Articles

Does a lock-up reduce the fair value of listed shares?

Under ASU 2022-03 a contractual sale restriction belongs to the holder, not to the share: no discount, no blockage factor, and four disclosures instead.

A company receives listed shares as part of a sale and signs a lock-up: it cannot sell them for more than a year. It feels natural to value them below the market price. Under US GAAP, since ASU 2022-03, it may not: a contractual sale restriction is a characteristic of the holder, not of the share, so the shares are measured at the quoted price of the unrestricted shares, and the restriction is disclosed instead.

Worked in full in The Fair Value Measurement Handbook by Julian R. Sterling, with every figure reproduced in a free workbook.Get the DRM-free PDF, $19.99 →

The rule

As read in November 2026, ASU 2022-03 amended ASC 820 to say that a contractual restriction on the sale of an equity security, such as a lock-up, a market stand-off agreement or a provision of a shareholder agreement, is a characteristic of the reporting entity that holds the security, not of the security itself. It is not part of the unit of account, it is not considered in measuring fair value, and it cannot be recognized as a separate unit of account. A restriction that is a characteristic of the security is different and is still considered: for example, shares that are not registered for sale while other shares of the same class are. The update applied to public business entities for fiscal years beginning after 15 December 2023 and to all other entities after 15 December 2024, prospectively.

A worked example

The case is fictional: Calderwick Instruments, Inc., a listed US maker of measurement instruments that reports under US GAAP with a calendar year. Every price, rate, probability and amount below is a teaching assumption of that case, not a market figure, and the facts of your own entity govern. It already held 600,000 shares of Hollinbrook Optics, a listed company, when on 1 July 2026 it sold a product line to Hollinbrook for cash and 200,000 more shares. Calderwick signed a lock-up: no sale before 31 December 2027. The shares are of the same class as the freely traded ones.

LineAmount
Consideration received on 1 July 2026: cash$3,380,000
Consideration received: 200,000 shares x $13.10$2,620,000
Total consideration$6,000,000
Carrying amount of the product line sold$5,400,000
Gain on sale$600,000
Locked-up shares at 31 December 2026: 200,000 x $11.85$2,370,000
Loss in 2026 on the locked-up shares: $2,370,000 - $2,620,000-$250,000
Whole holding at 31 December 2026: 800,000 x $11.85$9,480,000

The shares received are measured at the closing price on the day, $13.10, with no discount for the lock-up, and the gain on the sale is computed on that value. At year-end they are measured at the official closing price of $11.85, like every other Hollinbrook share Calderwick holds. They stay in Level 1, because the measurement uses the unadjusted quoted price for identical shares. A discount for the lock-up would have been an adjustment to that price, and would have moved the measurement out of Level 1 as well as out of compliance.

The block cannot be discounted either

After the sale Calderwick holds 800,000 shares, under 10 percent of the 9,000,000 outstanding, against an average daily trading volume of 45,000 shares. A buyer for the whole block at once might ask a discount, but ASC 820 does not allow a blockage factor at any level of the hierarchy: the size of a position is a characteristic of the holder, not of the asset. The holding is measured at quoted price x quantity, $9,480,000.

What the note says instead

ASU 2022-03 replaced the discount with disclosures for equity securities subject to contractual sale restrictions. For the locked-up shares the note gives four items in one short paragraph:

Investment companies: a change announced

The FASB issued ASU 2026-03 on 9 September 2026 for investment companies under ASC 946 only. As read in November 2026, they will consider the effect of a contractual sale restriction when measuring an equity security and disclose the discount attributable to it, for annual periods beginning after 15 December 2027, with early adoption permitted. Nothing changes for an operating company such as Calderwick: it keeps measuring restricted shares at the price of otherwise identical unrestricted shares.

Mistakes that recur in the file

Where the shares sit in the hierarchy, and why, is set out in the article on classifying fair value measurements.

Rules are described as read in November 2026 from the FASB Accounting Standards Codification (Topic 820, and Topics 321, 805 and 946 where named) and IFRS 13, and they change. This page is education, not accounting or audit advice: your entity's facts govern, and its accountants and auditors decide.

Questions people ask

Does a lock-up reduce the fair value of listed shares under US GAAP?

No, when the lock-up is a contract signed by the holder. Since ASU 2022-03 such a restriction is a characteristic of the holder, not of the share, and is not considered in measuring fair value.

Which restrictions are still taken into account?

Restrictions that are a characteristic of the security itself, for example shares not registered for sale while other shares of the same class are.

What must be disclosed for restricted shares?

The fair value of the shares subject to the restriction, the nature of the restriction, its remaining duration, and the circumstances that could cause it to lapse.

Can a large holding be valued below the quoted price?

No. ASC 820 does not allow a blockage factor at any level: the holding is measured at the quoted price times the number of shares.

Does ASU 2026-03 change this?

Only for investment companies under ASC 946, which will consider the effect of a contractual sale restriction and disclose the discount, for annual periods beginning after 15 December 2027, early adoption permitted, as read in November 2026.

Read the whole case

This article is one step of The Fair Value Measurement Handbook. The book follows one listed company through two year-ends: seven instruments measured and placed in the hierarchy, a pricing service challenged, a swap that changes sides, an earn-out remeasured until its contingency is resolved, private shares re-anchored to a new round, a fund at net asset value, a plant written down on its highest and best use, and the fair value note written line by line, with IFRS 13 compared where it differs.

Paperback PDF edition, $19.99 Book page and free files

Free: the fair value hierarchy and Level 3 roll-forward model in Excel.

Also on this site

Case figures computed by the book's model; the companies are fictional and every term is a teaching assumption. Figures checked on 20 November 2026. Rules described as read on the dates given; not accounting or audit advice.