The panel, revenue and contribution per member, fixed costs with each physician's market pay, the break-even before and after the loan, capacity and growth: one practice worked line by line.
A direct primary care practice needs enough members to cover its fixed costs, each physician's market pay included. In the book's fictional two-physician practice each panel member left $88.28 a month after variable costs; with $64,770 of fixed costs the break-even was 734 members (763 after the loan payment), against a capacity of 1,500 and a panel of 1,068.
Worked in full in The Direct Primary Care Practice Owner by Julian R. Sterling.Get the DRM-free PDF, $19.99 →or the paperback
Free: the Direct Primary Care Membership and Break-Even Calculator, an Excel workbook that takes your members by age tier, your fees, your employer contract, labs, medicines and fixed costs, and returns revenue and contribution per panel member, the break-even in panel members before and after the loan payment, net members added a month and the fill rate of your capacity.
A direct primary care practice is paid by its members, not by the visit. Each member pays a monthly membership fee for the practice's primary care. In the book's case the fee covers visits, messaging, same-day access during office hours and in-office waived tests (the practice holds a CLIA certificate of waiver), the practice bills no insurer, and its physicians opted out of traditional Medicare, so each member enrolled in Medicare, whatever the age, signs a private contract under 42 CFR part 405, subpart D, before any service. So the question "how many patients" is really how many members, and it splits into two numbers: how many the practice needs to cover its costs (the break-even) and how many its physicians can care for at the access they promise (the capacity).
Every figure below comes from Calvenridge Direct Care, the fictional practice of the book: opened on 1 October 2023 by a family physician who left a hospital-owned group, joined by a second physician as an owner on 1 October 2025, with an employer contract since 1 October 2024. No figure from the market is quoted, because none was verified from a primary source: fees, costs, pay and the panel capacity are teaching assumptions, and nothing here is clinical guidance. The method is what carries over to your own practice.
Counting starts with levels that never mix. Active paying members are those whose fee for the month was collected and who stay members. Contract members are employees enrolled under an employer contract, paid by the employer. The panel is the two added together. Attrition is the month's departures over active paying members at the start of the month, one base only, and the fill rate is the panel over capacity.
| Tier | Members | Monthly fee | Fees billed |
|---|---|---|---|
| Children (under 18) | 198 | $45.00 | $8,910.00 |
| Adults (18 to 64) | 546 | $95.00 | $51,870.00 |
| Seniors (65 and over) | 252 | $125.00 | $31,500.00 |
| Employer contract (per enrolled employee) | 72 | $70.00 | $5,040.00 |
| Panel | 1,068 |
At 30 September 2026 the practice had 996 active paying members and 72 contract members: a panel of 1,068. Its capacity is 750 members per physician, a case input tied to the visit length and same-day access the practice promises, so 1,500 with two physicians, and the panel filled 71.2 percent of it.
A month at the September 2026 panel brings $96,969.34 of membership fees collected: $92,280.00 of individual fees billed, less $350.66 of unpaid fees (0.38 percent of fees billed, the last fee of members who left for non-payment), plus $5,040.00 from the employer. Labs sent out and medicines dispensed are sold to members at posted prices, a case convention where the state allows it: $8,010.00 a month, which cost $5,874.00.
| Line | A month |
|---|---|
| Membership fees collected | $96,969.34 |
| Labs and medicines sold | $8,010.00 |
| Recurring revenue | $104,979.34 |
| Labs and medicines at cost | −$5,874.00 |
| Medical supplies | −$1,922.40 |
| Card processing, 2.9% of payments collected by card from members | −$2,898.24 |
| Left after variable costs | $94,284.70 |
Revenue per panel member = $104,979.34 ÷ 1,068 = $98.30 a month
Contribution per panel member = ($104,979.34 − $10,694.64) ÷ 1,068 = $88.28 a month
Enrollment fees ($75.00 once per new individual member, $3,000.00 a month at 40 new members) are real cash but one-time: they stay out of the contribution, so the break-even does not lean on new sign-ups.
The book goes further: seven Excel workbooks (membership fees and revenue, labs, medicines and cost per member, break-even, panel and growth, the employer contract, launch budget and financing, a second physician's units and distributions, selling the practice to a partner), each with an exercise and its answer. See The Direct Primary Care Practice Owner · PDF, $19.99
Break-even is the number of panel members at which what each member leaves after variable costs (labs and medicines at cost, supplies and card processing) covers the month's fixed costs, each physician's market pay with burden included. It is a break-even of EBITDA: it leaves out enrollment fees, depreciation, interest and every loan payment. It is rounded up to a whole member. The break-even after debt service adds the monthly loan payment to the fixed costs.
| Line | A month |
|---|---|
| Both physicians' market pay, with burden | $41,440 |
| Two medical assistants and the front desk, with burden | $12,880 |
| Rent | $4,800 |
| Software and telephone | $1,350 |
| Malpractice insurance | $1,500 |
| Accounting and legal, marketing, utilities and other | $2,800 |
| Fixed costs | $64,770 |
Break-even = $64,770 ÷ $88.28 = 734 panel members (rounded up), 48.9 percent of the capacity of 1,500
After debt service = ($64,770 + $2,534 of loan payment) ÷ $88.28 = 763 panel members
Actual: a panel of 1,068, 334 members above the break-even, which leaves $29,513 a month of EBITDA after both physicians' market pay
Each physician's market pay is $18,500 a month before burden, $20,720 with it, paid as a fixed cost from his first day. The payroll burden of 12.00 percent is the employer's social security and Medicare taxes of 7.65 percent plus a case rate for unemployment, workers' compensation and benefits.
The trap: leaving the physicians' pay out of the fixed costs. Without it the same arithmetic gives a far lower break-even, a figure that only says when the physicians start working for free. A practice that cannot pay its physicians at market has not broken even, and a buyer who replaces one would have to pay a successor that pay. Here EBITDA and every break-even are after it; a physician's income is his market pay plus his distributions on units, shown side by side and never added into one value.
The break-even moves with every fixed cost. Had the practice moved to a larger suite with rent up by $1,500 a month and nothing else changed, the break-even would rise to 751 panel members (50.1 percent of capacity) and 780 after debt service.
The founding physician opened alone, with fixed costs of $36,970 a month to September 2025. The practice's monthly EBITDA first reached zero in August 2024 with a panel of 413 members, enrollment fees included; by then the ramp had used $132,588 of the working capital left at opening, and the lowest month-end cash was $95,412. At 30 September 2025 the panel of 672 filled 89.6 percent of one physician's capacity of 750. That is when a second physician joined: capacity doubled to 1,500, and so did the physicians' pay in fixed costs. FY2026 EBITDA, $197,378, was lower than FY2025's $202,084 in dollars, with a second physician's market pay for twelve months and his panel still filling.
| Fiscal year | Panel | Revenue | EBITDA |
|---|---|---|---|
| FY2024 (opening year) | 432 | $386,227 | −$101,481 |
| FY2025 | 672 | $717,287 | $202,084 |
| FY2026 | 1,068 | $1,097,826 | $197,378 |
A panel grows by new members less departures. In September 2026 the practice signed 40 new individual members a month; monthly attrition of 1 percent of its 996 active paying members meant 10 departures, rounded to a whole member, so 30 net members added a month. With the panel already above the break-even, the months needed to reach it are zero; for a practice below it, the book's workbook divides the gap by the net members added, a smooth estimate rather than a month-by-month path. The article on converting monthly churn to annual churn shows why 1 percent a month is not 12 percent a year.
Which members a practice can take, and how long a visit lasts, are clinical and access decisions, never a target of this arithmetic. What a member pays, and how the tiers, the enrollment fee and the employer contract are set, is in how to price a direct primary care membership; whether a member's HSA can sit alongside the fee is in direct primary care and HSAs in 2026.
Rules checked on 18 November 2026, federal rules only, and not legal, tax, accounting or clinical advice. Calvenridge Direct Care, its employer under contract, its bank and its landlord are fictional: every case figure is a teaching assumption, not a norm. State law is for counsel in the practice's state.
No figure from the market is given here, because none was verified from a primary source. In the book's fictional two-physician practice the break-even was 734 panel members after both physicians' market pay, and 763 after the loan payment, against a capacity of 1,500.
Capacity is a promise about access, set by each practice. In the case it is 750 members per physician, a teaching assumption tied to the visit length and same-day access promised; the September 2026 panel of 1,068 filled 71.2 percent of two physicians' capacity.
Divide the month's fixed costs, each physician's market pay with burden included, by the contribution per panel member. In the case, $64,770 ÷ $88.28 = 734 members, rounded up; enrollment fees, depreciation, interest and loan payments are left out.
Yes, at market pay with burden. Leaving it out gives a far lower break-even, which only says when the physicians would work for free; in the case, with both physicians' pay the break-even is 734.
This article is one chapter's worth of arithmetic from The Direct Primary Care Practice Owner, which follows one fictional membership practice from its launch budget to a partner's offer for the founder's units: membership fees by age tier, fees billed, unpaid and collected, an employer contract, labs and medicines at posted prices, the panel and its capacity, break-even after both physicians' market pay, Medicare's opt-out and the 2026 HSA rule read at the source and dated, a second physician's units, distributions by units, and the value of the practice, never counting a physician's work, taken apart to the cash at closing.
DRM-free PDF, $19.99 · Paperback, $32.99, shipped worldwide · Free calculator