Articles · US Corporate Tax
Dual-prong voting and nonvoting control rules, catastrophic tax failure at 78.63%, the 10% accommodation transferor safe harbor, and Intermountain Lumber binding commitments.
In an IRC Section 351 formation, property transferors must own at least 80% of voting power and 80% of each nonvoting class immediately after the exchange. Granting just 21.37% of voting stock solely for services drops property-transferor control to 78.63%, blowing up tax-free treatment for every founder and investor and triggering $1,636,780 of incremental Day-1 tax in the Meridian Precision Systems case.
IRC Section 351(a) defers gain or loss only if the transferors of property are in "control" of the transferee corporation immediately after the exchange. Under IRC Section 368(c) and Rev. Rul. 59-259, control requires two independent thresholds simultaneously: at least 80% of total combined voting power of all voting stock AND at least 80% of the total number of shares of each separate class of nonvoting stock. Under Section 351(d)(1), stock issued solely for services is NOT property, so a pure service provider is excluded from the transferor control group.
In the formation of Meridian Precision Systems, Inc., three property transferors (Elena Vance, Apex Industrial Ventures LP, and Borealis Robotics Corp.) receive 9,200 voting common shares (1,000 nonvoting NQPS shares to Apex, which still count as stock for Section 368(c) control). CTO Marcus Chen receives voting common stock solely for engineering services:
| Scenario | Property Voting Shares | Service Shares | Total Voting Shares | Control % | Sec. 351 Verdict |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Base Case (800 Service Shares) | 9,200 | 800 | 10,000 | 92.00% | PASS |
| Services Trap (2,500 Service Shares) | 9,200 | 2,500 | 11,700 | 78.63% | FAIL |
| Accommodation Cure (+$250,000 Cash) | 11,950 | Included | 11,950 | 100.00% | PASS |
| Binding Sale of 2,500 Shares (Intermountain) | 6,700 | 800 | 10,000 | 67.00% | FAIL |
When Marcus receives 2,500 service-only shares, property-transferor control drops to 78.63% (9,200 / 11,700). Section 351 collapses for the entire group: Elena recognizes her full $5,800,000 realized gain ($1,723,600 tax instead of $148,700), and Apex recognizes $800,000 net gain ($190,400 tax instead of $128,520), creating $1,636,780 of avoidable Day-1 tax damage.
If Marcus contributes property alongside his services, all of his shares (both property shares and service shares) count toward Section 368(c) control, UNLESS his property contribution is of "relatively small value" made primarily to qualify other transferors (Treas. Reg. 1.351-1(a)(1)(ii)). Under Rev. Proc. 77-37 Section 3.07, the IRS safe harbor requires contributed property FMV to equal at least 10% of the FMV of stock already owned or received for services. On $2,500,000 of service stock, Marcus must contribute at least $250,000 in cash or qualifying property; a token $50,000 contribution (2.00%) fails the safe harbor and leaves the entire incorporation taxable.
1. IRC Sections 351(a), 351(d)(1), 368(c); Treas. Reg. 1.351-1(a)(1)(ii) (verified 2026-11-21).
2. Rev. Rul. 59-259; Rev. Proc. 77-37 Section 3.07; Intermountain Lumber Co. v. Commissioner, 65 T.C. 1025 (1976).
No. Under IRC Section 351(d)(1), services are not property. A transferor who receives stock solely for services is excluded from the transferor group unless they also transfer qualifying property meeting the Treas. Reg. 1.351-1(a)(1)(ii) and Rev. Proc. 77-37 10% threshold.
Property transferred by a service provider or existing shareholder is not disregarded as relatively small value if its fair market value equals at least 10% of the fair market value of stock already owned or to be received for services by that person.
Yes. Although Section 351(g) treats NQPS as boot for gain recognition purposes, NQPS continues to count as stock when testing the 80% control thresholds under Section 368(c).
Run your own Section 368(c) control check, Section 357(c) liability allocation, Rev. Rul. 68-55 boot schedule, and Section 362(e)(2) election model in the Section 351 Incorporation Calculator (Excel).
Complete worked computations on Meridian Precision Systems, Inc. and Horizon Precision Partners LP covering IRC Sections 351, 357, 358, 362(e)(2), 368(c), Rev. Rul. 68-55, and Rev. Rul. 84-111.