At what announcement drop does a marketed follow-on beat an accelerated bookbuild?
A marketed follow-on pays a smaller discount and a larger fee, and it gives the market days to mark the stock down first. The choice turns on how far the announcement moves the price.
A shareholder selling 20.0m shares at EUR 50.00 nets EUR 47.40 a share in an accelerated bookbuild and EUR 46.82 in a marketed follow-on if the stock falls 2.0% on the announcement, a gap of EUR 11.61m. The marketed deal wins only if the announcement drop stays below 0.78%.
The assumptions
Illustrative block sale, invented figures
Item
Value
Position sold
20.0m shares, last close EUR 50.00 (EUR 1,000.0m)
Accelerated bookbuild (ABB)
Launched after the close, priced overnight at a 4.0% discount to last close, 1.25% fee
Marketed follow-on
Announced, then priced after three trading days at a 2.5% discount to the price on the day, 2.0% fee
Announcement drop
The fall in the share price when the marketed deal is announced, 2.0% in the base case
Daily volatility
1.8%, so three trading days carry a standard deviation of 1.8% × √3
In an ABB the seller fixes the price before the market reopens, so the only price it takes is the discount. In a marketed deal the seller pays less discount and a bigger fee but is exposed to the stock from announcement to pricing.
Step 1: what the accelerated bookbuild nets
Net per share = price × (1 − discount) × (1 − fee)
50.00 × (1 − 0.04) = EUR 48.00 gross
48.00 × (1 − 0.0125) = EUR 47.40 net
20.0m shares × 47.40 = EUR 948.00m
Excel: =50*(1-0.04)*(1-0.0125)
Step 2: what the marketed follow-on nets
Price after a 2.0% announcement drop: 50.00 × 0.98 = EUR 49.00
Priced at a 2.5% discount: 49.00 × 0.975 = EUR 47.775
Less a 2.0% fee: 47.775 × 0.98 = EUR 46.8195 net, or EUR 936.39m in total
Before any announcement drop the marketed deal nets 95.55% of the price against 94.80% for the ABB, an edge of only 0.75 points: it gives back 1.5 points of discount but pays 0.75 points more fee. The two deals tie when the stock falls 0.78% on launch.
Marketed follow-on against the ABB by announcement drop (ABB nets EUR 47.40 a share)
Announcement drop
Marketed, net EUR a share
ABB, net EUR a share
Marketed minus ABB, EUR m
0.00%
47.78
47.40
7.50
0.78%
47.40
47.40
0.00
1.00%
47.30
47.40
-2.06
2.00%
46.82
47.40
-11.61
3.00%
46.34
47.40
-21.17
Step 4: the risk the marketed deal carries
Three-day standard deviation: 1.8% × √3 = 3.12%
On EUR 50.00 that is EUR 1.56 a share, or EUR 31.18m on 20.0m shares, one standard deviation either way
The ABB gap in Step 2, EUR 11.61m, is 37% of that one-standard-deviation swing
The announcement drop is a known cost once it happens, but the three days of drift after it are not. The marketed seller keeps the chance of a rally and bears the chance of a fall.
What if: the ABB needs a deeper discount
Break-even drop by ABB discount (marketed deal unchanged)
ABB discount
ABB net, EUR a share
Break-even announcement drop
Marketed (2.0% drop) minus ABB, EUR m
4.0%
47.40
0.78%
-11.61
5.0%
46.91
1.82%
-1.74
6.0%
46.41
2.85%
8.14
7.0%
45.92
3.89%
18.01
A bigger block forces a deeper ABB discount. At 5.0% the break-even drop rises to 1.82%, and at 6.0% it is 2.85%, so for larger blocks a marketed deal wins unless the announcement moves the stock by more than 1.8% to 2.9%. The model has no market-impact difference on the day and ignores that an ABB leaves some demand untapped.
The common mistakes
Comparing only the discounts. The ABB discount is 4.0% against 2.5%, but the fees are 1.25% and 2.0% and the marketed deal also loses the announcement drop.
Applying the discount to last close for both. A marketed deal is priced off the price on the day, after the announcement has moved it.
Treating the announcement drop as the whole risk. The three days to pricing add a standard deviation of 3.12%, EUR 31.18m on the position.
Ignoring size. The ABB discount grows with the block, so the break-even drop in the table moves from 0.78% at a 4.0% discount to 3.89% at 7.0%.
Takeaway
Net price = price × (1 − discount) × (1 − fee): EUR 47.40 for the ABB and EUR 46.82 for the marketed deal at a 2.0% announcement drop.
The marketed deal beats the ABB only if the stock falls less than 0.78% on launch; at 2.0% it costs the seller EUR 11.61m.
A deeper ABB discount moves the break-even up, to 1.82% at 5.0%, but the marketed deal also carries 3.12% of three-day price risk.
Questions readers ask
At what announcement drop does a marketed follow-on beat an accelerated bookbuild?
When the stock falls by less than 0.78%. With a 4.0% ABB discount and 1.25% fee against a 2.5% discount and 2.0% fee, the two net the same at that drop.
Why does a marketed deal cost more fee but less discount?
It takes longer and uses a roadshow, so the banks charge 2.0% against 1.25%, but it builds demand and the discount to the price on the day is 2.5% instead of 4.0%.
Does the break-even change with the size of the block?
Yes. A larger block needs a deeper ABB discount. At 5.0% the break-even announcement drop is 1.82% and at 6.0% it is 2.85%.
The workbooks behind this article
The free companion files for The Equity Capital Markets Banker rebuild a fictional IPO's offering, greenshoe, valuation, book, first day and fees, and a block trade, with live formulas. The deal in this article is invented and is not in them. No account and no email address.
Not on Amazon: 19 paperbacks by Julian R. Sterling on markets, funds and compliance, printed on demand and shipped worldwide. Browse the bookshop →
Also on this site
How does a greenshoe option work in a share offering?A greenshoe lets underwriters over-allot up to 15 per cent of a share offering and close the resulting short by buying in the market or exercising an option on new shares. On an illustrative 20,000,000 share offer at EUR 25.00 with a 2.5 per cent spread, a rising price brings the issuer EUR 73,125,000 more, a falling one sees EUR 70,800,000 of stabilising purchases and a 4,200,000 gain to the banks.
How is an IPO price range set from peer multiples?A company with EBITDA of 120 and net debt of 480 is priced off a peer median of 11.0x EBITDA. After a 15.0% IPO discount the equity value is 642, or $6.42 a share, and a range of plus or minus 7.5% runs from $5.94 to $6.90.
How do you calculate the true cost of an IPO, underpricing included?The true cost of an IPO is the gross spread and expenses plus underpricing, the first-day gain on every share sold. On an illustrative EUR 500 million primary offering at EUR 20.00 closing at 23.40, the company pays 22.75 million invoiced and 85.0 million in underpricing, 21.55 per cent of proceeds, 78.9 per cent of it uninvoiced.
How do you calculate TERP in a rights issue?The theoretical ex-rights price is (existing shares x price + new shares x subscription price) / enlarged shares. On an illustrative 2-for-5 rights issue at EUR 30.00 with the shares at 42.60, TERP is 39.00, a nil-paid right is worth 9.00 per new share, the discount is 23.08 per cent to TERP against 29.58 per cent to the close, and a holder who does nothing loses 8.45 per cent.
How is an IPO gross spread split among the underwriters?An IPO gross spread is commonly split 20 per cent management fee, 20 per cent underwriting fee (net of syndicate expenses) and 60 per cent selling concession. On an illustrative $600.0m IPO with a 5.0 per cent spread ($30.0m), a lead-left bookrunner with a 35 per cent commitment earns $10.275m, 36.1 per cent of the $28.5m distributed, under fixed economics, and $12.975m under a jump ball.