Articles

At what announcement drop does a marketed follow-on beat an accelerated bookbuild?

A marketed follow-on pays a smaller discount and a larger fee, and it gives the market days to mark the stock down first. The choice turns on how far the announcement moves the price.

A shareholder selling 20.0m shares at EUR 50.00 nets EUR 47.40 a share in an accelerated bookbuild and EUR 46.82 in a marketed follow-on if the stock falls 2.0% on the announcement, a gap of EUR 11.61m. The marketed deal wins only if the announcement drop stays below 0.78%.

The assumptions

Illustrative block sale, invented figures
ItemValue
Position sold20.0m shares, last close EUR 50.00 (EUR 1,000.0m)
Accelerated bookbuild (ABB)Launched after the close, priced overnight at a 4.0% discount to last close, 1.25% fee
Marketed follow-onAnnounced, then priced after three trading days at a 2.5% discount to the price on the day, 2.0% fee
Announcement dropThe fall in the share price when the marketed deal is announced, 2.0% in the base case
Daily volatility1.8%, so three trading days carry a standard deviation of 1.8% × √3

In an ABB the seller fixes the price before the market reopens, so the only price it takes is the discount. In a marketed deal the seller pays less discount and a bigger fee but is exposed to the stock from announcement to pricing.

Step 1: what the accelerated bookbuild nets

Net per share = price × (1 − discount) × (1 − fee)

50.00 × (1 − 0.04) = EUR 48.00 gross

48.00 × (1 − 0.0125) = EUR 47.40 net

20.0m shares × 47.40 = EUR 948.00m

Excel: =50*(1-0.04)*(1-0.0125)

Step 2: what the marketed follow-on nets

Price after a 2.0% announcement drop: 50.00 × 0.98 = EUR 49.00

Priced at a 2.5% discount: 49.00 × 0.975 = EUR 47.775

Less a 2.0% fee: 47.775 × 0.98 = EUR 46.8195 net, or EUR 936.39m in total

ABB advantage: 47.4000 − 46.8195 = EUR 0.5805 a share, EUR 11.61m

Step 3: the break-even announcement drop

Set the two net prices equal and solve for the drop a: (1 − a) × (1 − dM) × (1 − fM) = (1 − dA) × (1 − fA)

a = 1 − (0.96 × 0.9875) ÷ (0.975 × 0.98) = 1 − 0.9480 ÷ 0.9555 = 0.785%

Excel: =1-(1-0.04)*(1-0.0125)/((1-0.025)*(1-0.02))

Before any announcement drop the marketed deal nets 95.55% of the price against 94.80% for the ABB, an edge of only 0.75 points: it gives back 1.5 points of discount but pays 0.75 points more fee. The two deals tie when the stock falls 0.78% on launch.

Marketed follow-on against the ABB by announcement drop (ABB nets EUR 47.40 a share)
Announcement dropMarketed, net EUR a shareABB, net EUR a shareMarketed minus ABB, EUR m
0.00%47.7847.407.50
0.78%47.4047.400.00
1.00%47.3047.40-2.06
2.00%46.8247.40-11.61
3.00%46.3447.40-21.17

Step 4: the risk the marketed deal carries

Three-day standard deviation: 1.8% × √3 = 3.12%

On EUR 50.00 that is EUR 1.56 a share, or EUR 31.18m on 20.0m shares, one standard deviation either way

The ABB gap in Step 2, EUR 11.61m, is 37% of that one-standard-deviation swing

The announcement drop is a known cost once it happens, but the three days of drift after it are not. The marketed seller keeps the chance of a rally and bears the chance of a fall.

What if: the ABB needs a deeper discount

Break-even drop by ABB discount (marketed deal unchanged)
ABB discountABB net, EUR a shareBreak-even announcement dropMarketed (2.0% drop) minus ABB, EUR m
4.0%47.400.78%-11.61
5.0%46.911.82%-1.74
6.0%46.412.85%8.14
7.0%45.923.89%18.01

A bigger block forces a deeper ABB discount. At 5.0% the break-even drop rises to 1.82%, and at 6.0% it is 2.85%, so for larger blocks a marketed deal wins unless the announcement moves the stock by more than 1.8% to 2.9%. The model has no market-impact difference on the day and ignores that an ABB leaves some demand untapped.

The common mistakes

Takeaway

Questions readers ask

At what announcement drop does a marketed follow-on beat an accelerated bookbuild?

When the stock falls by less than 0.78%. With a 4.0% ABB discount and 1.25% fee against a 2.5% discount and 2.0% fee, the two net the same at that drop.

Why does a marketed deal cost more fee but less discount?

It takes longer and uses a roadshow, so the banks charge 2.0% against 1.25%, but it builds demand and the discount to the price on the day is 2.5% instead of 4.0%.

Does the break-even change with the size of the block?

Yes. A larger block needs a deeper ABB discount. At 5.0% the break-even announcement drop is 1.82% and at 6.0% it is 2.85%.

The workbooks behind this article

The free companion files for The Equity Capital Markets Banker rebuild a fictional IPO's offering, greenshoe, valuation, book, first day and fees, and a block trade, with live formulas. The deal in this article is invented and is not in them. No account and no email address.

Open the companion files →

Not on Amazon: 19 paperbacks by Julian R. Sterling on markets, funds and compliance, printed on demand and shipped worldwide. Browse the bookshop →

Also on this site

Reading guide: corporate finance, valuation and markets → · All 1908 articles →