Articles

How do you apply the ASC 280 quantitative thresholds?

An operating segment is reportable if it meets any one of three 10% tests: revenue, the absolute amount of profit or loss, or assets. Then the reportable segments must cover at least 75% of consolidated revenue.

Under ASC 280-10-50-12, an operating segment must be reported separately if its revenue (external plus intersegment), the absolute amount of its profit or loss, or its assets reach 10% of the combined amount for all operating segments. Meeting any one test is enough. In the worked case below, five of six segments are reportable, and three of them pass exactly one test.

Worked in full in The Segment Reporting Handbook by Julian R. Sterling, with every figure reproduced in a free workbook.Get the PDF, $19.99 →or the paperback

The case

Calderwood Technologies is a fictional listed industrial company with a calendar fiscal year. After aggregating its two regional Flow Control businesses, it has six operating segments. The figures are those its chief executive, the chief operating decision maker, reviews each month, in millions of dollars for fiscal 2026.

Operating segments as reported to the chief operating decision maker, FY2026 ($ millions)
Operating segmentRevenue (external and intersegment)Operating incomeAssets
Flow Control1,024.0149.0950.0
Sensors & Instrumentation320.061.0260.0
Water Analytics142.09.0230.0
Aftermarket Services118.031.060.0
Software64.0-38.070.0
Specialty Coatings64.0-6.040.0
Total1,732.01,610.0

Test 1: the revenue test

The revenue test compares each segment's revenue, including sales to other segments, with the combined revenue of all operating segments. Here the threshold is 10% of $1,732.0, or $173.2. Flow Control and Sensors & Instrumentation pass; Water Analytics, at $142.0, does not.

Test 2: the profit or loss test

The profit or loss test uses absolute amounts against the greater of two separate totals: the combined profit of the segments with a profit, and the combined loss of the segments with a loss. Profits total $250.0 and losses $44.0, so the threshold is 10% of $250.0, or $25.0. Flow Control, Sensors & Instrumentation and Aftermarket Services pass on their profits. Software passes on its loss of $38.0.

Test 3: the asset test

The asset test compares each segment's assets with combined segment assets, $1,610.0, so the threshold is $161.0. Water Analytics, with $230.0 of assets, passes. The test applies only when the chief operating decision maker reviews assets by segment.

Results: one test is enough
SegmentRevenue shareProfit or loss shareAsset shareReportable
Flow Control59.1%59.6%59.0%yes, all three
Sensors & Instrumentation18.5%24.4%16.1%yes, all three
Water Analytics8.2%3.6%14.3%yes, assets only
Aftermarket Services6.8%12.4%3.7%yes, profit only
Software3.7%15.2%4.3%yes, loss only
Specialty Coatings3.7%2.4%2.5%no

The trap: requiring a segment to pass two or three tests. The tests are alternatives. Read as cumulative, they would drop three of Calderwood's five reportable segments, including the loss-making acquisition investors most want to see.

The 75% test

The external revenue of the reportable segments must reach at least 75% of consolidated revenue (ASC 280-10-50-14). Note the numerator: external revenue only. Calderwood's five reportable segments have $1,610.0 of external revenue against consolidated revenue of $1,662.0, or 96.9%. Flow Control and Sensors & Instrumentation alone would reach 77.4%. If the test fails, the company adds operating segments as reportable until it passes. Specialty Coatings, which meets no test, goes into the "all other" category in the reconciliations.

Second example: the same tests after a reorganization

From January 2027, Calderwood moves Aftermarket Services into Flow Control (70%) and Sensors & Instrumentation (30%). Recast fiscal 2026 figures give Flow Control revenue of $1,106.6, operating income of $170.7 and assets of $992.0, and Sensors & Instrumentation $355.4, $70.3 and $278.0. Combined revenue, profits and assets do not change, so the thresholds stay at $173.2, $25.0 and $161.0. Software's loss is still 15.2% of combined profits and Water Analytics' assets 14.3% of combined assets: the company now has four reportable segments, and prior periods are recast under ASC 280-10-50-34.

Takeaway

Free Excel template: Segment Reporting Workbook (10% tests, 75% test, significant segment expenses, reconciliations, entity-wide data and recast).

Also on this site: significant segment expenses (ASU 2023-07) · single-segment disclosures under ASC 280.

Questions readers ask

Does a segment have to meet all three 10% tests?

No. A segment that meets any one of the revenue, profit or loss and asset tests in ASC 280-10-50-12 is a reportable segment.

Can a loss-making segment be reportable?

Yes. The profit or loss test uses the absolute amount, so a segment whose loss is at least 10% of the greater of combined profits and combined losses is reportable.

Is intersegment revenue included in the 10% revenue test?

Yes. The revenue test uses revenue from external customers and from other segments. The 75% test uses external revenue only.

What happens to segments below every threshold?

They may be reported separately if useful, combined with other small segments that share similar economics and a majority of the aggregation criteria, or shown in an all other category.

Sources: FASB ASU 2023-07 and ASC 280-10 (paragraphs cited in the text), ASU 2025-01, checked on 18 November 2026. Figures computed by the author's model for a fictional company. Education only, not accounting, auditing or legal advice.

Read the whole case

This article is one calculation from The Segment Reporting Handbook. The book follows one listed company's segment reporting through fiscal year 2026, from the chief operating decision maker to the filed note and the recast, and every figure it prints is a live formula in the free workbook.

Get the PDF edition, $19.99 Paperback · Free companion files