Articles · Business Brokerage

Business Broker Commission Rates: 10% Flat vs. Double Lehman Worked Examples

Main Street business brokers charge 10% flat (with a $15,000 to $25,000 floor) under $1,000,000, and tiered Double Lehman rates of 7.5% to 8.5% on $1,000,000 to $5,000,000 deals.

Main Street business brokers charge a 10% flat success fee under $1,000,000, with a $15,000 to $25,000 minimum fee floor. Between $1,000,000 and $5,000,000, most brokerages apply the Double Lehman schedule (10/8/6/4/2), reducing a $2,500,000 seller's fee from $250,000 to $210,000 (8.40%). Understanding co-broker splits and seller-note clauses protects closing proceeds.

1. Standard Main Street vs. Lower Middle Market Commission Structures

Business brokerage fees split at the $1,000,000 mark. Below $1,000,000 (Main Street businesses priced on Seller's Discretionary Earnings, or SDE), brokers quote a flat 10% commission with no upfront retainer and a minimum fee floor of $15,000 to $25,000. The floor exists because a $200,000 service business requires nearly as much valuation, buyer screening, and SBA loan work as a $750,000 listing. On a $200,000 sale with a $25,000 floor, the effective rate reaches 12.50%.

Above $1,000,000 (the lower middle market, priced on adjusted EBITDA with SBA 7(a) loans capped at $5,000,000), brokerages switch to the Double Lehman formula: 10% on the first $1,000,000, 8% on the second $1,000,000, 6% on the third $1,000,000, 4% on the fourth $1,000,000, and 2% above $4,000,000. Many firms also use a Modified Double Lehman schedule (10% on the first $1,000,000, 8% on the next $1,000,000, and 6% above $2,000,000, with a $150,000 minimum fee and a $25,000 retainer credited at closing). Institutional M&A banks on $25,000,000+ deals use separate classic Lehman scales; this guide covers $250,000 to $5,000,000 business brokerages.

Market SegmentDeal SizeFee FormulaMinimum FloorRetainer
Main Street$150K to $1.0M10% flat$15,000 - $25,000$0
Lower Middle Market (Double Lehman)$1.0M to $5.0M10% / 8% / 6% / 4% / 2%$100,000 - $150,000$15K - $25K
Lower Middle Market (Modified 10/8/6)$1.5M to $5.0M10% / 8% / 6% above $2M$150,000$25,000

2. Worked Example 1: 10% Flat vs. Double Lehman on $750K and $2.5M Sales

Compare two illustrative sales: Deal A, a $750,000 Main Street plumbing company with $15,000 in seller closing costs, and Deal B, a $2,500,000 commercial contractor with $40,000 in seller closing costs.

On Deal A ($750,000), both 10% flat and Double Lehman yield $75,000 (10.00%) because the entire price falls in the first $1,000,000 tier. After $75,000 in commission and $15,000 in legal and CPA fees, the seller nets $660,000 (88.00%) before debt payoff and taxes.

On Deal B ($2,500,000), Double Lehman saves the seller $40,000:

Seller Proceeds BridgeDeal A ($750K Flat)Deal B ($2.5M Flat)Deal B ($2.5M DL)
Headline Purchase Price$750,000$2,500,000$2,500,000
Less: Broker Commission-$75,000-$250,000-$210,000
Effective Commission Rate10.00%10.00%8.40%
Less: Seller Legal, CPA & Escrow-$15,000-$40,000-$40,000
Seller Net Proceeds (Pre-Debt/Tax)$660,000$2,210,000$2,250,000

In The Business Broker, Corvale Climate Services closes at $3,370,000 after a $130,000 quality-of-earnings re-trade. Under Thornbeck Business Advisors' Modified 10/8/6 schedule, the fee is $100,000 + $80,000 + (6% x $1,370,000 = $82,200) = $262,200 (7.78%), with $237,200 paid at closing after the $25,000 retainer credit. Under pure Double Lehman (4% above $3,000,000), the fee would be $254,800 (7.56%).

Model your own deal price and fee schedule in Excel

Compare 10% flat, Double Lehman, and Modified 10/8/6 with dynamic seller net proceeds and broker-split waterfalls.

Download Excel Calculator Explore The Business Broker →

3. Worked Example 2: Broker-Side Economics, Splits, and Close Rates

A 10% fee looks large until you trace brokerage economics. In Thornbeck Business Advisors' annual model from The Business Broker, an average Main Street closing sells for $520,000 and pays $52,000 gross. Two splits cut the listing broker's share immediately.

First, under a 50/50 co-brokering split, an outside buyer's broker takes $26,000. Second, the listing firm splits retained fees with the deal broker (Thornbeck pays 50% on Main Street deals and 40% on lower middle market deals). On an in-house $520,000 sale, the agent earns $26,000; on a co-brokered sale, $13,000.

Close rates compress hourly pay further. Thornbeck signs 24 engagements per year (18 Main Street, 6 lower middle market) and closes 50% (industry-wide Main Street close rates often run 20% to 35%). At 120 hours per closed listing and 60 sunk hours per expired listing, a 50% close rate means 180 hours per closing. That yields $144.44/hr in-house ($26,000 / 180) and $72.22/hr co-brokered ($13,000 / 180). Firm marketing, portals, and data rooms cost $84,000 a year across 24 listings ($3,500 per engagement, or $7,000 per closing).

Broker Waterfall ($520K Main Street Deal)In-HouseCo-Brokered (50/50)
Gross Commission (10% of $520,000)$52,000$52,000
Less: Co-Broker Split$0-$26,000
Listing Brokerage Revenue$52,000$26,000
Deal Broker Payout (50% House Split)$26,000$13,000
House Share (Before $7,000 Adj. Marketing)$26,000$13,000
Effective Broker Hourly Rate (180 Hours)$144.44/hr$72.22/hr

This explains why brokerages move upmarket. In Thornbeck's annual P&L, 9 Main Street closings generate $468,000, while 3 lower middle market closings (averaging $4,200,000 and $312,000 in fee) generate $936,000, or 66.7% of total revenue ($1,404,000) from one quarter of listings. After $608,400 in broker splits and $366,000 in overhead, firm profit before the managing broker's pay is $429,600. Corvale's $262,200 fee is 7.3 times the $36,000 fee on a $360,000 coffee shop taking roughly the same 8.4 months to close.

The trap: Seller-financed notes, earnouts, and real estate carve-outs often surprise owners at closing. Engagement agreements base commission on total consideration and treat seller notes as cash paid at closing. On Corvale, the seller carries a $180,000 SBA full-standby note with zero payments for 10 years, yet owes $10,800 in commission on that note (6% marginal rate) out of closing cash. Earnouts are safer: brokers typically collect their marginal fee ($21,000 per $350,000 installment) only when the buyer pays. If you own the building, verify whether real estate is excluded (leased to the buyer) or charged separately at 4% to 6% instead of 10%. For stock sales, confirm the broker qualifies under the SEC M&A Brokers exemption (15 U.S.C. 78o(b)(13)) or holds FINRA registration.

4. Frequently Asked Questions

What is the standard business broker commission rate?

Main Street brokers charge 10% flat under $1,000,000 with a $15,000 to $25,000 minimum floor. Between $1,000,000 and $5,000,000, brokers typically apply the Double Lehman scale (10/8/6/4/2), lowering the effective rate to 7.5% to 8.5%.

Who pays the business broker commission, the buyer or the seller?

The seller pays the commission from closing proceeds in nearly all Main Street and lower middle market deals. If an outside buyer's broker brings the buyer, the listing firm usually splits the seller-paid commission 50/50.

Do business brokers charge a commission on seller financing or earnouts?

Yes. Standard agreements include seller notes and earnouts in total consideration. Seller-note commissions are usually due at closing, while earnout commissions are paid only when each earnout installment clears.

Is a business broker commission paid on real estate included in the sale?

Real estate is normally carved out and charged a separate 4% to 6% commercial real estate fee if sold alongside the business. If the seller keeps the building and leases it to the buyer, no commission applies to the property.

5. Sources and Methodology

  1. IBBA & M&A Source, Market Pulse Survey methodology: Main Street ($0 to $2M) and Lower Middle Market ($2M to $50M) transaction benchmarks.
  2. U.S. Small Business Administration, SOP 50 10 8.1: 7(a) acquisition financing, 10% equity injection, full-standby seller notes, and variable rate caps.
  3. Securities Exchange Act of 1934, 15 U.S.C. 78o(b)(13) (M&A Brokers Exemption): federal broker-dealer exemption for qualifying private company transfers under $250M revenue or $25M EBITDA.

Read the complete playbook: The Business Broker

Follow a $3,370,000 HVAC sale and a $360,000 Main Street listing from add-backs and valuation to SBA 7(a) debt service, fees, and closing day. Includes the Excel workbook and broker checklists.

Buy DRM-Free PDF ($19.99) Apple Books Google Play