The unreported share, one minus one over the age-to-ultimate factor, applied to expected losses on a recent and a mature accident year, beside the chain ladder and the expected loss ratio method.
The Bornhuetter-Ferguson method adds to what has already been reported an expected amount for what has not: earned premium times an expected loss ratio times the unreported share, one minus one over the age-to-ultimate factor. On a year at 12 months with a factor of 2.180, the unreported share is 54.13 percent and the estimate is $2,297,945, against $2,781,680 by the chain ladder. On a year at 48 months the share falls to 4.03 percent and the two methods nearly meet.
Worked in full in The Loss Reserving Handbook by Julian R. Sterling, with every figure reproduced in a free workbook.Get the DRM-free PDF, $19.99 →
The method takes its name from R. L. Bornhuetter and R. E. Ferguson, who described it in The Actuary and IBNR, Proceedings of the Casualty Actuarial Society, 1972. It answers a practical problem. For a young accident year, the chain ladder multiplies a small and noisy amount of reported losses by a large factor, while the expected loss ratio method ignores the claims entirely. Bornhuetter-Ferguson keeps the reported losses as they are and estimates only the part still to come from an expectation set in advance.
For one accident year: ultimate = reported losses + earned premium x expected loss ratio x (1 - 1 / age-to-ultimate factor). The last term is the unreported share. If a year at its current age has reported, on the development pattern, one dollar out of every 2.18 it will finally cost, then less than half of the expected cost is already in and the rest is still to emerge. The method takes that remaining part of the expected losses, not of the actual ones.
Two consequences follow. A surprise in the reported losses of a young year passes into the estimate dollar for dollar, never multiplied. And the estimate leans on the expected loss ratio exactly as much as the year is undeveloped: heavily at 12 months, hardly at all at 48.
A sample book, not the book's case. Two accident years of the same line are read at the same evaluation date: one at 12 months, one at 48 months. Both were priced at an expected loss ratio of 0.640. The age-to-ultimate factors come from the line's own development pattern. All figures are teaching assumptions.
| Line | Recent year | Mature year |
|---|---|---|
| Reported losses (latest diagonal) | $1,276,000 | $2,604,000 |
| Age | 12 months | 48 months |
| Earned premium | $2,950,000 | $3,100,000 |
| Expected loss ratio | 0.640 | 0.640 |
| Expected losses (expected loss ratio method) | $1,888,000 | $1,984,000 |
| Age-to-ultimate factor | 2.180 | 1.042 |
| Unreported share: 1 - 1 / factor | 54.13 percent | 4.03 percent |
| Expected unreported losses | $1,021,945 | $79,969 |
| Bornhuetter-Ferguson ultimate | $2,297,945 | $2,683,969 |
For the recent year, the expected losses are $1,888,000. Of that, 54.13 percent is expected to be still unreported at 12 months, which gives $1,021,945. Adding the $1,276,000 already reported gives $2,297,945. For the mature year, only 4.03 percent of its $1,984,000 of expected losses is still to come, $79,969, and the estimate is $2,683,969.
| Method | Recent year | Mature year |
|---|---|---|
| Expected loss ratio method | $1,888,000 | $1,984,000 |
| Bornhuetter-Ferguson | $2,297,945 | $2,683,969 |
| Chain ladder (reported times factor) | $2,781,680 | $2,713,368 |
On the recent year the three methods spread widely. The chain ladder reads $2,781,680: it believes the reported losses fully and multiplies them by 2.180. The expected loss ratio method reads $1,888,000: it does not look at the claims at all. Bornhuetter-Ferguson sits between them at $2,297,945, much closer to the expectation, because at 12 months the year has reported less than half of what the pattern says it will.
On the mature year the picture changes. The chain ladder gives $2,713,368 and Bornhuetter-Ferguson $2,683,969: close, because both rest mainly on the reported losses. The expected loss ratio method, at $1,984,000, is now far away. Four years of reported claims say this year is running well above the price, and Bornhuetter-Ferguson listens to them, because the expected part it still uses is small.
Rearranged, the formula is a blend: the chain ladder estimate times the reported share, one over the factor, plus the expected loss ratio estimate times the unreported share. The weights are not chosen by the analyst; they come from the development pattern. For the recent year the chain ladder gets less than half the weight. For the mature year it gets almost all of it. Checking the example: the reported share of $2,781,680 plus the unreported share of $1,888,000 returns $2,297,945, to the rounding.
Seen this way, the method is a credibility rule. The company's own experience earns weight as it develops, and the prior expectation gives way at the same pace.
The expected loss ratio is an input, and the method is only as good as it. It is usually the ratio the business was priced at, adjusted for rate changes and trend, or the loss ratio of mature years brought to the level of the year being estimated. Whatever its source, it should be declared and explained in the file. Here it is a teaching assumption, not a market or industry figure.
A related method, Cape Cod, keeps the same formula but derives the expected loss ratio from the data: the reported losses of all years divided by the premium each year has used up, that is, earned premium divided by its age-to-ultimate factor. When the Cape Cod ratio and the priced ratio disagree, that disagreement is itself a finding worth writing down.
The book's case is fictional: Ashmerrow Mutual Insurance Company, a regional mutual writing commercial auto liability in its home state, reviewed at December 31, 2026 over accident years 2017 to 2026, gross of reinsurance, with ALAE kept out of the loss triangles. Every amount, premium, factor and ratio is a teaching assumption, not a market or industry figure.
Chapter 8 applies the method to all ten years. For the youngest year, at 12 months, earned premium of $23,870,000 at the expected loss ratio of 0.700 and an incurred factor of 1.883 give $7,835,394 of expected unreported losses; added to the $9,118,000 already reported, that is $16,953,394, between the expected loss ratio method at $16,709,000 and the incurred chain ladder at $17,169,194. For the oldest year, at 120 months, Bornhuetter-Ferguson gives $9,978,075 and the chain ladder $9,974,625, only $3,450 apart. The incurred Cape Cod ratio comes out at 67.59 percent, below the 70.0 percent the line was priced at, and the book records that its own reported losses point lower than the price. Bornhuetter-Ferguson is the method selected for the four youngest accident years.
Sources and limits: the standards named on this page are summarized as read in November 2026: Actuarial Standard of Practice No. 43, Property/Casualty Unpaid Claim Estimates (Actuarial Standards Board), and a Casualty Actuarial Society study text on basic techniques for estimating unpaid claims (Version 3, 2010). They are paraphrased in principle and they can change. This is not actuarial advice and not a statement of actuarial opinion: every figure is a sample, and only a qualified actuary working on the company's own data can say which method and which factors fit it.
Ultimate equals reported losses plus earned premium times the expected loss ratio times one minus one over the age-to-ultimate factor. The last term is the share of expected losses still unreported.
The chain ladder multiplies reported losses by the age-to-ultimate factor. Bornhuetter-Ferguson keeps reported losses as they are and adds expected losses for the unreported share, so it is more stable for young years and close to the chain ladder for mature ones.
It is named after R. L. Bornhuetter and R. E. Ferguson, who described it in The Actuary and IBNR, Proceedings of the Casualty Actuarial Society, 1972.
From pricing, adjusted for rate changes and trend, or from mature years brought to the current level, and it should be declared in the file. A Cape Cod ratio computed from the data is a useful cross-check.
Analysts often use it for young accident years where the chain ladder is unstable. As read in November 2026, ASOP No. 43 requires no specific method; a qualified actuary decides what fits a company's data.
This article is one step of The Loss Reserving Handbook. The book follows one regional insurer through one year-end review: a claims registry turned into paid, reported and count triangles, diagnostics read before any method, factors chosen with their reasons, two declared tails, the chain ladder, the expected loss ratio method, Bornhuetter-Ferguson and Cape Cod side by side, an estimate selected year by year with its range, ALAE and ULAE added once, the next year compared with what was expected, and a captive with a thin triangle.
Paperback PDF edition, $19.99 Book page and free files
Free: the loss reserving calculator in Excel.
Case figures computed by the book's model; the companies are fictional and every term is a teaching assumption. Figures checked on 21 November 2026. Standards described as read on the dates given; not actuarial advice.