Articles · The IFRS 17 Handbook

IFRS 17 GMM vs. PAA vs. VFA: Measurement Models Compared

Eligibility criteria, Liability for Remaining Coverage vs. Liability for Incurred Claims, CSM mechanics, and side-by-side worked examples across life, P&C, and participating portfolios.

IFRS 17 prescribes three measurement models: the General Measurement Model (GMM, also called the Building Block Approach) as the default for long-duration contracts, the Premium Allocation Approach (PAA) as an optional simplification for short-duration coverage, and the Variable Fee Approach (VFA) as a mandatory modification for contracts with direct participation features. Choosing and documenting the right model determines how profit emerges and how market volatility hits the income statement.

1. Side-by-Side Comparison of GMM, PAA, and VFA

DimensionGMM (Default)PAA (Optional)VFA (Mandatory if Eligible)
IFRS 17 Paragraphs32 to 4453 to 5945, B101 to B118
Typical ProductsTerm life, whole life, annuities, long-term protectionMotor, property, marine, 12-month commercial linesUnit-linked with guarantees, participating savings
Explicit CSM on LRC?Yes (unearned profit)No (premium-based LRC)Yes (variable fee absorbed)
CSM Interest AccretionLocked-in discount rateNot applicableNone (implicit in variable fee)
Financial Market ChangesP&L or OCI (never CSM)LIC discounting to P&L/OCIEntity share adjusts CSM
LIC MeasurementPVFCF + RA (current rate)PVFCF + RA (same as GMM)PVFCF + RA (current rate)

2. Worked Comparison Across Three MLG Portfolios

To see how each model behaves numerically, consider three cohorts written by Meridian Life & General Insurance plc (MLG, USD thousands):

Go deeper in The IFRS 17 Handbook

The free Excel workbook includes all four measurement tabs (GMM, Onerous + Reinsurance, PAA, and VFA) pre-loaded with Meridian Life & General's exact numbers.

Get the free Excel calculator → · View the handbook

3. Common Eligibility Pitfalls

Three practical traps surface regularly during external audits and regulatory reviews:

First, PAA is not optional for multi-year contracts without quantitative testing. If a 3-year engineering or warranty policy uses PAA, the insurer must document under IFRS 17.53(a) that LRC under PAA does not differ materially from GMM under reasonably expected scenarios (including interest rate shifts and claim pattern changes).

Second, VFA is mandatory, not an accounting policy choice. If a contract meets all three IFRS 17.B101 criteria at initial recognition, the insurer must apply VFA. Conversely, reinsurance contracts issued or held are strictly prohibited from using VFA (IFRS 17.B109).

Third, PAA acquisition cash flow elections affect mid-year balance sheets. Under IFRS 17.59(a), insurers with coverage of one year or less may expense acquisition cash flows immediately. On Cohort C, deferring $3,600.0k of acquisition costs reduces mid-year Q2 LRC from $12,000.0k to $10,200.0k, even though full-year Year 1 P&L is identical.

Frequently Asked Questions

When is an insurer eligible to use the Premium Allocation Approach (PAA)?

Automatically when the coverage period is one year or less (IFRS 17.53(b)), or for longer coverage periods if the insurer demonstrates PAA reasonably approximates GMM LRC (IFRS 17.53(a)).

Does PAA eliminate discounting and Risk Adjustment on claims liabilities?

No. PAA simplifies only the LRC. The Liability for Incurred Claims (LIC) always requires a Risk Adjustment and must be discounted whenever claims are expected to settle more than one year after being incurred.

What makes a contract qualify for the Variable Fee Approach (VFA)?

All three IFRS 17.B101 criteria must hold at inception: a clearly identified underlying pool, a substantial share of fair value returns paid to policyholders, and a substantial proportion of cash flow variability linked to underlying fair value changes.

The IFRS 17 Handbook

Every GMM, PAA, VFA, onerous contract, reinsurance held, and transition schedule worked end to end on Meridian Life & General Insurance plc, with a free live Excel calculator.

PDF edition ($19.99) Paperback ($32.99) Free Excel calculator →

Also on this site

Sources: IASB IFRS 17 Insurance Contracts (paragraphs 32-59, B101-B118). Figures verified 2026-11-21.