Articles

How far does a catastrophe bond fall in price when the risk model raises its expected loss?

Cat bonds are priced as a multiple of modelled expected loss. When the modeller raises the expected loss, the price depends on whether the market keeps the multiple or the premium over expected loss.

If the expected loss rises from 2.00% to 2.60% and the market keeps the 3.0x multiple, the required spread rises from 6.00% to 7.80% and the bond falls from 100 to 95.66, a 4.34-point drop. If the market keeps the 4.00% premium over expected loss, the spread rises only to 6.60% and the price is 98.52.

The assumptions

Illustrative floating-rate catastrophe bond, invented figures
ItemValue
Bond3 years remaining, annual coupons, par 100, floating coupon equal to the reference rate plus the spread
Reference rate4.00%, paid on the collateral account and flat for the life of the bond
Spread at issue6.00%, with the bond priced at par
Modelled expected loss2.00% a year before the update, 2.60% after it
Position$40.0m of notional

Expected loss is the annual probability that principal is lost, multiplied by the share lost. The reference rate is paid on the collateral, so the investor is paid the spread for taking the insurance risk and the price reacts to the spread alone.

Step 1: the multiple and the premium before the update

Multiple: spread ÷ expected loss = 6.00% ÷ 2.00% = 3.0x

Premium over expected loss: 6.00% − 2.00% = 4.00%

The two ways of holding the price steady give different answers once the expected loss moves, so the market has to pick one

Step 2: the price if the market holds the multiple

Required spread: 3.0 × 2.60% = 7.80%, so the bond is discounted at 4.00% + 7.80% = 11.80%

Cash flows: coupons of 4.00% + 6.00% = 10.00 a year and 100 of principal in year 3

Present value: 10.00 ÷ 1.118 + 10.00 ÷ 1.250 + 110.00 ÷ 1.397 = 8.94 + 8.00 + 78.72 = 95.66

Loss on $40.0m: 4.34% × 40.0 = $1.74m

Excel: =PV(0.04+0.078,3,-10,-100)

Step 3: the price if the market holds the premium

Required spread: 4.00% + 2.60% = 6.60%, so the discount rate is 10.60%

Price: =PV(0.04+0.066,3,-10,-100) = 98.52, a fall of 1.48 points or $0.59m on $40.0m

The multiple would then be 2.54x, against 3.0x before

The bond has a spread duration of 2.49 years, so each 1.00 point of spread moves the price by about 2.49 points. The multiple convention adds 1.80 points of spread and the premium convention 0.60.

Price by the new expected loss, 3 years remaining
New expected lossSpread at 3.0xPriceChangeSpread at 4.00% premiumPriceChange
1.50%4.50%103.83+3.83%5.50%101.25+1.25%
2.00%6.00%100.000.00%6.00%100.000.00%
2.60%7.80%95.66−4.34%6.60%98.52−1.48%
3.00%9.00%92.92−7.08%7.00%97.56−2.44%
3.50%10.50%89.64−10.36%7.50%96.37−3.63%

At a constant multiple a 0.50-point rise in expected loss (to 2.50%) costs 3.63 points of price and a 0.50-point fall (to 1.50%) adds 3.83, so each 0.10 point of expected loss is worth about 0.75 points. The multiple convention magnifies the update three times, since every 0.10 point of expected loss becomes 0.30 point of spread.

What if: the bond is different

Price at a 2.60% expected loss by bond characteristics
CaseSpread at constant multiplePrice at constant multipleChangeChange at constant premium
Base case: 3 years left, 3.0x multiple7.80%95.66−4.34%−1.48%
1 year left7.80%98.39−1.61%−0.54%
5 years left7.80%93.48−6.52%−2.24%
Spread 4.00%, multiple 2.0x5.20%96.97−3.03%−1.53%
Spread 8.00%, multiple 4.0x10.40%94.47−5.53%−1.43%

Shorter bonds move less, with −1.61% at one year against −6.52% at five. The model assumes the required spread resets instantly and ignores the secondary market bid-ask spread and any change in the multiple the market demands after a model change.

The common mistakes

Takeaway

Questions readers ask

How far does a cat bond fall when the risk model raises its expected loss?

From 100 to 95.66 if the market holds a 3.0x multiple, and to 98.52 if it holds the 4.00% premium, for a 3-year bond with expected loss rising from 2.00% to 2.60%.

Does the market hold the multiple or the premium?

It depends on the bond and the cycle. Holding the multiple gives a required spread of 7.80% and holding the premium 6.60%, so the two conventions bracket the likely price between 95.66 and 98.52.

Why does a shorter bond move less?

Spread duration is lower. A bond with one year left falls 1.61 points for the same expected loss update, against 4.34 with three years left.

The workbooks behind this article

The free companion files for The Catastrophe Bond Investor rebuild a fictional UCITS cat bond fund: three bonds, their coupons, expected losses and multiples, a partial loss on an aggregate bond, the portfolio’s VaR and TVaR and the fund’s results. The single bond in this article uses invented probabilities and is not in them. No account and no email address.

Open the companion files →

Not on Amazon: 36 paperbacks by Julian R. Sterling on how to read the documents, printed on demand and shipped worldwide. Browse the bookshop →

Also on this site

Reading guide: credit, private credit and distressed debt → · All 1908 articles →