Articles

How many defence bids must a small supplier win to pay for the ones it loses?

Bid cost is a cost of the contracts a supplier wins. The break-even win rate shows whether the pipeline pays before the next proposal is written.

A small defence supplier that spends 90k writing each proposal and earns 270k of margin (9% of a 3.0m contract) on a win needs to win 33.3% of its bids to break even, or one in three. At a 20% win rate it takes 5 bids to win once, the bidding for that win costs 450k against 270k of margin, and a year of twelve bids loses 432k in expectation.

Writing a proposal for a defence tender is paid work with no invoice. A small supplier spends engineering time, a bid manager, legal review and sometimes a teaming partner’s fee, whether or not the award comes. The question that decides whether a pipeline is a business is simple: how often must the supplier win for the wins to pay for the losses?

The assumptions

One illustrative supplier
ItemValue
All-in cost per proposal (time, review, partner costs)90k
Contract value of a win3,000k
Margin on the contract9.0%
Margin earned on one win270k
Proposals submitted a year12

Step 1: the margin on a win

Margin on a win = contract value × margin

Excel: =ContractValue*Margin

3,000 × 9.0% = 270k. This is the only money a win brings in to pay for all the bids.

Step 2: the break-even win rate

Each bid costs 90k for certain and earns 270k with probability p. The expected value is zero when the two are equal.

Expected value per bid = p × margin on a win − cost per proposal

Break-even p = cost per proposal / margin on a win

Excel: =Cost/(ContractValue*Margin)

90 / 270 = 33.3%. Put another way, the supplier must win one bid in 3.

Step 3: the results across win rates

Expected result of one bid and of twelve a year (k)
Win rateBids per winBidding cost per winExpected value per bidExpected result of 12 bids
10.0%10.0900-63-756
15.0%6.7600-50-594
20.0%5.0450-36-432
25.0%4.0360-23-270
30.0%3.3300-9-108
33.3%3.027000
40.0%2.522518216
50.0%2.018045540

At a 20% win rate: 12 × 0.20 = 2.4 wins a year, worth 2.4 × 270 = 648k of margin, against 12 × 90 = 1,080k of bidding. The year loses 432k. The break-even row shows the same pipeline at exactly one win in three, where the result is zero.

What if: the margin or the cost of a proposal changes

The break-even moves with both inputs. At a 6% margin the margin on a win is 180k and the break-even is 50.0%; at 12% it is 360k and 25.0%. If reuse of earlier proposal text brings the cost of a proposal down to 60k, the break-even at a 9% margin falls from 33.3% to 22.2%, and a supplier winning 20% of its bids earns -6k per bid (-72k on twelve) instead of losing 36k.

The common mistakes

Takeaway

Questions readers ask

What win rate should a defence supplier assume?

Its own, counted over every proposal it has submitted, not a market average. If the history shows 1 win in 5, use 20%; against 90k of cost and 270k of margin that is a loss of 36k per bid.

Does a larger contract fix a losing bid ratio?

Only if the margin grows with it. At a 9% margin, raising the contract from 3.0m to 4.5m lifts the margin on a win to 405k and lowers the break-even win rate to 22.2% from 33.3%, provided the proposal does not cost more to write.

Should a lost bid ever be written off as a sunk cost?

For the decision to bid on the next tender, yes: only its own 90k counts. For judging the pipeline, no: all twelve bids together cost 1,080k and must be recovered by the wins.

The workbooks behind this article

The workbooks for this book cost a defence proposal on dated inputs, including what a proposal takes to write. The win-rate table in this article is a separate illustration and is not in them.

Open the companion files →

Not on Amazon: 19 paperbacks by Julian R. Sterling on energy, infrastructure and land, printed on demand and shipped worldwide. Browse the bookshop →

Also on this site

Reading guide: regulation, compliance and banking → · All 1908 articles →