Articles

How much CCC excess can a CLO hold before the senior overcollateralisation test fails?

CCC loans above the permitted bucket are carried at market value in the OC test, so a rating downgrade cuts the numerator. How much cushion is left can be computed in four lines.

A $500 million CLO with $360 million of Class A and B notes starts at an OC ratio of 138.9% against a 129.0% trigger, a cushion of $35.6 million of par. CCC assets above the 7.5% bucket count at market price, so at a price of 70 the cushion is gone when CCC assets reach 31.2% of par, which is $156.2 million of CCC loans. At a 20% CCC share the haircut is $18.75 million, the ratio is 133.7% and only $37.4 million of defaults at a 55% recovery remain to breach it.

A CLO manager can buy and hold loans rated CCC, but only up to a limit. Past it, the OC test stops counting them at par and uses the lower of par and market value. A downgrade wave therefore cuts the senior OC ratio even if no loan has defaulted. The relevant question is how much room the structure has before that happens.

The assumptions

One illustrative CLO
ItemValue
Collateral par$500 million
Class A and B notes (senior)$360 million
Senior OC trigger129.0%
CCC bucket limit7.5% of par
Market price of CCC loans70 per 100
Recovery on defaulted loans55%

Step 1: the OC cushion

OC ratio = adjusted collateral par / senior notes

Cushion = collateral par − trigger × senior notes

Excel: =Par-Trigger*Notes

At the start 500 / 360 = 138.9%. To stay at 129.0% the numerator must be at least 1.29 × 360 = $464.4 million. The cushion is 500 − 464.4 = $35.6 million.

Step 2: the haircut on the CCC excess

Only the part above the bucket is marked. With 12.5% of the portfolio in CCC loans the holding is 12.5% × 500 = $62.5 million, the bucket holds 7.5% × 500 = $37.5 million and the excess is $25.0 million.

Haircut = (CCC share − bucket limit) × par × (1 − market price)

Excel: =MAX(0,Share-Limit)*Par*(1-Price)

$25.0 million × (1 − 0.70) = $7.50 million. The numerator is 492.50 and the ratio 136.81%, still above the trigger with $28.10 million of cushion left.

Step 3: the results by CCC share

Senior OC ratio at a CCC price of 70
CCC share of parExcess ($m)Haircut ($m)OC ratioCushion left ($m)Defaults to breach ($m par)
7.5%0.00.00138.89%35.6079.1
10.0%12.53.75137.85%31.8570.8
12.5%25.07.50136.81%28.1062.4
15.0%37.511.25135.76%24.3554.1
20.0%62.518.75133.68%16.8537.4

Defaults draw on the same cushion. A default carried at the 55% recovery costs 45 cents per dollar of par, so the par of defaults that exhausts the remaining cushion is the remainder divided by 0.45. At a 12.5% CCC share that is 28.10 / 0.45 = $62.4 million, 12.5% of par.

Step 4: where the cushion runs out

The CCC share at which the haircut alone uses the whole cushion solves (share − 7.5%) × 500 × 30% = 35.6. So share = 7.5% + 35.6 / 150 = 31.2%, which is $156.2 million of CCC loans.

What if: CCC loans trade at 55

A weaker market raises the haircut to 45 cents on the dollar of excess. The haircut at a 12.5% share becomes $11.25 million, the ratio 135.76%, and the CCC share that exhausts the cushion falls from 31.2% to 23.3%. The structure has less room at exactly the moment when CCC holdings are most likely to rise.

The common mistakes

Takeaway

Questions readers ask

What is the CCC bucket in a CLO?

A limit, commonly 7.5% of the portfolio par, on the CCC-rated loans that count at full value in the OC tests. Above it, the excess is carried at the lower of its market value and its par, here 70 per cent of par.

Can the OC test come under pressure with no default?

Yes. The CCC excess is marked down by its price discount alone: at a 20% CCC share the haircut is $18.75 million, 53% of the cushion, with no loan in default.

What happens when the OC test fails?

Interest on the junior classes is diverted to repay senior notes until the ratio is back above the trigger. Equity is cut off first. The cushion of $35.6 million in this example is the room before that diversion starts.

The workbooks behind this article

The workbooks for this book rebuild structured credit waterfalls and tests with live formulas. The CCC bucket arithmetic in this article is a separate illustration and is not in them.

Open the companion files →

Not on Amazon: 36 paperbacks by Julian R. Sterling on how to read the documents, printed on demand and shipped worldwide. Browse the bookshop →

Also on this site

Reading guide: credit, private credit and distressed debt → · All 1908 articles →