For a consulting practice below the QBI threshold, an S corporation salary takes income out of the 20 percent deduction, and the payroll tax saving can disappear. Once income enters the phase-in range, the election can pay.
On $405,400 of profit in 2027, a married owner would keep $298,988 as a sole proprietor and $298,133 as an S corporation paying herself $170,000: $855 less. The election breaks even at a salary of about $165,000. At $549,652 of profit it would save $13,139.
An S corporation pays its owner a salary, subject to payroll tax, and passes the rest of the profit through without it. That saving is real. But a fractional CFO practice would probably be a specified service business under section 199A (accounting, consulting and financial services are among the listed fields), and the owner's salary is not qualified business income. Below the threshold, $416,600 of taxable income on a joint return for 2027 under Rev. Proc. 2026-35, a sole proprietor deducts up to 20 percent of the whole profit. The S corporation owner deducts 20 percent of what is left after the salary.
| Profit $405,400 | Sole proprietor | S corporation, salary $170,000 |
|---|---|---|
| Self-employment or payroll taxes | $35,821 | $26,430 |
| QBI deduction | $70,970 | $43,675 |
| Federal income tax | $52,849 | $59,478 |
| Kept after all taxes and costs | $298,988 | $298,133 |
A sole proprietor pays self-employment tax of 12.4 percent on 92.35 percent of net earnings up to the Social Security wage base, $192,300 in 2027, and 2.9 percent on all of it, plus 0.9 percent on self-employment income above $250,000 on a joint return. The cap limits what the S corporation can save. The election here saves payroll taxes, loses QBI deduction, and adds $3,600 of payroll service and a separate return.
Worked in full in The Fractional CFO by Julian R. Sterling.Get the DRM-free PDF, $19.99 →or the paperback
Free: the fractional CFO pricing calculator in Excel: paper and worked rate per tier, clients per CFO, the margin of a contractor-delivered client and a creep stress test, with its checks.
The IRS requires an S corporation to pay a working owner reasonable compensation before distributions. In the case, a salary of $130,000 would leave the owner $305,432, ahead of the sole proprietorship; $210,000 would leave $290,834. What is reasonable for a CFO's work is for the CPA to judge, and the answer sets the sign of the result.
Between $416,600 and $566,600 of taxable income, a specified service business keeps only part of its deduction, and the salary of an S corporation counts as W-2 wages for the limit. In the worked case, at $549,652 of profit, the owner would keep $393,841 as an S corporation against $380,702 as a sole proprietor, $13,139 more, on 2027 amounts: the election can pay well before the end of the range.
A specified service business loses the QBI deduction entirely once taxable income passes $566,600 on a joint return. The deduction is then gone under both structures, and the S corporation mainly takes the pass-through income out of Medicare tax. At $714,900 of profit, on 2027 amounts, the owner would keep $483,487 as an S corporation against $468,623 as a sole proprietor.
For an owner who works in the practice, neither the sole proprietor's profit nor the S corporation's pass-through income would normally be net investment income under section 1411. A passive partner or a sale of the practice raises separate questions.
Do the comparison every autumn, on next year's projected profit, with your state's rules on S corporations and entity-level taxes and a salary your CPA can defend.
Figures checked on 18 November 2026. The practice in the examples is fictional and its figures are teaching assumptions, not market norms, quotes or rules of law. Not legal, tax, accounting or investment advice.
An LLC can be taxed either way. Below the QBI threshold, a specified service business may keep more as a sole proprietor; inside the phase-in range and above it, the S corporation election often pays. Run both on your own figures with your CPA.
Reasonable compensation for the services provided, judged on the facts by the CPA; the worked example tests $130,000, $170,000 and $210,000.
Probably: accounting, consulting and financial services are listed fields. The practice's facts decide, and the CPA should confirm.
This article is one step from The Fractional CFO, a practitioner’s guide to building, pricing and running a part-time CFO practice: retainers and scope, capacity, contract CFOs, engagement letters, the S corporation question and what the practice is worth, worked through one practice.
DRM-free PDF, $19.99 · Paperback, $32.99, shipped worldwide · Free Excel calculator