Articles

How much carry does a tiered continuation vehicle pay the GP at different multiples?

A tiered carry is a marginal schedule: it costs investors less than a flat rate on weak outcomes and more on strong ones, and the break-even multiple is the number to know.

On $400 million invested in a continuation vehicle with carry of 10% from 1.00x to 1.50x, 20% to 2.00x and 30% above, the GP receives $44.0 million at a 1.80x exit, 13.8% of profit, against $64.0 million at a flat 20%. The two structures are equal at 2.50x, where each pays $120.0 million; at 3.00x the tiered carry is $180.0 million against $160.0 million.

The assumptions

Illustrative single-asset continuation vehicle, $ million
ItemValue
Capital invested in the vehicle (new investors and rolling investors)400
Carry on profit between 1.00x and 1.50x of capital10%
Carry on profit between 1.50x and 2.00x20%
Carry on profit above 2.00x30%
Comparison: flat carry on all profit above cost20%

The tiers are marginal: each rate applies only to the slice of profit inside its band, as in a tax table. Thresholds are set on the multiple of invested capital for simplicity; real vehicles often combine them with a preferred return, which moves the numbers but not the shape.

Step 1: carry slice by slice

Carry = Σ over tiers of [ max(0, min(multiple, upper) − lower) × capital × rate ]

Excel, one row per tier, then a sum: =MAX(0,MIN(M,Upper)-Lower)*K*Rate

At a 1.80x exit, the first slice is (1.50 − 1.00) × 400 × 10% = 20.0, the second (1.80 − 1.50) × 400 × 20% = 24.0. Carry is $44.0 million, which is 13.8% of the $320.0 million profit.

Step 2: carry at different exits

Tiered carry against a flat 20%, $ million
Exit multipleProceedsTiered carry% of profitFlat 20% carryDifferenceNet multiple, tiered
1.00x4000.0n/a0.00.01.000x
1.30x52012.010.0%24.0-12.01.270x
1.80x72044.013.8%64.0-20.01.690x
2.00x80060.015.0%80.0-20.01.850x
2.50x1,000120.020.0%120.00.02.200x
3.00x1,200180.022.5%160.020.02.550x

Tiered carry is lower than a flat rate at every multiple below 2.50x: $12.0 million against $24.0 million at 1.30x, $44.0 million against $64.0 million at 1.80x. The two meet at 2.50x, where each pays $120.0 million, 20.0% of the $600.0 million profit. Above that the 30% top rate overtakes the flat 20%: at 3.00x tiered carry is $180.0 million against $160.0 million, $20.0 million more.

Step 3: where the crossover comes from

Up to 2.00x the tiered structure pays $60.0 million against $80.0 million flat, $20.0 million less. Above 2.00x it earns 30% of each extra dollar against 20%, so it gains 10 points of rate on every extra dollar of profit: 10% of 400 = $40.0 million per extra 1.00x of multiple. The gap closes in 0.50 turns of multiple, from 2.00x to 2.50x.

What if: the vehicle exits at 1.30x

The asset disappoints. Tiered carry is $12.0 million, 10.0% of the $120.0 million profit, against $24.0 million flat. Investors keep 1.270x instead of 1.240x. The structure shares the downside with the GP, which is the argument for it, and costs the GP $12.0 million of carry relative to a flat rate.

The common mistakes

Takeaway

Questions readers ask

How is a tiered carry in a continuation vehicle calculated?

Each rate applies only to the slice of profit inside its multiple band. At 1.80x on $400 million the carry is 10% of the first $200 million of profit plus 20% of the next $120 million, $44.0 million.

At what multiple does tiered carry equal a flat 20%?

At 2.50x in this example. Below it the tiered structure pays less than a flat 20%, above it the 30% top tier makes it pay more.

Is the top tier rate the effective carry rate?

No. It applies only to profit above 2.00x. At 2.50x the effective rate is 20.0% of total profit, not 30%.

Run the numbers yourself: the free distribution waterfall model splits fund profits between investors and the manager in Excel, with preferred return, catch-up and carried interest. For a closed-end fund with up to eight assets, fees and a European or American waterfall, see the Real Estate Fund Model, Pro Edition ($129).

The workbooks behind this article

The free companion files for The Continuation Fund Handbook hold four Excel workbooks: the Thalia transaction of Chapter 18 from first discussion to closing, the pricing arithmetic of Chapter 7, the fee comparison of Chapter 12 and the appendix checklists as working documents. The tiered carry schedule in this article uses invented tiers and is not in them. No account and no email address.

Open the companion files →

Not on Amazon: 24 paperbacks by Julian R. Sterling on insurance and retirement, printed on demand and shipped worldwide. Browse the bookshop →

Also on this site

Reading guide: private equity and private markets → · All 1908 articles →