Articles

How are earnout disputes resolved?

The statement, the notice of disagreement, 30 days of talks and an independent accountant, worked on one disputed period.

The case's agreement resolves disputes in a fixed sequence: the buyer delivers an earnout statement, the sellers review it and deliver a notice of disagreement item by item, the parties negotiate for a set period, and the items still open go to an independent accountant who decides only those items, within the range of the two positions. In the worked case the buyer said $13,960,000 of earnout EBITDA, the sellers $15,240,000, and the accountant decided $14,710,000.

Worked in full in The Earnout Handbook by Julian R. Sterling, with every figure reproduced in a free workbook.Get the DRM-free PDF, $19.99 →

The case

The case is fictional: Corrimont Water Technologies, a platform owned by a private equity fund, buys Wendhallow Hydrometrics, a founder-owned maker of leak, pressure and water-quality sensors, for $96,000,000 in cash at closing and an earnout of up to $24,000,000 over three years. Every term below is a teaching assumption of that case, not a market norm, and the definitions in your own purchase agreement govern. Period 2, year 2, paid on earnout EBITDA on a straight line from a threshold of $13,500,000 to a target of $15,500,000, for up to $7,000,000. It is the period the parties disagreed about.

Step 1: the statement, and what has to come with it

The case's schedule gives the buyer 90 days after the period ends to deliver its statement, in the schedule's worked format and with its supporting files. The buyer's chief financial officer delivered on day 88: earnout EBITDA of $13,960,000, so a payment of $7,000,000 x ($13,960,000 - $13,500,000) / $2,000,000 = $1,610,000. A statement that arrives without the bridge and the files behind each adjustment is not a statement the sellers can review; it is a figure, and it invites a general objection.

Step 2: pay what is not disputed

Payment falls due on day 120 after the period ends, and the case writes that an undisputed amount is paid on that day even while other items are disputed. The buyer paid its own figure, $1,610,000, on day 120, before the sellers had even delivered their notice. That rule is worth more than it looks: it stops one contested line from holding back the whole payment, and it removes the incentive to delay.

Step 3: the notice of disagreement, item by item

The sellers had 45 days after delivery, with access to the books and to the people. Their notice, on day 131, said earnout EBITDA of $15,240,000 and a payment of $6,090,000, and it named three items, each with an amount and a reason. In the case, an item not named in the notice is accepted: a general objection to the statement would have preserved nothing. Whether your own agreement reads that way is a question for counsel.

Fictional case, period 2 disputed add-backs, dollars
ItemBuyerSellersExpertAwarded to sellers
Integration costs$800,000$1,400,000$1,250,000$450,000 of $600,000
Group recharge$520,000$900,000$680,000$160,000 of $380,000
Transfer price on sales to other divisions$250,000$550,000$390,000$140,000 of $300,000

Step 4: thirty days, then the accountant

The case allows 30 days of negotiation. Nothing settled, so all three items went to an independent accountant, engaged on day 175. The case's wording has the accountant decide only the items still in dispute, within the range of the two positions, acting as an expert and not as an arbitrator. That wording matters: an expert decides an accounting question on the documents; an arbitrator decides a legal dispute with the procedure that goes with it. Which one a court would see in a given clause is for the company's counsel, and depends on the words used.

The determination came on day 300, and its reasons were short. On integration costs, the accountant kept $150,000 of recurring software licences as ordinary operating costs the business would have bought anyway. On the group recharge, it accepted insurance and audit as replaced standalone costs, $620,000, and rejected treasury and legal services the company had never bought on its own. On the transfer price, it applied the schedule price list less 15 percent to the invoices it could match, $140,000 of the $300,000 claimed. In total the sellers had claimed $1,280,000 of add-backs and were awarded $750,000, so earnout EBITDA became $13,960,000 + $750,000 = $14,710,000, inside both positions on every item.

Step 5: pay the award, the interest and the fees

The final payment was $7,000,000 x ($14,710,000 - $13,500,000) / $2,000,000 = $4,235,000. With $1,610,000 already paid, the award was $4,235,000 - $1,610,000 = $2,625,000, paid on day 315, 15 days after the determination, with simple interest at 8.0 percent a year from day 120: $2,625,000 x 8 percent x 195 / 365 = $112,192. The interest sits outside the earnout and its cap.

The accountant's fees of $180,000 were shared in proportion to what each party lost on the disputed items. The buyer lost $750,000 of the $1,280,000 claimed and bore $105,469; the sellers bore $74,531. A fee rule of that kind rewards a reasonable notice and penalizes a padded one, on both sides.

Fictional case, period 2 calendar, days after period 2 ends
DayEvent
Day 88Buyer delivers the period 2 earnout statement: earnout EBITDA $13,960,000, payment $1,610,000
Day 120Undisputed amount of $1,610,000 paid
Day 131Sellers' notice of disagreement, item by item: earnout EBITDA $15,240,000, payment $6,090,000
Day 161End of the 30 days of negotiation; three items still open
Day 175Independent accountant engaged
Day 300Determination: earnout EBITDA $14,710,000, payment $4,235,000
Day 315Amount awarded, $2,625,000, paid with interest of $112,192
The trap. Treating the dispute as a single number. Each item has its own clause, its own evidence and its own effect: the period 2 figure also moved the catch-up a year later, the escrow deposit on the award, the compensation booked for the founders' share and the buyer's remeasurement of the contingent consideration. Compute the consequences of each outcome before the determination, not after.

What to draft before anyone disagrees

Every step above came from a clause written at signing: the 90-day statement with its format, the 45-day review with access, the item-by-item notice, the 30 days of talks, the expert's mandate and its range, the undisputed payment on day 120, interest on a late award, and a fee rule. None of them decides who is right; together they decide how long being right takes, and what it costs.

Questions people ask

Who decides an earnout dispute?

Whoever the agreement names. In the case, an independent accountant chosen under the agreement decides the accounting items still open after negotiation, and it decides only those items, within the range of the two positions, acting as an expert and not as an arbitrator.

Is the undisputed part of an earnout paid while the dispute runs?

In the case, yes: the undisputed amount, $1,610,000, was paid on day 120 even while other items were disputed.

Who pays the independent accountant?

It depends on the agreement. In the case the $180,000 of fees is shared in proportion to what each side lost on the disputed items: $105,469 for the buyer and $74,531 for the sellers.

Is interest due on an amount awarded late?

If the agreement says so. In the case, simple interest at 8.0 percent a year from day 120: $112,192 on the $2,625,000 awarded, paid on day 315.

Read the whole case

This article is one step of The Earnout Handbook. The book follows one earnout from the term sheet to the release of the escrow: the payment curves, the calculation schedule, three statements, a dispute, set-off and escrow, the founders' share, five scenarios under ASC 805 and federal tax in principle, with every figure a live formula in the free workbook.

Paperback PDF edition, $19.99 Book page and free files

Free: the earnout scenario calculator in Excel.

Also on this site

Case figures computed by the book's model; the companies are fictional and every term is a teaching assumption. Figures checked on 18 November 2026.