Articles · Market Risk & Basel III

FRTB Internal Models Approach (IMA): PLA Test Thresholds, RFET & NMRF Capital Surcharge

Under FRTB, internal model approval is granted trading desk by trading desk, gated continuously by Backtesting, the Profit and Loss Attribution (PLA) test, and the Risk Factor Eligibility Test (RFET).

FRTB replaces 99% VaR with 97.5% Expected Shortfall (ES) scaled across five liquidity horizons (10, 20, 40, 60, and 120 days). Every approved desk must pass 250-day backtesting and the PLA test comparing Risk-Theoretical P&L (RTPL) to Hypothetical P&L (HPL). At Northbridge Capital Markets Bank (NCMB), Desk 1 is Green, Desk 2 is Amber ($3.704M surcharge), and Desk 3 is Red (SA fallback), yielding $72.158M hybrid capital (22.12% below full SA).

1. PLA Test Traffic-Light Thresholds (MAR32.42)

The PLA test evaluates 250 daily pairs of RTPL and HPL using two non-parametric statistics: the Spearman rank correlation (testing monotonic alignment) and the Kolmogorov-Smirnov (KS) metric (measuring maximum vertical distance between empirical CDFs). A desk's zone is determined by the worse of the two metrics.

PLA ZoneSpearman ThresholdKS MetricCapital Consequence
Green≥ 0.80< 0.09Full IMA eligibility; zero PLA surcharge
Amber0.70 to < 0.800.09 to 0.12IMA retained, plus MAR33.43 Amber capital surcharge
Red< 0.70> 0.12Desk loses IMA approval; mandatory SA fallback (C_U)

2. Worked Example: NCMB PLA Surcharge & NMRF Capital

On NCMB Desk 1 (Rates & FX, Green: Spearman 0.91, KS 0.052; bank-wide backtesting multiplier m_c = 1.70 based on 5 aggregate exceptions across IMA-eligible desks), liquidity-scaled ES_R,S equals $16.042M, full/reduced scaling lifts IMCC(C) to $17.004M, and blending 50/50 with constrained sum IMCC(C_i) ($22.600M) gives IMCC = $19.802M. Taking max(19.802, 1.70 * 17.500) = $29.750M plus $2.100M NMRF SES yields Desk 1 IMA = $31.850M (vs. $48.681M SA).

On Desk 2 (Corporate Credit, Amber: Spearman 0.76, KS 0.098; same bank-wide m_c = 1.70), IMCC capital is $6.800M, NMRF SES combines two idiosyncratic spread factors ($1.140M) and two non-idiosyncratic factors at rho = 0.60 ($1.576M) for $2.716M total, and DRC-IMA adds $4.600M, giving Desk 2 IMA = $14.116M (vs. $21.481M SA).

Because Desk 2 is Amber, MAR33.43 applies an Amber factor k = 0.50 * (SA_Amber / SA_GA) = 0.50 * (21.481 / 70.162) = 15.31%, creating a PLA Amber Surcharge = 15.31% * (70.162 - 45.966) = $3.704M. Desk 3 fails PLA in Red (Spearman 0.62, KS 0.145) and falls back to SA ($22.488M).

Go deeper in The FRTB Handbook

See the full Expected Shortfall liquidity horizon cascade, RFET data-pooling rules, and Backtesting multiplier table in The FRTB Handbook.

Get the free Excel calculator → · View the handbook

3. Interaction with the 72.5% Output Floor

Scenario (NCMB Bank-Wide)Capital ($M)RWA ($M)vs. Full SA
Full FRTB-SA (Baseline)92.6501,158.130.00%
Hybrid IMA + SA (Base: Desk 2 Amber)72.158901.97-22.12%
Sensitivity 1: Desk 2 Cures PLA to Green68.454855.67-26.12%
72.5% Output Floor (Full Phase-In)67.171839.64-27.50%
Sensitivity 3: Desk 2 NMRF SES Doubles74.458930.73-19.63%

The trap: Curing Desk 2 from Amber to Green saves $3.704M (dropping capital to $68.454M), leaving just $1.283M of headroom above the 72.5% Output Floor ($67.171M). Banks must always evaluate IMA remediation investments against their bank-wide Output Floor headroom.

Frequently Asked Questions

1. What happens when a risk factor fails the 24-observation RFET?

It is classified as a Non-Modellable Risk Factor (NMRF) and excluded from Expected Shortfall. Instead, it receives a standalone Stressed Expected Shortfall (SES) capital charge calibrated to a 12-month stress period with limited diversification (zero correlation for idiosyncratic credit/equity, 60% correlation for non-idiosyncratic factors).

2. When does UK PRA FRTB-IMA go live compared to EU CRR3?

EU CRR3 FRTB (both SA and IMA) takes effect on January 1, 2027, whereas UK PRA Basel 3.1 (PS1/26) applies FRTB-SA on January 1, 2027 and delays FRTB-IMA by one year to January 1, 2028.

3. Can Hybrid IMA+SA capital ever exceed Full FRTB-SA?

No. Under MAR33.43, total bank-wide market risk capital under IMA (including Amber surcharges and Red fallbacks) is capped at the bank-wide FRTB-SA capital requirement.

Sources & Related Reading

The FRTB Handbook

Every SBM Delta, Vega, Curvature, DRC, RRAO, IMA Expected Shortfall, PLA test, and Output Floor schedule worked end to end on Northbridge Capital Markets Bank, with a free live Excel calculator.

PDF edition ($19.99) Paperback ($32.99) Free Excel calculator →