Articles

How much does a sliding scale commission raise the break-even loss ratio of a quota share?

A sliding scale makes the cedant bear part of the loss ratio through its commission. The break-even moves, but only up to the minimum commission.

A quota share ceding $100m of premium pays the cedant a flat 30% commission: with 1% brokerage, the reinsurer breaks even at a loss ratio of 69.0%. If the commission instead slides by half a point for each point of loss ratio, between a 22% minimum and a 34% maximum, the reinsurer breaks even at 77.0%, 8.0 points higher. The cedant gives the reinsurer that room by earning less commission when losses are high.

The assumptions

Illustrative quota share, per $100m of ceded premium
ItemValue
Ceded premium$100.0m
Provisional commission, at a 60% loss ratio30.0%
Slide: commission change per point of loss ratio−0.5 point
Minimum and maximum commission22.0% and 34.0%
Brokerage paid by the reinsurer1.0%

The slide reaches its maximum at a 52.0% loss ratio (34.0% = 30.0% + 0.5 × 8) and its minimum at 76.0% (22.0% = 30.0% − 0.5 × 16). Between them each point of loss ratio moves the commission by half a point; outside them it is fixed. The reinsurer’s own expenses and investment income are left out so that the effect of the slide stands alone.

Step 1: the commission at a given loss ratio

Commission = 30.0% − 0.5 × (loss ratio − 60%), bounded between 22.0% and 34.0%

Excel: =MIN(34%,MAX(22%,30%-0.5*(LR-60%)))

At a 65% loss ratio the commission is 30.0% − 0.5 × 5 = 27.5%. At 80% the formula gives 20.0%, so the 22.0% minimum applies; at 50% it gives 35.0%, so the 34.0% maximum applies.

Step 2: the reinsurer’s result

Result = premium − losses − commission − brokerage

At 65%, flat: 100.0 − 65.0 − 30.0 − 1.0 = 4.0

At 65%, sliding: 100.0 − 65.0 − 27.5 − 1.0 = 6.5

Reinsurer’s result per $100m of premium, in $m
Loss ratioSliding commissionResult, flat 30%Result, slidingDifference
50%34.0%19.015.0-4.0
60%30.0%9.09.00.0
65%27.5%4.06.52.5
70%25.0%-1.04.05.0
75%22.5%-6.01.57.5
80%22.0%-11.0-3.08.0
90%22.0%-21.0-13.08.0

The slide costs the reinsurer money when losses are low (-4.0 at 50%) and returns it when losses are high (+8.0 at 80%). At the 60% provisional loss ratio the two are the same.

Step 3: the break-even loss ratio

With a flat 30% the reinsurer keeps nothing once losses plus commission plus brokerage reach 100%: 100 − 30 − 1 = 69.0%. With the slide, the break-even falls beyond the point where the commission reaches its 22.0% minimum, so it is 100 − 22 − 1 = 77.0%. A reinsurer that expected a 65% loss ratio had 4.0 points of room before; it has 12.0 now.

What if: a shallower slide

A slide of a quarter point per point of loss ratio reaches its 22.0% minimum only at a 92% loss ratio, so the break-even falls on the slope: LR + (30 − 0.25 × (LR − 60)) + 1 = 100 gives 72.0%. At a 75% loss ratio the commission is 26.3% and the reinsurer’s result is -2.3, against 1.5 on the half-point slide and -6.0 on a flat commission. The quarter-point slide adds 3.0 points to the break-even and the half-point slide 8.0; the minimum commission caps the second, which would break even at 78.0% without it.

The common mistakes

How an insurer accounts for a one-year policy of this kind under IFRS 17, with revenue released as coverage passes, is worked in the premium allocation approach.

Takeaway

Questions readers ask

What is a sliding scale commission?

A reinsurance commission that changes with the loss ratio of the ceded business: lower when losses are high, higher when they are low, within a minimum and a maximum. Here it runs from 34% to 22% around a 30% provisional.

How does it change the reinsurer's break-even loss ratio?

It raises it, because the commission paid falls as losses rise. On $100m with 1% brokerage the break-even goes from 69.0% with a flat 30% to 77.0% with a half-point slide.

Why is the break-even capped by the minimum commission?

Once the commission reaches 22%, a further point of loss ratio costs the reinsurer a full point. Beyond 76.0% the slide no longer helps.

The workbooks behind this article

The free companion files for The Reinsurance Professional rebuild a fictional reinsurer’s underwriting year: a quota share and its sliding scale commission, a catastrophe programme hit by a windstorm, burning cost, a catastrophe model, the technical price, a sidecar and a retro cover. The loss ratios here are invented and are not in them. No account and no email address.

Open the companion files →

Not on Amazon: 24 paperbacks by Julian R. Sterling on insurance and retirement, printed on demand and shipped worldwide. Browse the bookshop →

Also on this site

Reading guide: regulation, compliance and banking → · All 1908 articles →