Articles · Subchapter C

Section 336(d) Anti-Stuffing Loss Disallowance Rules Explained

How IRC Sections 336(d)(1), 336(d)(2), and 336(d)(3) permanently disallow corporate liquidation losses, with worked examples from Cobalt Industrial Components.

Although IRC Section 336(a) generally allows a liquidating C corporation to recognize losses on depreciated property, IRC Section 336(d) erects three formidable anti-stuffing barriers. Missing any one of them permanently destroys corporate tax deductions and turns a loss liquidation into a hefty federal tax bill.

1. Section 336(d)(1): Distributions to Section 267 Related Persons

Under IRC Section 336(d)(1)(A), 100% of a corporate loss (both pre-contribution and post-contribution decline) is permanently disallowed on any distribution to a Section 267 related person (> 50% direct or constructive ownership) if either: (i) the distribution is not pro rata, OR (ii) the asset is disqualified property acquired in a Section 351 exchange or capital contribution within the 5-year period ending on the distribution date.

In Cobalt Industrial Components, Inc. (CIC, owned 70% by related shareholder Marcus Vance and 30% by unrelated shareholder Elena Ortiz), distributing a 3-year-old warehouse (basis $4,200,000, FMV $2,400,000, loss -$1,800,000) 100% non-pro-rata to Marcus disallows the entire $1,800,000 loss, driving CIC's federal corporate tax to $546,000. Switching to a pro-rata 70/30 distribution salvages the 30% unrelated share ($540,000 allowed loss), cutting corporate tax to $432,600 and saving $113,400 immediately.

2. Section 336(d)(2): The Two-Year Tax-Avoidance Stuffing Presumption

Unlike Section 336(d)(1), IRC Section 336(d)(2) reaches sales to unrelated third parties as well as distributions. If depreciated property was contributed in a Section 351 exchange or capital contribution within 2 years before adoption of the plan of liquidation, it is presumed acquired with a tax-avoidance purpose (rebuttable only by a clear and substantial business relationship). Basis for determining loss is reduced by the pre-contribution built-in loss, while post-contribution economic decline remains deductible.

On CIC's stuffed securities portfolio (contributed 14 months prior with basis $3,600,000 and FMV $2,100,000, sold at liquidation for $1,700,000), Section 336(d)(2) disallows the $1,500,000 pre-contribution built-in loss (costing $315,000 in tax) while preserving the $400,000 post-contribution decline.

3. Section 336(d)(3): Minority Distributions in Section 332 Liquidations

In an 80-percent parent-subsidiary liquidation under Section 332, Section 336(d)(3) disallows 100% of corporate losses on distributions to minority shareholders even though gains on minority distributions remain fully taxable under Section 336(a). Always sell loss assets to unrelated buyers prior to liquidation or route them to the 80-percent parent to preserve carryover basis.

Test Your Own Liquidation Assets

Run both Section 336(d)(1) and Section 336(d)(2) automatically on Tab Sec336d_AntiStuffing of the free companion workbook.

Download Free Excel Calculator → Read the Full Handbook

Related guides: Section 331 vs. Section 332 Tax Rules · Section 165(g)(3) Insolvent Subsidiaries · Section 754 Partnership Basis Adjustments