Companion files
A Practitioner’s Guide to Defaults, Extensions, Discounted Payoffs and Getting Value Out of a Broken Loan
These are the companion files of The Real Estate Workout by Julian R. Sterling.The book on Amazon →
The four Excel workbooks that go with the book, corrected where they were wrong: the four ways out of one broken loan, the enforcement and extension models behind them, and the diligence list with the decision record. Around them: the same four models with the inputs emptied, thirteen working documents to print, forty questions that mark themselves, and three cases the book names and never prices. Every number is a live formula, and nothing is gated behind a sign-up.
Twelve workbooks, the printable documents and the read-me. Each group below can also be downloaded on its own. Last revised 24 September 2026.
Reading the paperback or the Kindle edition? The same book is also sold as a DRM-free PDF: searchable, printable, yours on any device. $19.99, instant download.Buy the PDF edition → Free sample
Finished the book? Two or more PDF editions bought together are 15% off. Browse the PDF editions →
The working models behind the books, built out for live deals: the Pro models →
Optional. When a workbook on this page is corrected or a new worked case goes up, readers on the list get one email, plus a short note when a new book comes out. The downloads do not need it.
Join the reader listRun by MailerLite, off this site. How your address is used.
These carry the book’s own figures, so that every number it prints can be traced to a live formula. Each ends on a checks sheet that states its own verdict. Download these four91 KB
Chapters 3 to 8 · the whole decision
The whole book on four sheets. One broken loan — an office bought at a 4.50 per cent yield and refinanced into a 6.65 per cent market — and four ways out of it, each discounted to today over its own timetable so that the four are actually comparable. That comparison is what the book exists to make, and it is the one a credit committee is almost never shown, because the four options arrive on four different pages with four different horizons.
Go to sheet 3 and read the last line: 58.7 cents, the price at which a discounted payoff exactly matches what enforcement would return. Then go back to Assumptions and raise the forced-sale discount from 18 to 30 per cent. The indifference point falls to 49.6 cents, and nothing about the building, the borrower or the loan has changed.
That sensitivity is the negotiation. Whoever knows the number sets the range.
Revised: the consensual sale now uses Chapter 6’s own assumptions and gives the book’s 66.42 (the first file said 63.64, and nothing checked it); the provision per option and the break-even probability, 47 per cent, are computed.
Download the workbook23 KBChapters 5 and 6
Enforcement is the alternative every other option is priced against, and it is the one most often estimated rather than computed. Four separate things destroy the value — the forced-sale discount, the delay, the transaction costs and the cost of carrying the asset — and sheet 2 shows each of them in euros and in cents on the euro of loan, ranked. On the base case the largest is not the one people assume.
Sheet 3 is a two-way grid over the discount and the delay, in recovery and again in indifference point: find your own view in the grid rather than arguing about a base case. Sheet 4 runs the identical loan through six asset classes — residential is repaid in full, a shopping centre recovers 31.3 per cent — and prices a receiver against a share pledge, which is worth seventeen points. (Revised: the first file let residential “recover” 102.5 per cent; a lender cannot recover more than it is owed, and the surplus is now shown as the borrower’s. The book says nineteen points in three places; the arithmetic, 73.5 against 56.3, says seventeen.)
At the bottom of sheet 4: what waiting a year costs. Even on an improving market it loses money, and the break-even yield compression is 73 basis points a year.
Download the workbook22 KBChapters 9 to 12
Three years of cash flow with the lender’s cash capped at the income the building actually earns, the shortfall added to the balance rather than quietly forgiven, capex funded by the sponsor before any lender money, and an exit capped at the outstanding balance. The covenants are re-tested each year, because an extension that breaches in year two has not been thought through.
Sheet 4 is the sheet that matters: a grid over year-3 income and exit yield, against the recovery on the payoff that is actually on the table. An extension that only works in one corner of that grid is not a plan, it is a hope with a term sheet attached. This one beats the payoff in every cell, down to 69.3 per cent against 69.0; and if the letting plan fails outright, with income flat at 5.15, it still returns 74.52, where the book says it returns less than enforcement.
Revised: the first file counted 1.24 a year of amortisation on top of income already spent on interest, and never paid out the 1.5 of capex the lender advances — the lender “received” 6.39 in year one from a building earning 5.15. With the cash capped at the income, as Chapter 33 says it must be, the extension is worth 80.33, not 81.75, and repays in full only up to a 6.69 per cent exit yield, not 7.01.
Also inside, and left out of most workout analyses entirely: the swap mark to market, and what the sponsor guarantee is actually worth once the solvency discount, the time discount and the years it takes to collect are applied. On this file that is 4.8 points of recovery, against a headline cap that suggests far more.
Download the workbook25 KBAppendix A · the committee paper
The eighty diligence questions as a live checklist — the same eighty, generated from the same source as the appendix, so the book and the workbook cannot drift apart. There are columns for the answer, the source document, the owner and the date, and the status column marks anything answered without a source as unsourced. A question whose answer is “the borrower says” is not answered.
Then the one-page decision record, and the committee paper’s switching values: the level of each input at which the recommendation changes. Five lines, and the committee knows exactly how wrong it can afford to be. Revised: the five values were typed in and checked against themselves; they are now computed from a model under the table: 94.9 million, 0.47 years, 0.6 per cent, 10.29 per cent (not 11.48) and 5.01 per cent.
Do not work through the eighty in order. Start with sections three and four — cash and income — because those can be answered from documents rather than from the borrower.
Download the workbook23 KBThe reason a workout committee argues in circles is that the four options are never presented on the same basis. Enforcement returns cash in two years; an extension returns it in three or four; a discounted payoff returns it next month. Comparing a recovery percentage across those three timetables is comparing nothing at all.
Discounted to today over its own timetable, the same loan gives enforcement 46.42 (56.3 per cent), a consensual sale 66.42 (80.5), the extension 80.33 (97.4), and a discounted payoff at the price on the table 56.89 (69.0). The extension wins here, but it is a three-year plan against cash in six months: it is the better choice only if the letting plan is more than 47 per cent likely to work.
58.7 cents. Below it a discounted payoff is worse than enforcing; above it, better. A borrower offering 55 is offering less than the lender’s own alternative, and a lender demanding 70 is asking for more than its alternative supports. Neither side normally knows the number, so the range gets set by whoever is more confident — which is not the same thing as whoever is right.
It also moves. Nine cents on the forced-sale discount alone, from 18 to 30 per cent. That is why the workbook makes the discount an input rather than a house assumption, and why the honest way to take this into a meeting is with the grid rather than the point.
The extension model originally forgave the unpaid interest instead of adding it to the balance, and the checks sheet caught it: 79.86 against the 81.75 the book states. Both the book and the workbooks now capitalise the shortfall, which is what the loan documents would do. The recovery moved from 96.8 per cent to 99.1, and the error had been in the direction that flatters the lender — which is the direction errors in workout models usually run.
The same model had a second error that no check could catch, because the book printed the same figure: the lender’s cash was the whole income plus 1.24 a year of amortisation, and the capex it advances never left its pocket. Capped at the income, the extension is worth 80.33, not 81.75 (97.4 against 99.1 per cent), and the balance at the exit is 86.74. The ranking does not move. Again the error flattered the lender. A check only tests the model against the book; when both share the mistake, the only defence is recomputing from the rule.
The four workbooks with every input emptied. The checks sheets count what is still missing and test what holds for any inputs.
Chapters 1 to 7, 15, 24, 26 and 28
The four options, the enforcement bridge, the extension and the committee paper’s switching values, with the same formulas and every blue cell emptied. The grid steps, the six sector profiles and the two enforcement routes stay: they are the book’s comparisons, not your loan.
The book’s inputs are listed in a text file inside the archive. Type them back in and its figures come back with them: 46.42 for enforcement, 80.33 for the extension, 58.7 cents.
Download the blank set79 KBThirteen pages to print and use. A4, with margins wide enough for US Letter.
Chapters 3 to 38 · Appendix D
A broken loan in ninety minutes, with the split between income and yield and the covenant table. The four options on one page, with the indifference point, the break-even probability and the provisions. Pricing enforcement, deduction by deduction and route by route. The extension year by year, with the four rules that keep it honest. The first thirty days. The standstill. Documenting an extension, a payoff and a sale. The twelve clauses. The information you will not be given, with the rent-roll tests. Before accepting a payoff: the source of the money, the hedge, the guarantee and tax. The credit committee paper. The decision record and the twelve mistakes. And when there are other parties: the syndicate, the mezzanine, a second jurisdiction and a servicer.
Download the documents37 KBA workbook that marks itself. Answer in the yellow cells; the marking fills in as you go.
All parts of the book
Six on the loan and the fall in value, seven on enforcement, seven on the extension, seven on the payoff, the sale and the negotiation, seven on the rest of the file, and six on the three cases below. Numbers are marked to a tolerance, multiple choice to the letter, and the score sheet counts your errors part by part: that is your revision list.
Nothing is hidden. The marking sheet holds every answer, every tolerance, and the reason for each answer.
Download the questions17 KBNew material, not a restatement. Three situations the chapters name and never take to a number. Each case is one workbook: the note is the first sheet, the model is the rest, and a checks sheet closes it. Type your own figures in and every finding recomputes.
Chapter 28 · Case one
Chapter 28 prices a year of waiting with the lender funding the carry, finds that yields must tighten by 73 basis points, and says that if the building pays its way “the break-even falls sharply”. How sharply: with the trapped rent reaching the lender, to about 5 basis points. The chapter’s 25 basis points pay once 73 per cent of the rent arrives (a threshold, not an ADDED forecast). And even a receiver collecting every euro of rent for the whole enforcement would reach 56.54, still short of the offer’s 56.89.
Download the three cases34 KBChapter 17 · Case two
The chapter tells the senior to budget 1.5 million to buy out a 12 million mezzanine “entitled to nothing”. It is entitled to nothing in every option but one: if the extension works, the surplus at the exit is 6.08, worth 4.70 today. So 1.5 is a fair price only if the plan is less than 32 per cent likely to work; at an ADDED 50 per cent the range runs from 2.35 to 14.02, and below a 24.6 per cent chance the whole manoeuvre loses to enforcement.
Chapter 27 · Case three
The originating bank, the insurer, the debt fund and the small bank, each against its own book (holdings and carrying values ADDED). Enforcement is a loss for all four. The insurer can be bought out: a zone of 3.04 million between the payoff it wants and what a buyer at 15 per cent pays. The small bank cannot: it carries at par and no buyer pays more than 97.4. What gets its signature is a senior strip money-good in every scenario: enforcement’s own 56.35 of cash covers its holding 4.6 times. On the way, a correction: the debt fund bought at 64 cents, not the 74 the book prints, at which the 72-cent offer would be a loss.
| Blue on a pale fill | an input — you may edit these |
| Black text | a formula — do not overtype these |
| Yellow fill | the assumptions that carry the answer |
| Checks sheet | the last sheet of every workbook: each control states its own verdict, and the file ends ALL OK |
| ADDED | a figure the book does not give, used in the cases and marked wherever it appears |
Amounts are in millions of euros. Harbour Quay is fictional, and deliberately ordinary rather than extreme: it is the commonest broken loan there is. 149 checks across the four workbooks, and every one passes: the figures the book prints, each to the precision the book prints at, and the identities that hold for any inputs — a figure printed to two decimals is checked to 0.005. The rule behind those sheets is the reason to trust them: if a check fails, the model is wrong until proven otherwise, not the book.
The Real Estate Workout develops the complete framework behind these models, with the assumptions, trade-offs and worked examples tied together.
View the book on Amazon Read the related analysisAlso as an ebook on Apple Books · Google Play.
The workbooks open in Microsoft Excel, LibreOffice Calc, Google Sheets and Numbers; the PDF prints on A4 or US Letter. They use no macros and no add-ins, so nothing needs to be enabled or trusted. If your spreadsheet asks to update links on opening, decline — there are none.
| 24 Sep 2026 | The four workbooks corrected; each now ends on a checks sheet, 149 checks in all, ALL OK. The extension capped at the income the building earns: 80.33, not 81.75 (recovery 97.4, not 99.1). The consensual sale on Chapter 6’s own assumptions (66.42, not 63.64). Residential recovery capped at the loan; the share pledge worth seventeen points, not nineteen; the switching values computed, not typed. Added: a blank set, thirteen working documents, forty questions that mark themselves, and three cases. |
More in real estate, with free companion files. The full list of titles is on the author page.
If this book helped — or didn’t — a few lines on Amazon are worth more than they look: they are what the next reader goes on. Write a review. The workbook stays free either way.
Also available as a standalone free template: loan workout options model.