund held that asset, not by how long the fund has existed or by the average holding period.
A buyout fund sells three companies and earns a carried interest of $10.0m, 20.0% of a $50.0m gain. Company B was held 2.5 years, so its carry of $2.4m is taxed at 40.8% rather than 23.8%. The extra tax is $0.408m and the total tax is $2.788m, 27.9% of the carry. The average holding period is 3.5 years, which hides the problem.
| Item | Value |
|---|---|
| Carried interest | 20.0% of each gain |
| Rate on long-term gain | 20.0% |
| Rate on short-term gain, the ordinary income rate | 37.0% |
| Net investment income tax | 3.8% on both, assumed to apply |
| Holding period that qualifies for the long-term rate | More than three years |
| Company A: held 4.0 years, gain | $30.0m |
| Company B: held 2.5 years, gain | $12.0m |
| Company C: held 3.2 years, gain | $8.0m |
| Company B: sale price, for the what-if | $40.0m |
The rule looks at the holding period of each asset sold. A gain on an asset held three years or less that is allocated to the carried interest is taxed at ordinary rates, whatever the gain would have been taxed at in the fund. The model is simplified: state taxes, the effect on the investors and any planning around the rule are left out.
| Company | Held, years | Gain, $m | Carry at 20.0%, $m | Rate applied |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Company A | 4.0 | 30.0 | 6.00 | 23.8% |
| Company B | 2.5 | 12.0 | 2.40 | 40.8% |
| Company C | 3.2 | 8.0 | 1.60 | 23.8% |
| Total | 50.0 | 10.00 |
Rate = 23.8% if held more than 3 years, 40.8% if not
Excel: =Carry*IF(Years>3,LongTerm,ShortTerm)+Carry*NIIT
| Company | Carry | Tax at the rate applied | Tax at the long-term rate | Extra tax |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Company A | 6.00 | 1.428 | 1.428 | 0.000 |
| Company B | 2.40 | 0.979 | 0.571 | 0.408 |
| Company C | 1.60 | 0.381 | 0.381 | 0.000 |
| Total | 10.00 | 2.788 | 2.380 | 0.408 |
Company B: 2.40 × 40.8% = $0.979m, against 2.40 × 23.8% = $0.571m
Extra tax = 2.40 × (40.8% − 23.8%) = $0.408m
Company A, held four years, and Company C, held 3.2 years, pay the long-term rate. Company B is six months short of the three years, and it accounts for all of the extra tax, which is 14.6% of the total bill. The average holding period, weighted by gain, is 3.5 years, above three, yet the rule is applied sale by sale.
Carry on B after selling now = 2.40 × (1 − 40.8%) = $1.421m after tax
Carry on B after waiting six months, same price = 2.40 × (1 − 23.8%) = $1.829m, $0.408m more
Gain at which waiting is equal = 1.421 / (20.0% × (1 − 23.8%)) = $9.32m
Excel: =AfterTaxNow/(Carry%*(1-LongTerm-NIIT))
From the carry holder's point of view, waiting is better unless the sale price falls by more than $2.68m, or 6.7% of a $40m sale price, over the six months. The same price move also changes the investors' return and the fund's timetable, and a six-month delay has a cost of its own, so this is only the tax side of the decision.
The gain allocated to the carry is taxed at ordinary income rates instead of long-term rates. Here 40.8% against 23.8% on $2.4m of carry, an extra $0.408m.
In this illustration it uses the holding period of each asset. The average is 3.5 years, but the asset held 2.5 years is taxed at the higher rate.
For the carry holder, yes unless the price falls by more than 6.7% in the meantime. Waiting six months on Company B adds $0.408m of after-tax carry at an unchanged price.
Run the numbers yourself: the free distribution waterfall model splits fund profits between investors and the manager in Excel, with preferred return, catch-up and carried interest. For a closed-end fund with up to eight assets, fees and a European or American waterfall, see the Real Estate Fund Model, Pro Edition ($129).
The free companion files for The Private Equity Tax Professional rebuild a fictional buyout fund's tax year with live formulas. The sales in this article are invented, simplified and are not in them; this is not tax advice. No account and no email address.
Not on Amazon: 10 paperbacks by Julian R. Sterling on tax and incentives, printed on demand and shipped worldwide. Browse the bookshop →
Reading guide: private equity and private markets → · All 1908 articles →