Articles

Covenant waiver vs amendment: which one do you ask for?

A waiver forgives one breach; an amendment changes the terms. What each covers, what each costs, and when to ask, on one case.

A covenant waiver forgives a specific breach at a specific test date and leaves the terms as they were; an amendment changes the terms themselves, such as the levels, the definitions or the schedule, for the quarters to come. In the worked case a waiver of one breach would cost $855,497 and leave a new breach one quarter later, while the amendment costs $1,799,750 plus a higher margin and, with three operating levers, holds to the end of the forecast.

Worked in full in The Covenant Compliance Handbook by Julian R. Sterling, with every figure reproduced in a free workbook.Get the DRM-free PDF, $19.99 →

Two different questions

A waiver answers the question "will you forgive this breach?" An amendment answers "will you change the rules we are tested against?" The first looks back at one test date; the second looks forward over several. Which one to ask for depends less on the breach than on the forecast: if the next test date passes, a waiver may be enough; if the next one breaks too, a waiver only buys three months.

The case is a fictional company owned by a private equity sponsor. Its downside forecast breaks the net leverage maximum at Q3 year 4, at 5.87x against 5.75x, and stays in breach at every test date after it. All terms below are teaching assumptions of the case, negotiated in the story; they are not market norms, and what an event of default would allow the lenders to do is set by your own agreement and read by the company's counsel.

Side by side

Fictional case, downside, terms requested in Q2 year 4
WaiverAmendment
What it coversThe leverage breach of Q3 year 4 onlyLevels, cap and liquidity from Q3 year 4 to Q4 year 5
Fee0.25 percent of loans outstanding: $855,4970.50 percent of term loans and commitment: $1,799,750
Marginunchanged+0.50 percent, about $1,710,993 a year
Conditionsthose of the waiver lettermonthly reporting, a monthly 13-week forecast, sponsor fees deferred, no acquisition draws
Next test dateQ4 year 4: 6.03x against 5.75x, a new breachQ4 year 4: 5.67x against 6.50x with the levers

The waiver is cheaper on paper and useless in this forecast. The steps stay where they were, and at Q4 year 4 the downside reads 6.03x against 5.75x: a second breach, a second request, and a lender who now knows the company asked for less than it needed. The amendment in the case resets the maximum to 6.50x for four quarters and 6.25x for the last two, lowers the minimum FCCR to 0.95x, raises minimum liquidity to $25,000,000 and cuts the cap on capped add-backs from 7.5 percent to 5.0 percent. The lenders give room on the ratio and take some back on the definitions.

An amendment alone is not a plan

The case runs the amendment on its own before running it with anything else, and the result is the reason to do so:

Fictional case, downside: amendment alone against the combination with levers (a) to (c)
QuarterAmendment aloneMaximumLiquidity, aloneCombinationCushion
Q3 year 45.90x6.50x$26,331,2455.85x10.1 percent
Q4 year 46.07x6.50x$28,053,3505.67x12.7 percent
Q1 year 56.27x6.50x$25,465,4565.75x11.6 percent
Q2 year 56.29x6.50x$24,384,7435.73x11.9 percent
Q3 year 56.21x6.25x$25,542,9185.66x9.5 percent
Q4 year 56.12x6.25x$27,461,5725.57x10.8 percent

On its own, the amendment fails at Q2 year 5 on the new liquidity minimum it raised, $24,384,743 against $25,000,000, and holds the dates around it by thin margins: $25,465,456 of liquidity at Q1 year 5, 6.21x against 6.25x at Q3 year 5. The three operating levers alone hold from Q3 year 4 to Q2 year 5 and break at the step-down of Q3 year 5, at 5.63x against 5.50x. With the three operating levers and the amendment, cost actions, capex moved inside the cap and a working capital release, recomputed together rather than added, every test date complies to Q4 year 5. The lowest cushion of the combination is 9.5 percent at Q3 year 5, the amended step-down: compliant, and still red under the company's own thresholds, with every other quarter amber, which is a fact the board should hear in the same sentence as the good news.

The trap. Adding the effects of each response as if they were independent. The amendment cuts the cap on add-backs, which clips the capped basket, the severance and the run-rate add-back of the cost program included; its fee and margin add to the revolver, while the deferred sponsor fees reduce it. In the case, levers (a) to (c) alone are close to additive and the amendment is not. The combination has to be recomputed, never summed.

What about an equity cure?

The case's agreement lets the sponsor contribute cash that is deemed to increase covenant EBITDA for the cured quarter. At Q3 year 4 the amount needed is $1,194,125, the shortfall to 5.75x; a prepayment of debt would need $6,866,218 for the same test. But the cure counts for one test date, cannot be repeated in the next quarter, and at Q4 year 4 the downside breaks again. A cure is a bridge to something else, never the answer to a forecast that breaks at every test date.

When to ask, and with what

Ask before the test date, while the company still has choices. In the case the request goes in at Q2 year 4, a quarter before the breach, and the agent asks for four things: the downside forecast, the levers already decided, a sponsor view on equity support, and the reason for the forecast miss. A company that brings all four, with the cost of the combination laid beside its effect on each test date, negotiates terms. A company that brings a breach and a request negotiates its credibility first.

Questions people ask

What is the difference between a covenant waiver and an amendment?

A waiver forgives a specific breach at a specific test date and leaves the terms unchanged. An amendment changes the terms, such as the levels or the definitions, for the quarters to come.

How much does a covenant waiver cost?

It is negotiated. In the worked case, a teaching assumption, the fee is 0.25 percent of loans outstanding, $855,497, for one test date.

How much does a covenant amendment cost?

In the case, a fee of 0.50 percent of term loans and revolver commitment, $1,799,750, a margin 0.50 percent higher (about $1,710,993 a year), and conditions such as monthly reporting.

Is a waiver enough if the next quarter also breaks?

No. In the case the waived breach is followed by another at Q4 year 4, 6.03x against 5.75x. A forecast that breaks at several test dates calls for an amendment and operating levers.

Read the whole case

This article is one step of The Covenant Compliance Handbook. The book follows one company through nine test dates and an eight-quarter forecast: the add-back file and the cap, every test, the certificate, headroom, the downside, levers, an equity cure, a waiver and an amendment, with every figure a live formula in the free workbook.

Paperback PDF edition, $19.99 Book page and free files

Free: the covenant compliance headroom calculator in Excel.

Also on this site

Case figures computed by the book's model; the company is fictional and every balance, rate and covenant level is a teaching assumption. Figures checked on 18 November 2026.