Articles

Section 338(h)(10) or F reorganization: which route fits the deal?

Who can buy, what happens to rolled equity, what an invalid S election does to each route, and what the conversion to an LLC asks of contracts and permits, on one example.

Both routes give the buyer a basis in the assets equal to the price. The election needs a corporate buyer and a valid S corporation, and it taxes rolled equity now. The F reorganization works for any buyer, survives a doubtful S election and defers the gain on rolled units: on a 30 percent rollover in the example below, $1,440,000 of tax waits.

Worked in full in The Section 338(h)(10) Handbook by Julian R. Sterling, with every figure reproduced in a free workbook.Get the DRM-free PDF, $19.99 →

What each route does

A Section 338(h)(10) election keeps the legal form of a stock purchase and changes its tax treatment. As read in November 2026, section 338(a) treats the target as having sold all its assets at fair market value at the close of the acquisition date, and as a new corporation that bought them the next day. The buyer owns the same corporation, with the same contracts, permits and employer identification number, but with a stepped-up basis in its assets.

An F reorganization changes the legal form before the sale. Rev. Rul. 2008-18 describes the sequence: the shareholders of the S corporation form a new holding corporation, contribute the stock of the old corporation to it, and the new holding corporation elects to treat the old one as a qualified subchapter S subsidiary. When the steps qualify as a reorganization under section 368(a)(1)(F), the S election does not end; it continues for the new holding corporation, which needs a new employer identification number while the old corporation keeps its own. Under section 1361(b)(3)(A), a qualified subchapter S subsidiary is not treated as a separate corporation. In practice the old corporation is then converted into a limited liability company under state law, and the buyer buys the LLC units. For federal income tax, buying units of an LLC disregarded as separate from its owner is buying its assets.

Who can buy

The election needs a qualified stock purchase: under section 338(d)(3), a corporation must buy, by purchase, stock with at least 80 percent of the vote and 80 percent of the value within a 12-month acquisition period. Under Treas. Reg. 1.338(h)(10)-1(c), the target must be bought from a selling consolidated group, a selling affiliate or the shareholders of an S corporation. A buyer that is a partnership or a fund vehicle taxed as one cannot make a qualified stock purchase. For an S corporation target, a Section 336(e) election may still be open, because a qualified stock disposition does not require a corporate buyer, but it is a different election, made by written binding agreement and a statement attached to the return rather than on Form 8023. The F reorganization has no condition on the buyer: anyone who can buy LLC units can buy the assets.

Rolled equity: taxed now or later

Sellers who keep part of the business usually want the kept part untaxed. The two routes treat it differently. Under Treas. Reg. 1.338(h)(10)-1(d)(5), when an S corporation shareholder keeps some target stock, the deemed sale of all the assets still happens, the shareholder still takes a share of its gain, and the retained stock is treated as acquired the next day at fair market value. The rolled equity is taxed at closing even though no cash was received for it.

In an F reorganization, the buyer buys only some of the LLC units. Rev. Rul. 99-5 (Situation 1) treats the purchase of part of a disregarded LLC as the purchase of that share of each asset, followed by a contribution of both owners' interests to a new partnership; the seller recognizes gain only on the interest sold, and section 721(a) applies to the conversion. The holding corporation keeps the rest of the units, and the gain on them is deferred, not forgiven. The buyer, in turn, steps up only the share it bought. For what a partnership then does with contributions and allocations, see The Partnership Tax Handbook.

A worked example

A sample S corporation, not the book's case, is valued at $30,000,000 for all its equity; its assets have a basis of $6,000,000, so the gain on a sale of everything is $24,000,000. To keep the example clean, all of it is capital gain at 20 percent and the sellers' stock basis equals the asset basis. The sellers keep 30 percent; both percentages and rates are teaching assumptions.

LineElectionF reorganization
Price for 100 percent of the equity$30,000,000$30,000,000
Basis of the company's assets$6,000,000$6,000,000
Gain on all the assets$24,000,000$24,000,000
Equity the sellers keep30 percent of the stock30 percent of the units
Gain taxed at closing$24,000,000$16,800,000
Tax at closing, 20 percent$4,800,000$3,360,000
Tax deferred on the rolled equity$0$1,440,000
Buyer's step-up$24,000,000$16,800,000

With the election, the deemed sale covers every asset, so the whole gain of $24,000,000 is taxed at closing, $4,800,000, including the share that belongs to the rolled stock. In the F reorganization, only the units sold are taxed: $3,360,000 now, and $1,440,000 deferred until the holding corporation sells its remaining units. The buyer's side moves the other way. The election steps up all the assets, $24,000,000, inside a company the buyer owns only in part; the F reorganization steps up $16,800,000, the share it bought. Neither route is better in general: the sellers gain time on the rolled part, the buyer loses step-up, and the price conversation decides how the difference is shared.

When the S election is in doubt

A Section 338(h)(10) election for an S corporation only works if the company really is an S corporation. Section 1361(b)(1) allows no more than 100 shareholders, only eligible shareholders, and not more than one class of stock. Under Treas. Reg. 1.1361-1(l)(2)(i), whether all shares carry identical rights to distribution and liquidation proceeds is read in the governing provisions, which can include binding agreements on those proceeds. A shareholder agreement that gives one holder different liquidation rights can therefore create a second class of stock and end the election years before the sale, without anyone noticing.

If that happened, the target is a C corporation owned by individuals: neither an S corporation nor a member of a selling consolidated group. The election would fail, the buyer would keep the old basis, and it would own a company exposed to corporate tax for the years after the S election ended. The F reorganization changes the exposure, not the past: the buyer buys assets through the LLC and gets its step-up, but the LLC is the same legal entity as the old corporation and keeps its own federal tax liabilities for the years before it became disregarded (Treas. Reg. 301.7701-2(c)(2)(iii), as read in November 2026), so the indemnity and any holdback still have to cover that history. That is why diligence on the S election, and the representations and indemnity that follow from it, matter in an F reorganization as much as in an election. Whether anything can still repair a broken S election is a question for the deal's tax advisers, not for the model.

Contracts, permits and timing

The election leaves the corporation untouched, so its contracts, licenses, permits and bank accounts stay where they are. The F reorganization converts the old corporation into an LLC before closing. Depending on state law and the wording of each document, a conversion may count as an assignment or a change of control, and some permits or licenses may need notice, consent or reissue. The steps also take time: forming the holding corporation, the qualified subchapter S subsidiary election, the conversion, and new tax registrations all happen before signing or closing. The election, by contrast, is made after closing: under section 338(g)(1) and Treas. Reg. 1.338(h)(10)-1(c)(3), Form 8023 is due by the 15th day of the 9th month beginning after the month that includes the acquisition date, signed by the buyer and by every S corporation shareholder. States may not follow the federal treatment of either route; that question stays with the deal's advisers.

The same comparison in the book

The case is fictional: Tavistrell Composites, Inc., a US S corporation owned by its two founders and bought for cash by a corporate buyer on July 31, 2025. Every price, basis, fair value, cost and rate of the case is a teaching assumption, not a market figure, and the facts of your own transaction govern.

When the buyer purchases 100 percent, the two routes give exactly the same figures: founders' tax $7,492,192, built-in gains tax $2,814,000, after-tax cash $35,043,808, and a step-up worth $4,653,338 to the buyer. With a 20 percent rollover, they part: the F reorganization defers $2,221,536 of tax that the election charges at closing, while the buyer's step-up falls from $37,150,000 to $29,890,000. The book also follows a second company whose S election ended years before its sale because of a second class of stock, and shows why only the F reorganization still gives that buyer a step-up.

Questions to settle before choosing

Rules are described as read in November 2026 from the Internal Revenue Code (26 U.S.C. 338, 336(e), 1374, 1366, 1361, 1245, 197 and 1060), Treas. Reg. 1.338-4, 1.338-5, 1.338-6, 1.338(h)(10)-1 and 1.336-1 to 1.336-4, Rev. Rul. 2008-18, Rev. Rul. 99-5 and the IRS instructions for Forms 8023 and 8883, and they change. State rules are not covered. This page is education, not tax advice: ask the deal's tax advisers how any rule applies to your transaction.

Questions people ask

Is an F reorganization better than a Section 338(h)(10) election?

Neither is better in general. At 100 percent the two routes can give the same tax figures; they differ on who may buy, on rolled equity, on the risk of an invalid S election, and on contracts and permits.

Can a private equity fund make a 338(h)(10) election?

Only through a corporation. As read in November 2026, a qualified stock purchase needs a corporate purchaser. A fund that buys through a partnership looks at Section 336(e) or at an F reorganization.

What happens to rolled equity in a 338(h)(10) election?

The deemed sale covers all the assets, so the shareholder who keeps stock still takes a share of the gain, and the kept stock is treated as bought back at fair market value the next day.

Does an F reorganization end the S election?

Not when the steps match Rev. Rul. 2008-18: the S election continues for the new holding corporation, which needs a new employer identification number.

Which route protects the buyer if the S election was invalid?

The F reorganization protects the buyer's step-up, because the buyer buys assets through the LLC. It does not erase the past: the LLC keeps its own federal tax liabilities for the years before it became disregarded, so the indemnity has to back them. Ask the deal's tax advisers how the rules apply to a given deal.

Read the whole case

This article is one step of The Section 338(h)(10) Handbook. The book follows one S corporation through its sale to a corporate buyer: the eligibility test, ADSP and AGUB from one price, nine assets placed in seven classes, the gain split into recapture and capital gain, a built-in gains tax with its five-year calendar, the step-up valued year by year, a gross-up that leaves the founders exactly whole, the F reorganization with and without a rollover, Forms 8023 and 8883, and six sensitivities.

Paperback PDF edition, $19.99 Book page and free files

Free: the Section 338(h)(10) gross-up calculator in Excel.

Also on this site

Case figures computed by the book's model; the companies are fictional and every term is a teaching assumption. Figures checked on 20 November 2026. Rules described as read on the dates given; not tax advice.