Book · Julian R. Sterling
Running, Growing, Valuing and Selling an Independent Insurance Agency: Commissions, Retention, Producers, Book Purchases, Consolidators and Succession
In October 2026 a letter from a private equity backed acquirer lands on the desk of the founder of an independent insurance agency. The same month, a retiring neighbor offers his book of business. The founder plans to step back within five years and asks the successor a plain question: what is the agency worth, and which road should it take?
The Insurance Agency Owner is a practitioner's guide to the owner's desk of an independent property and casualty agency: how the agency earns, what it really owns, how it grows, what it is worth and who can own it next. One fictional agency, Tamberlow Insurance Agency, fifteen people and $35.00 million of premium placed, is followed from its commission statements to the choice of its next owner. Every figure of the case comes from one model.
Some of what the arithmetic shows: why reported EBITDA of $1.19 million becomes $1.38 million once the owner's pay, a one-off cost and the contingents are normalized; why one point of commercial retention is worth about $193,800 of value at the buyer's multiple; why carrier rate increases flatter organic growth; why a producer who leaves without an enforceable agreement can take $2.48 million of value with him; how a book bought at $0.99 million pays for itself; why an earn-out of up to $3.45 million is worth $1.41 million on the base projection; and why staying independent beats a sale today only if the agency can sell at more than 5.7x its EBITDA five years from now.
The model is not described, it is supplied. A companion workbook rebuilds the agency by live formula, with a Checks sheet and an exercise for every lever, and the checklists come as an editable document. The closing pages say where to find them.
What you will be able to do:
Sixteen chapters in four parts and four appendices: a guide to the workbook with fifteen exercises, eight owner's checklists, thirty-six questions an owner, a buyer or a lender will ask, with model answers, and a glossary of sixty terms.
Written for owners and future owners of independent property and casualty agencies; producers who want to buy a book or a share of their agency; successors and agency managers; and buyers of agencies and the people who work with them. The case, its agency, its carriers, its buyers and its figures are fictional teaching assumptions, not market rates, market multiples or market pay; real-world facts are dated as of November 2026. This book is for education only. It is not legal, tax, accounting or investment advice. Part of The Private Markets Career Guides.
How this book was made: written with the help of artificial intelligence tools, under the author's direction; every figure was computed by a model and every rule was checked against its source.
Related titles. The full list is on the author page.