Give before any binding agreement, value the shares with a qualified appraisal inside its window, and price the routes at equal base, counting the tax the trust payments will still carry.
Shares of a private company held more than a year and given to a public charity before the company is sold are deducted at fair market value within 30 percent of the contribution base, and the donor does not sell them, as read in November 2026. The gift has to come before the sale is practically certain, with a qualified appraisal signed inside its window. In the example below, giving $720,000 of shares to a donor-advised fund and $1,800,000 to a unitrust before the sale leaves the family $594,100 more than selling and giving the same value in cash, before the tax on the unitrust payments.
Worked in full in The Charitable Planning Handbook by Julian R. Sterling.Get the DRM-free PDF, $19.99 →or the paperback
Free: the charitable remainder trust calculator in Excel, which turns a gift to a term unitrust into its remainder factor, the 10 percent test, the deduction year by year under the limit and the floor, and the projected payments.
An owner who sells a company and then gives part of the proceeds pays tax on the whole gain, then deducts a cash gift. An owner who gives shares before the sale does not sell the shares given. As read in November 2026, private company shares held more than a year and given to a public charity are deducted at fair market value, within 30 percent of the contribution base, and the gain on them leaves the donor’s return for the year of the sale.
The book follows a fictional sale file. Graham and Elise Ormsley own all 1,000,000 shares of Pemberford Engineering Services, a C corporation, with a basis of $0.30 a share. A buyer signs a non-binding letter of intent at $18.00 a share on 14 April 2026. The shares do not qualify for the small business stock exclusion: engineering is one of the fields section 1202(e)(3) lists. The couple wants part of the value to go to charity.
The risk has a name: assignment of income. If the sale is, in the words courts have used, practically certain when the shares are given, the donor may be treated as having sold the shares and given the proceeds, and taxed on the gain on shares the donor no longer owns. Court decisions on gifts made shortly before a closing were read for this article only in secondary summaries, so the principle is all that is stated here. A binding agreement is the clearest line; courts have looked earlier. The later the gift, the stronger the argument that the donor sold the shares and gave the proceeds.
The practice in the book writes its own rule into the file: no gift of shares once a binding agreement is signed, or once the sale is practically certain, and the client’s attorney confirms the timing in writing. The calendar of the case follows it:
| Date (fictional) | Step |
|---|---|
| 14 April 2026 | Non-binding letter of intent at $18.00 a share: the buyer can walk away, the couple can refuse |
| 1 June 2026 | Qualified appraisal signed |
| 12 June 2026 | Unitrust agreement signed, drafted by the client’s attorney |
| 15 June 2026 | 40,000 shares to the donor-advised fund, 100,000 shares to the unitrust |
| 21 September 2026 | Binding stock purchase agreement signed |
| 12 January 2027 | Closing: the couple, the DAF sponsor and the trustee each sell at $18.00 a share |
Private shares have no market price, so the deduction rests on paper. As read in November 2026: a qualified appraisal is required for a deduction of more than $5,000 for property, and it is attached to the return when the deduction is more than $500,000. It must be signed and dated no earlier than 60 days before the gift and no later than the due date, with extensions, of the return that first claims the deduction (26 CFR 1.170A-17). Form 8283 Section B covers property deducted at more than $5,000 per item or group of similar items, and all shares of nonpublicly traded stock count as one item; the donee signs Part V. Any gift of $250 or more needs a contemporaneous written acknowledgment from the donee.
In the case, the appraisal is signed on 1 June 2026, within the window, and concludes at $18.00 a share, a case assumption: a real appraisal can differ from a letter of intent. The DAF sponsor’s acknowledgment of 22 June 2026 describes the shares and states that no goods or services were provided.
The trap: treating the price in the letter of intent as the value. The deduction rests on the appraisal, signed inside its window.
The 100,000 shares, worth $1,800,000, go to a charitable remainder unitrust for 15 years. It pays the couple 9.0 percent of its value each year, and what is left at the end goes to the DAF sponsor for their fund. As read in section 664(d), the percentage must be between 5 and 50 percent, the term no longer than 20 years, and the remainder at least 10 percent of the value contributed. At the June 2026 Section 7520 rate of 5.0 percent, the remainder factor is 0.260753, so the test passes and the deduction for the remainder is $1,800,000 x 0.260753 = $469,355. The same rate in an annuity trust paying a fixed 9.0 percent would fail the test; for how that other trust works, see how a charitable remainder annuity trust works.
The CPA prices three routes on the same $18,000,000 of shares and the same two years: (a) sell everything and give nothing; (b) sell everything, then give $1,189,355 in cash to the donor-advised fund in 2027; (c) give the shares to the fund and the unitrust in 2026, before the binding agreement. In every row, family, charity and the tax caused by the sale and the gifts add up to the value of the shares.
| Scenario (fictional) | Family | Charity, gift-date value | Tax caused |
|---|---|---|---|
| (a) Sell, no gift | $13,787,400 | $0 | $4,212,600 |
| (b) Sell, then give cash | $12,979,844 | $1,189,355 | $3,830,801 |
| (c) Give shares before the sale | $13,573,944 | $1,189,355 | $3,236,701 |
Giving costs the family money in every route: $807,556 in (b) and $213,456 in (c), against (a). For the same gift to charity, (c) leaves the family $594,100 more than (b). The whole difference is tax.
The two blocks of shares do not leave the couple’s hands in the same way. The gain on the 40,000 shares given to the fund is never taxed to anyone in the family. The 100,000 shares given to the trust are sold by the trust at closing, for a gain of 100,000 x $17.70 = $1,770,000. The trust itself is not subject to income tax, as section 664(c)(1) reads in November 2026, but its payments are taxed to the couple in the order section 664(b) sets: ordinary income first, then capital gain, then other income, then corpus. The trust’s gain sits in the capital gain tier, and it reaches the couple as the payments carry it out over the 15 years.
The scenario table counts the unitrust interest at its gift-date value, before that tax. That favors (c). As an order of magnitude only, undiscounted and at the case’s rates of 20 percent plus 3.8 percent, the whole gain reaching the couple would mean $1,770,000 x 23.8 percent = $421,260 of tax, spread over 15 years of payments, so its present value is lower. Part of the $594,100 is therefore a deferral, not a saving, and the CPA writes that beside the figure. The choice of (c) in the book does not turn on it: the fund’s share of the gift is a gain the family is never taxed on, and the trust’s share is taxed later rather than at closing.
Rules as read in November 2026 in the Internal Revenue Code, Public Law 119-21, Treasury regulations and publications of the Internal Revenue Service; amounts, rates and procedures change, so check the current figure on irs.gov. US federal income tax only, illustrative, and not tax, legal or investment advice; for a real gift, consult a qualified tax professional and the donor’s attorney. The donors, the practice, the company and the figures in the examples are fictional teaching assumptions, and nothing here promises any tax result.
A non-binding letter of intent leaves both sides free, but the later the gift, the weaker the donor's position. A binding agreement is the clearest line, and courts have looked earlier. The donor's attorney decides the timing.
Yes, for a deduction of more than $5,000, signed no earlier than 60 days before the gift; it is attached to the return when the deduction is more than $500,000, with Form 8283 Section B signed by the donee.
The trust itself is not subject to income tax when it sells, as read in section 664(c)(1), but the gain comes back to the donors in the capital gain tier of their payments over the term. It is deferred and spread, not removed.
Shares of a private company given to a private nonoperating foundation are deducted at basis, not at value, because they are not qualified appreciated stock. In the case, that is $12,000 instead of $720,000 for the same 40,000 shares.
This article is one step of The Charitable Planning Handbook, an adviser’s guide to charitable planning for wealthy clients: the deduction rules by donee, property and limit, the 2025 law in force from 2026, gifts of appreciated and private company shares before a sale, the qualified appraisal and Form 8283, donor-advised funds and private foundations, charitable remainder and lead trusts, qualified charitable distributions and bunching, and the year-end file, with five companion workbooks.
DRM-free PDF, $19.99 · Paperback, $32.99, shipped worldwide · Free Excel calculator