Articles

How does an annual default rate compound into a five-year default probability?

A rating's one-year default rate is not a five-year figure: survivors compound, and summing the annual rates overstates the total.

With an illustrative annual default probability of 0.25%, a BBB issuer has a 1.24% probability of default within five years, from the survival formula 1 − (1 − p)5. A BB issuer at 1.10% reaches 5.38% and a B issuer at 4.00% reaches 18.46%, not the 20.00% that adding five annual rates gives. If a BBB issuer is cut to BB after two years the five-year figure becomes 3.75%.

The assumptions

Illustrative constant annual default probabilities, not agency statistics
RatingAnnual default probability
BBB0.25%
BB1.10%
B4.00%

Each rate is the probability that an issuer rated that way at the start of a year defaults within the year, assumed constant and independent from one year to the next. Real default studies show rates that vary with the cycle and with the rating drift of survivors; the assumption keeps the arithmetic visible.

Step 1: survive each year, then take the complement

To default by year n an issuer must not survive all n years. If it survives each year with probability 1 − p, the chance of surviving n years is (1 − p)n.

Survival over n years = (1 − p)n

Cumulative default probability = 1 − (1 − p)n

Excel: =1-(1-p)^n

For BBB at 0.25% a year over five years, survival is 98.756% and the cumulative default probability is 1 − 0.98756 = 1.24%.

Step 2: the table by horizon

Cumulative default probability by horizon
RatingAnnual1 year3 years5 years10 years
BBB0.25%0.25%0.75%1.24%2.47%
BB1.10%1.10%3.26%5.38%10.47%
B4.00%4.00%11.53%18.46%33.52%

Step 3: the sum of annual rates overstates

Adding the annual rates counts the same issuer more than once: one that defaults in year two cannot default again in year three. The error is small for low rates and large for high ones.

Sum of annual rates against the cumulative probability
Rating5 years: sumcumulativegap10 years: sumcumulativegap
BBB1.25%1.24%0.01%2.50%2.47%0.03%
BB5.50%5.38%0.12%11.00%10.47%0.53%
B20.00%18.46%1.54%40.00%33.52%6.48%

For B the ten-year sum of 40.00% exceeds the cumulative 33.52% by 6.48 points, 19% too high; for BBB the gap over five years is 0.006 points.

Step 4: going back from a cumulative figure

Studies often quote cumulative rates. A five-year cumulative default probability of 10.00% implies a constant annual rate of 1 − (1 − 0.10)1/5 = 2.09% a year, not 2.00%, which is the simple average.

Annual rate = 1 − (1 − cumulative)1/n

Excel: =1-(1-Cum)^(1/n)

What if: the issuer is downgraded to BB after two years

A BBB issuer is cut to BB at the end of year two, as in the case of a group that loses its investment grade. The first two years carry 0.25%; the next three carry 1.10%. Survival is the product of the yearly survival probabilities, and the default probability of a given year is the survival to its start times that year’s rate.

BBB for two years, then BB
YearRatingAnnual rateDefault in the year (from today)SurvivalCumulative default
Year 1BBB0.25%0.25%99.75%0.25%
Year 2BBB0.25%0.25%99.50%0.50%
Year 3BB1.10%1.09%98.41%1.59%
Year 4BB1.10%1.08%97.32%2.68%
Year 5BB1.10%1.07%96.25%3.75%

The five-year cumulative probability is 3.75%, against 1.24% for an issuer that stays BBB and 5.38% for one that was BB throughout. The downgrade in year three adds 2.50 points, about 2.0 times the 1.24% of the BBB path. The probability of defaulting in year three, seen from today, is 1.09%, but given survival to that point it is 1.10%.

The common mistakes

Takeaway

Questions readers ask

How do you convert an annual default rate into a multi-year rate?

Raise the annual survival probability to the power of the number of years and take the complement: 1 minus (1 minus p) to the n. At 0.25% a year over five years the result is 1.24%.

Why is the sum of annual default rates wrong?

It counts an issuer that has already defaulted as still at risk in later years. For B over ten years the sum is 40.00% and the cumulative probability 33.52%.

What does a downgrade do to the default probability?

It raises the annual rate for the remaining years. BBB for two years then BB gives a five-year probability of 3.75% against 1.24% for an issuer that stays BBB.

The workbooks behind this article

The free companion files for The Credit Rating Analyst rebuild the Thornvale case from its first BBB rating to its fall below investment grade, with the adjusted metrics, the scorecard and the dashboard of triggers. The default arithmetic in this article uses invented rates and is not in them. No account and no email address.

Open the companion files →

Not on Amazon: 36 paperbacks by Julian R. Sterling on how to read the documents, printed on demand and shipped worldwide. Browse the bookshop →

Also on this site

Reading guide: credit, private credit and distressed debt → · All 1908 articles →