Articles · US Corporate Tax
How single damages, relator shares, SOX 308 Fair Funds, and the antitrust two-thirds rule determine corporate after-tax settlement cost
Three high-dollar corporate enforcement regimes generate the majority of IRS Large Business and International (LB&I) settlement audits: DOJ False Claims Act (qui tam) settlements, SEC disgorgement orders, and Clayton Act Section 4 antitrust treble damages under IRC Section 162(g). Each follows distinct statutory mechanics that can swing a corporation's after-tax cash cost by tens of millions of dollars.
Under 31 U.S.C. Section 3729, False Claims Act liability carries treble damages plus statutory per-claim penalties. Post-TCJA, the old intent-based allocation standard of Fresenius Medical Care is dead: only the portion explicitly identified in the DOJ Settlement Agreement as restitution (typically single damages) and established by documentary proof is deductible. In VBI's $45,000,000.00 FCA settlement (2.50x multiple), $18,000,000.00 is identified as Medicare/Medicaid single damages (deductible) while $27,000,000.00 is permanently disallowed under Section 162(f)(1). The whistleblower's 20.00% relator's share ($9,000,000.00), paid by DOJ out of the settlement proceeds, follows the underlying DOJ allocation ($3,600,000.00 deductible / $5,400,000.00 nondeductible). By contrast, separate statutory relator's counsel fees under 31 U.S.C. Section 3730(d)(1) ($1,800,000.00) and VBI's own defense fees ($3,200,000.00) remain 100% deductible under Section 162(a).
Following Liu v. SEC and final Treas. Reg. Section 1.162-21(e)(4)(i)(B), disgorgement paid to the general account of the U.S. Treasury is strictly nondeductible because it is not distributed to harmed investors. However, when an SEC order directs disgorgement into a Sarbanes-Oxley Section 308 Fair Fund for distribution to identifiable injured shareholders and satisfies both Identification and Establishment, the payment can qualify as deductible restitution. For VBI's $30,000,000.00 SEC Order ($18,000,000.00 Fair Fund + $12,000,000.00 civil monetary penalty), routing disgorgement through a Fair Fund saves $4,590,000.00 in cash taxes at a 25.50% combined rate compared with a Treasury General Fund remittance.
IRC Section 162(g) and Treas. Reg. Section 1.162-22 operate completely outside Section 162(f) and Form 1098-F. When a corporation is convicted or enters a guilty or nolo contendere plea in a federal criminal Sherman Act proceeding, two-thirds of any subsequent civil treble damages paid to private plaintiffs under Section 4 of the Clayton Act are permanently nondeductible. On VBI's $15,000,000.00 private antitrust settlement, only one-third ($5,000,000.00) is deductible, while two-thirds ($10,000,000.00) is permanently disallowed, costing $2,550,000.00 in lost tax shield compared to a pre-plea civil settlement.
| Enforcement Matter | Gross Principal | Deductible / Recov. | Nondeductible | Lost Tax Shield |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| DOJ False Claims Act | $45,000,000.00 | $18,000,000.00 | $27,000,000.00 | $6,885,000.00 |
| SEC Enforcement Order | $30,000,000.00 | $18,000,000.00 | $12,000,000.00 | $3,060,000.00 |
| Antitrust Section 162(g) | $15,000,000.00 | $5,000,000.00 | $10,000,000.00 | $2,550,000.00 |
Test these exact rules on your own settlement numbers with the Section 162(f) Settlement Deductibility Calculator (Excel), or explore all 16 chapters in The Section 162(f) Fines, Penalties, and Settlements Tax Handbook.
Section 162(f) Identification and Establishment Requirements: Restitution & Remediation Guide
Form 1098-F Reporting Threshold ($50,000) and Corporate Tax Reconciliation Guide
Related corporate tax handbooks: Section 381 · Section 385 · Section 460 · Section 467