Articles · IFRIC 23 Valuation

IFRIC 23 Uncertain Tax Treatments: Most Likely Amount vs. Expected Value in Practice

IFRIC 23 Uncertainty over Income Tax Treatments transformed how IFRS reporters measure and defend uncertain tax positions. Two rules drive every audit discussion: the mandatory 100% detection risk assumption (IFRIC 23.8) and the disciplined choice between Most Likely Amount and Expected Value (IFRIC 23.11).

100% Detection Risk and the Probable Threshold

Under IFRIC 23.8, preparers must assume that the taxation authority will examine every amount it has a legal right to examine and will have full knowledge of all related information. Perceived low audit probability is strictly irrelevant. Once technical merits are assessed on that basis, IFRIC 23.9 and 23.10 establish a clear threshold: if acceptance by the tax authority is probable (more than 50% likelihood), the entity reflects the filing position consistently in its tax provision. If acceptance is not probable (50% or less), the entity must measure the effect of uncertainty using the method that better predicts resolution.

Case 1: Binary Outcome (Most Likely Amount, IFRIC 23.11(a))

Veridian Industrial Group SE claimed an R&D super-deduction worth EUR 12.00M in tax savings (UTP-1). Tax counsel assesses only a 35.00% probability of acceptance under full examination (65.00% probability of full disallowance). Because the statutory dispute is binary (either the project qualifies in full or fails in full), IFRIC 23.11(a) mandates the Most Likely Amount: EUR 12.00M.

Had management incorrectly applied Expected Value, it would have booked EUR 7.80M, an outcome that can never occur in reality and understates the likely cash outflow by EUR 4.20M.

Case 2: Multi-Scenario Band (Expected Value, IFRIC 23.11(b))

Veridian's cross-border transfer pricing markup dispute (UTP-2) spans five plausible settlement outcomes from EUR 0.00M to EUR 20.00M. Because outcomes are distributed across a negotiation range rather than concentrated on a single point, IFRIC 23.11(b) mandates Expected Value. In FY 2025, the probability-weighted liability is EUR 8.20M. In FY 2026, an adverse preliminary audit notice issued to a comparable peer triggers a reassessment under IFRIC 23.13, shifting probabilities toward higher exposures:

Settlement ScenarioExposureFY25 ProbFY26 ProbFY26 Weighted
Scenario 1 (Full Acceptance)EUR 0.00M15.00%5.00%EUR 0.00M
Scenario 2 (Minor Adjustment)EUR 4.00M25.00%15.00%EUR 0.60M
Scenario 3 (Median Settlement)EUR 8.00M30.00%30.00%EUR 2.40M
Scenario 4 (Adverse Band)EUR 14.00M20.00%30.00%EUR 4.20M
Scenario 5 (Full Disallowance)EUR 20.00M10.00%20.00%EUR 4.00M
Expected Value Total-100.00%100.00%EUR 11.20M

The reassessment increases UTP-2 from EUR 8.20M to EUR 11.20M, generating a +EUR 3.00M current tax charge in FY 2026 (accounted for prospectively under IAS 8). Combined with UTP-1 (EUR 12.00M), total IFRIC 23 uncertain tax liabilities reach EUR 23.20M at December 31, 2026, presented within current tax liabilities under IAS 1.54 rather than IAS 37 provisions. Contrast this with US GAAP ASC 740-10 (FIN 48) in IAS 12 vs. ASC 740, where cumulative probability measurement yields EUR 14.00M on UTP-2 (+EUR 2.80M higher).

Free Companion Excel Workbook

Test these exact schedules with live formulas in IAS_12_Deferred_Tax_IFRIC_23_Calculator.xlsx (zero macros, 12 automated controls).

Download the free IAS 12 & IFRIC 23 calculator →

Go deeper in The IAS 12 Income Taxes and IFRIC 23 Handbook

16 chapters covering balance-sheet tax bases, single-transaction leases and AROs, outside basis differences, IFRIC 23 valuation, Pillar Two disclosures, ETR proof, and IAS 12 vs. ASC 740.

View the handbook →