Bid cost is a cost of the contracts a supplier wins. The break-even win rate shows whether the pipeline pays before the next proposal is written.
A small defence supplier that spends 90k writing each proposal and earns 270k of margin (9% of a 3.0m contract) on a win needs to win 33.3% of its bids to break even, or one in three. At a 20% win rate it takes 5 bids to win once, the bidding for that win costs 450k against 270k of margin, and a year of twelve bids loses 432k in expectation.
Writing a proposal for a defence tender is paid work with no invoice. A small supplier spends engineering time, a bid manager, legal review and sometimes a teaming partner’s fee, whether or not the award comes. The question that decides whether a pipeline is a business is simple: how often must the supplier win for the wins to pay for the losses?
| Item | Value |
|---|---|
| All-in cost per proposal (time, review, partner costs) | 90k |
| Contract value of a win | 3,000k |
| Margin on the contract | 9.0% |
| Margin earned on one win | 270k |
| Proposals submitted a year | 12 |
Margin on a win = contract value × margin
Excel: =ContractValue*Margin
3,000 × 9.0% = 270k. This is the only money a win brings in to pay for all the bids.
Each bid costs 90k for certain and earns 270k with probability p. The expected value is zero when the two are equal.
Expected value per bid = p × margin on a win − cost per proposal
Break-even p = cost per proposal / margin on a win
Excel: =Cost/(ContractValue*Margin)
90 / 270 = 33.3%. Put another way, the supplier must win one bid in 3.
| Win rate | Bids per win | Bidding cost per win | Expected value per bid | Expected result of 12 bids |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 10.0% | 10.0 | 900 | -63 | -756 |
| 15.0% | 6.7 | 600 | -50 | -594 |
| 20.0% | 5.0 | 450 | -36 | -432 |
| 25.0% | 4.0 | 360 | -23 | -270 |
| 30.0% | 3.3 | 300 | -9 | -108 |
| 33.3% | 3.0 | 270 | 0 | 0 |
| 40.0% | 2.5 | 225 | 18 | 216 |
| 50.0% | 2.0 | 180 | 45 | 540 |
At a 20% win rate: 12 × 0.20 = 2.4 wins a year, worth 2.4 × 270 = 648k of margin, against 12 × 90 = 1,080k of bidding. The year loses 432k. The break-even row shows the same pipeline at exactly one win in three, where the result is zero.
The break-even moves with both inputs. At a 6% margin the margin on a win is 180k and the break-even is 50.0%; at 12% it is 360k and 25.0%. If reuse of earlier proposal text brings the cost of a proposal down to 60k, the break-even at a 9% margin falls from 33.3% to 22.2%, and a supplier winning 20% of its bids earns -6k per bid (-72k on twelve) instead of losing 36k.
Its own, counted over every proposal it has submitted, not a market average. If the history shows 1 win in 5, use 20%; against 90k of cost and 270k of margin that is a loss of 36k per bid.
Only if the margin grows with it. At a 9% margin, raising the contract from 3.0m to 4.5m lifts the margin on a win to 405k and lowers the break-even win rate to 22.2% from 33.3%, provided the proposal does not cost more to write.
For the decision to bid on the next tender, yes: only its own 90k counts. For judging the pipeline, no: all twelve bids together cost 1,080k and must be recovered by the wins.
The workbooks for this book cost a defence proposal on dated inputs, including what a proposal takes to write. The win-rate table in this article is a separate illustration and is not in them.
Not on Amazon: 19 paperbacks by Julian R. Sterling on energy, infrastructure and land, printed on demand and shipped worldwide. Browse the bookshop →
Reading guide: regulation, compliance and banking → · All 1908 articles →